Comment your views on today's episode 15/9/17

Zara151 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Rate the episode out of 10 and comment the reason why you have rated that number.

My rating: 10/10

My views: I rate 10 because of the outstanding performance by our beloved Mohsin himself and of course Shivangi 👏

What I liked about the whole episode is that despite Kartik falling on his knees, becoming vulnerable, heartbroken and in pain that learning the whole truth, you have this guilt inside that starts to eat you up. I started to cry seeing Kartik throwing everything on the floor and Naira coming to console him. Oh Kartik I feel for you so much, the truth that you want to know so much and no-one is letting you know the exact truth 😭😭 Naira is the pillar, and the strength that Kartik needs. He is lucky because he has his sherni by his side to support him and console his weak side. I liked dadi today because she knows that Kartik is an adult now and will understand the truth. Not just that, he and Kirti has the right to know the whole truth.

Kartik reading the letter was the hardest part because we know that he would break down but if he did, Naira is there to console and calm him down. Manish was great today because he's getting back his son and also I too felt that he did the right thing by not telling him the truth because that's one of the hardest to share.

Sad moments: Both the siblings hugging out and letting the pain out because they just got to know the whole truth. Keerti you were great today 👏

Overall: No words to describe further on the pain Kartik endured and went through at the end of the episode. Poor boy feels guilty 😭😭😭
Great performance from Mohsin, Shivangi and everyone 👏👏👏👏

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.2k

Users

9

Likes

37

Frequent Posters

janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
10/10 extremely wonderful episode. Every moment was just perfect.

From Karthik asking for the reason of his mother's suicide to Manish, then pleading for an answer from everyone else, everyone feeling bad for him, following by Karthik breaking down and Naira holding him.

The family going up to Manish. Dadi making him realize that he needs to open the truth now.

Karthik finally getting to know it the realization hitting him hard, him breaking down and Naira holding him once again.

One of my most favorite non-kaira moments in the episodes. When Karthik notices that Kirti is about to break, he himself gets up despite being broken and holds his sister, then Kirti also gets a grip on herself and wipes her brother's tears.

Karthik's guilt as he remembers his own words and Naira looking on giving him time to himself.

Suvarna Manish scene in the room. I really love these two, they make a great couple. Manish feeling bad for behaving badly. Suvarna asking him to decide what he would say to his son. Manish excitement hearing that Karthik would talk to him.

The Naira Suvarna scene, both talk about Karthik Manish. Both wanting their husband's to get the happiness which they have been away from 20 years.

My only disappointment is I think just to keep a promise to a person who had already passed away, he ended up hurting a lot of alive people, along with himself for 20 whole years. I know sharing the truth would have been difficult but I think hiding it was more painful. Plus they haven't cleared the reason for Suvarna and Manish marriage that too without dadi's permission, I really hope they plan to address this issue and do not forget about it.

Everyone's performance brilliant and Momo was simply outstanding. I can't wait for Monday.
sigrid thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
⭐️👏
10/10...an emotional and well executed episode...where Shivin shined.
Today's Episode was mind blowing...it was so gripping, u could not blink your eye.

WOW!!!!! what a performances by Momo as Karthik...literally seeing him so heart broken, tears just rolled down my eyes...
It was well executed episode, where you could connect with the pain and grief of Karthik.
Naira, was there as his shadow and support. She was a perfect wife
The hug which she gave him to calm him..and his anger...WOW!!! That was the highlight. Their togetherness..throughout the episode.
We could see how Karthik's life went 180 degree...his guilt...pain..
OMG, the scene bwtween the siblings...Karthik and Kirti, so painful and emotional.
Loved, how they showed Swarna and Naira working together...
Both father and son want to be there but still there is hesitancy.
CVS take a bow..episode was handled so beautifully and in a sensitive manner.
It was power packed performances by Kathik/Mohsin and Naira/Shvigani
Parul was good...and Moehna too.



