janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Heart wrenching as some hearts healed and some hearts broke. Some people broke hearts, some people healed hearts.

Manish's heart broke when he got to know that his wife hid about their child, lied to him that he was dead. He was angry and harsh and I would expect anything less from a person in his shoes. Misunderstandings had kept his one son away from him, and now he gets to know he has a second son who was kept hidden from him, he isn't surely going to hug her and say thank you, especially taking into consideration that it is Aryaan / Shubhum how told the truth, he would have said it like what he saw the conversations he heard.

Dadi has never been fully team Suvarna because Manish never seeked Dadi's permission for the marriage, at least that is what has been hinted earlier. Her words seemed full of anger and I didn't understand what selfish motive she thought Suvarna had in hiding about Aryan. Her words seemed not only breaking Suvarna's heart but Karthik's as well. Though am glad she was extra harsh as that added more point of views something I appreciate in yrkkh and Goenkas is that the family members show many different views and that too openly.

Suvarna's heart broke with Dadi's accusations and Manish asking her to go away. We have all seen the sweet love between Suvarna and Manish. Manish has always been her strength, the person to stand by her when other's didn't and today when that same man tell her to go away it is obviously shattering.

If they are people to break your hearts they are people to join it as well and that is what Karthik did. He stood up for Suvarna for the first time he fought from her side. He gave explanations from her side, though even then she still seemed numb. Finally getting some courage as his Sherni motions him to come closer, taking baby step and with a lot of hesitation Karthik drops near Suvarna, placing his head on her lap. Apologizing for never understanding and always blaming her. A mother had got her child and that healed her heart.

When you heal someone else they also heal you. When Karthik stood up Suvarna took him into a hug. 20 years later a child was hugged by someone he could call his mother, that 7-8 year old child who lost his mother had found something.

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

793

Users

3

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

kaira101 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Awesome post. Agreed with everything you pointed out. Manish's hurt and anger were justified. He was hurt beyond anything by the woman he knew that could never hurt him. He fought against his whole family when it came to supporting her. He stood by her knowing how much Kartik disliked her. And to come to this stage and find out that she hid such a big part of their life from him. He wont forget this easily.
Suwarna always believed that every action if hers was for the good of the family. She sacrificed her son for Kartik. Although that isnt justified but there seems to be more to it than its showed now. Her heart broke hearing the accusations said by dadi.

Dadi goenka was on a roll. Seemed like puraana bharaas nikal rahi thi. It was always shown that dadi would taunt suwarna regarding her wedding with Manish.

Kartik was broken himself knowing that the woman he detested all his life gave up her own child for him. Despite that he was the ultimate healer of suwarnas wounds. And with the silent support of his sherni he made the first move to rectify things. The best part of Kartiks character is that he always stands up for what ot right. And he is not afraid to accept right from wrong and in turn apologise. No male ego at all 👏
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: kaira101

Awesome post. Agreed with everything you pointed out. Manish's hurt and anger were justified. He was hurt beyond anything by the woman he knew that could never hurt him. He fought against his whole family when it came to supporting her. He stood by her knowing how much Kartik disliked her. And to come to this stage and find out that she hid such a big part of their life from him. He wont forget this easily.

Suwarna always believed that every action if hers was for the good of the family. She sacrificed her son for Kartik. Although that isnt justified but there seems to be more to it than its showed now. Her heart broke hearing the accusations said by dadi.

Dadi goenka was on a roll. Seemed like puraana bharaas nikal rahi thi. It was always shown that dadi would taunt suwarna regarding her wedding with Manish.

Kartik was broken himself knowing that the woman he detested all his life gave up her own child for him. Despite that he was the ultimate healer of suwarnas wounds. And with the silent support of his sherni he made the first move to rectify things. The best part of Kartiks character is that he always stands up for what ot right. And he is not afraid to accept right from wrong and in turn apologise. No male ego at all 👏

Everyone makes sense in their own place. Manish is hurt so he was angry. Karthik is guilty for always being against Suvarna and now he knows she behave away her son for him so he is on her side and Dadi never like Suvarna much so she saw a scheme in Suvarna's doing.
Yes till now Karthik has not been shown egostic and am thankful for that
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

When you heal someone else they also heal you. When Karthik stood up Suvarna took him into a hug. 20 years later a child was hugged by someone he could call his mother, that 7-8 year old child who lost his mother had found something.

Beautiful Post...That's so true...Swarna-Karthik healing each other was the best scenario in this entire track...Karthik healing the pain of a mother who had to sacrifice her son to keep her husband close to his son...who consider them responsible for his mother's death...won't the longing to be with his son be diminished with presence of other son? or maybe Karthik would have got closer to Suwarnish because of his brother...anything was possible...she was wrong...but not 100% wrong...she gave him to the known people...to the most trusted ones...though she was being unfair...but parents are sometimes unfair...that happens in real life too...her sacrifice can't be labelled right...she did what situation demanded...according to her point of view...but she was being verry unfair...Karthik finally got his mother back...the mother who gave up on her life...was found in the mother who gave away her life...for keeping that hope of uniting her husband with his son intact...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".