Broken Pieces Between Us-Kaira

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

Naira's entry with that glass shattering into million pieces was well executed scene...than Karthik started breaking objects around...Naira again in her form "wrong can be made right according to Naira she did right by getting them married as they can get better with time and she voiced it infront of Karthik...Karthik still considering all what happened "wrong" was even more hurt listening to Naira's words...Naira saw him this way breaking things here and there for the first time..right?...Karthik more than being angry was in guilt and pain...he couldn't do it Again he couldn't save his love one...his sister...any person would be this guilty and hurt knowing ur life partner didn't let u save ur sister's life, whereas on other side life-partner herself was clueless...Naira even asked him to clarify it...after all the accusations she also got equally angry...Wiped the tears and retorted "I f u hate me this much why I'm here? In my opinion that was the moment...she said it out of anger...I personally love Naira's fighter side...so I'm not at all disappointed with what she said...after that he also told "don't blackmail me go I also don't want to see ur face" that time she regretted what she said but was persistent at her stubborn best...another beautifully executed scene was their reflections visible in those broken pieces...Both Momo and Shivi's facial expressions were too good their acting was too effortless to be termed acting...After that when Karthik turned a little to see Naira ready to go back...ready to go out was well enacted scene...The expressions his eyes held were too deep..

Karthik and Naira with those broken pieces of glass were standing on opposite sides with opposing opinions being the stubborn ones at their individual best...the broken pieces reflected their broken trust ... Relationships of years are broken due to misunderstandings...here their relationship is intact its not broken its only having broken pieces between...that are needed to be thrown out or mend..I think mending those cracks is a better option...

While going back Naira's breakdown was too good...all she could remember were the most hurtful words...she wasn't normal yet wasn't complaining infront of everyone...anybody can sense something is wrong as she was too lost in the flashbacks of whatever happened...when again she saw Karthik in mood to do something to Naksh she lost it completely and voiced infront KD "I want to go" but Naira we know will never let her families involved in the matter between her and her Karthik that also when there was beginning of another relationship between two families when they can still sort it out themselves ...therefore she went with other reason...During Keerti's Bidaai she had flashbacks of her Bidaai and how Karthik composed her saying "u don't even need sign language to explain me what's in ur heart now what happened "where is that understanding now?...Shivi's portrayal of Naira breakdown and her emotional turmoil was excellent also all those scenes with family were good too...When Naira turned back she could see Karthik standing there...seeing her going...This time both of them are right in their opinion so them being Karthik and Naira the individuals who won't bend when they are right, they have always been at their stubborn best they have always been this beautiful character...now I understand why this separation phase will be longg one...The flawed Karthik and Naira are not having a fairytale love story...A beautiful, unique yet relatable story...Kaira LS and husband-wife relationship...will have another twist...another fight...due to a valid reason...better call it fight phase rather than separation phase...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

588

Users

3

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Beautiful post.

Yes I loved how both Karthik and Naira behaved. I loved that they are strong in their opinions, which is absolutely right.

Karthik has seen his sister suffer in a loveless marriage, he got to know that her second husband doesn't love her either and the fact that the man who she was going to get remarried to was someone he considered like a brother / friend / family. Plus him getting to know that his wife hid the truth and circumstances leading him to believe that she locked him in the room, any person would feel hurt, guilty, pained, angry.

For Naira, she herself had talked to Naksh, being his sister and knowing him, she believed in his assurance. She believed that them getting married was for their best interest. That's why she didn't understand Karthik's anger, especially not why it was directed towards her. That's why she got mad at him too, which is absolutely right in her views as well, she is a Sherni, she is not going to be silent, not with her mendak at least.

Then in the heat of the moment it slips from her that she should leave and in anger he too asks her leave him and go. You can see both regret and pain in their eyes, still he doesn't stop her not she stops herself, because for them, they each are right, and that normally is life, we always see things through our own views first and fail to understand things from another view point easily.

Yes their story is about to people who have differences and arguments, but come together at the end, as they understand each other's views and falling in love with one another even more.
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: janvi0513

Beautiful post.


Yes I loved how both Karthik and Naira behaved. I loved that they are strong in their opinions, which is absolutely right.

Karthik has seen his sister suffer in a loveless marriage, he got to know that her second husband doesn't love her either and the fact that the man who she was going to get remarried to was someone he considered like a brother / friend / family. Plus him getting to know that his wife hid the truth and circumstances leading him to believe that she locked him in the room, any person would feel hurt, guilty, pained, angry.

For Naira, she herself had talked to Naksh, being his sister and knowing him, she believed in his assurance. She believed that them getting married was for their best interest. That's why she didn't understand Karthik's anger, especially not why it was directed towards her. That's why she got mad at him too, which is absolutely right in her views as well, she is a Sherni, she is not going to be silent, not with her mendak at least.

Then in the heat of the moment it slips from her that she should leave and in anger he too asks her leave him and go. You can see both regret and pain in their eyes, still he doesn't stop her not she stops herself, because for them, they each are right, and that normally is life, we always see things through our own views first and fail to understand things from another view point easily.

Yes their story is about to people who have differences and arguments, but come together at the end, as they understand each other's views and falling in love with one another even more.


Here creatives did very good job in making both Karthik and Naira right in their own way...more than agree with @bold...this time mendak was sher though Naira considered him her mendak only...both sher and sherni were fighting more with their own selves...This time more than communication they need assurance...both Karthik and Naira's misunderstandings will be cleared with time...this type of misunderstanding require time...till than we will enjoy their dreams and longing to be with each other..
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom


Here creatives did very good job in making both Karthik and Naira right in their own way...more than agree with @bold...this time mendak was sher though Naira considered him her mendak only...both sher and sherni were fighting more with their own selves...This time more than communication they need assurance...both Karthik and Naira's misunderstandings will be cleared with time...this type of misunderstanding require time...till than we will enjoy their dreams and longing to be with each other..

Yes time, Naira will I guess cool down faster then Karthik, in yesterday episode itself she went from initially frustrated to heart broken, so she might try to find reason first. Karthik will most likely take a bit of time because of the way he is seeing thing at the moment, but slowly he will realize his part of the mistake.
Yes, till then we will enjoy their dreams and longing.
ShadowImbue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Karthik and Naira both were equally right and equally wrong. According to Karthik the loveless marriage can make it even worse which can be true, according to Naira its the better decision to get them married, they can work on their relationship which can also be true. Karthik was wrong in blaming Naira for betrayal, for differentiating between Naksh and Kirti and locking him whereas Naira was wrong in leaving him and considering that he hates her but than situation make them believe that, precisely they weren't at fault. Karthik's words make Naira believe that he doesn't trust her anymore, hate her and Naira's previous incidents and hiding truth from him make Karthik believe Naira locked him up and betrayed him.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

3 months ago

Kaira leap Promo

https://youtu.be/eTMVcI1Ss0M?feature=shared Hey, This is the Promo of 5 year leap happened in Yrkkh Generation 2. Naira was in Goa with Kairav....

https://youtu.be/eTMVcI1Ss0M?feature=shared
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

6 months ago

Kaira Aniversary+ Seerat Birthday

Do you remember guys: They never mentioned exact date but two times as far as I remember,First on Valentine's day when It was Seerat's boxing...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".