Kaira/Shivin⭐️
Edited by sigrid - 7 years ago
vellainsaan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
It was a very good episode!
From Kartik's pleading for answers to Manish's determination for keeping the promise he gave to his dying wife.. to family members supporting Manish.. to Naira.. for just being there for her husband when he needed her.

The heart broken siblings.. father's longing.. son's guilt.. Swarna's support for her husband..

It was an emotional roller coaster...

Of course the best moment of the day was.. Kartik's breakdown and Naira holding him. Just being them.

I know today belonged to Momo.. but Sachin Tyagi is an amazing actor. And Shivi looked so god damn pretty.. she looks so serene with minimal makeup and simple pretty clothes.
Zara151 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: vellainsaan

It was a very good episode!

From Kartik's pleading for answers to Manish's determination for keeping the promise he gave to his dying wife.. to family members supporting Manish.. to Naira.. for just being there for her husband when he needed her.

The heart broken siblings.. father's longing.. son's guilt.. Swarna's support for her husband..

It was an emotional roller coaster...

Of course the best moment of the day was.. Kartik's breakdown and Naira holding him. Just being them.

I know today belonged to Momo.. but Sachin Tyagi is an amazing actor. And Shivi looked so god damn pretty.. she looks so serene with minimal makeup and simple pretty clothes.

I agree, it was an emotional rollercoaster to go through. And about Shivi's makeup and outfit, oh daaamm...she looked so beautiful no doubt. She's naturally beautiful, just made for Momo
Edited by Zara151 - 7 years ago
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
the episode was good... but i still want to know how/why manish married suwarna... like kartiks mom said in the letter she suspected manish of having an affair with his secretary and then after she does die manish ends up marrying the secretary (suwarna)... i hope this part also gets cleared out
beatsdongandy thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
epi was too good.momo was brilliant yesterday.that letter scene was truely heart wrenching.i loved how yrkkh once again showed what it takes to b parents,how much sacrifices,pain a father n mother goes through to b a parent..best thing about the whole track is naira's charc growth..best written charc in this track.i m so happy kpapa n naira said sorry to swarna coz she deserves it..i dont think thr ll b any swarna kartik patch up this time..infact we r going to know the reason of manish marrying swarna when her son's mystery ll come out.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Excellent episode on all counts
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
10/10 Best episode...Entire episode belonged to Goenkas specifically Karthik...the way complete story was presented...hats off CVs and actors for enacting all those scenes...

1. Liked KD's initiative to make Manish understand that truth can't be hidden now and if Soumya's knew the outcome she won't have restrain Manish by that promise...Liked the way they all decided it together to give Karthik that letter...

2. Loved the way Soumya's letter had all the details and the flashback scenes were very impactful...Mental illness is still considered a taboo and mental patients are not given proper therapy or treatment even if given treatment few psychological disorders are incurable...Soumya didn't want to harm people around her and didn't want to embarrass her children...but suicide is a big no no ...her children specifically Karthik had very bad impact of her committing suicide...one suicide kills happiness and peace of several people... the way Karthik's peace was taken away...

3. Karthik's realization...all his accusations and bitter words to Manish were suffocating him...Momo was exceptionally brilliant in that scene...most lovable scene for me was flashback scene "papa kehtey hain bara naam karey ga" Manish sang that song in drunk state because Karthik use to sing it...how happy they were as a family...

3. Naira was the first one to hold Karthik to pacify him...To absorb his pain...loved it...

4. Karthik-Keerti scene was beautiful for the first time liked Keerti's character firstly for firmly inquiring about her mother from her father and than for wiping off Karthik's tears like a protective elder sister...

5. Like that Naira actually considered Suwarna wrong...Another mistake committed by unconventional character Naira also liked that she apologized later on...



Again thank you CVs...a very well handled track...👏 👏 👏
-beena- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
My Rating 10/10

I liked that Kartik's dadi didn't start her blames again but instead made Manish understand that time had come for the truth to be revealed.

The part of Kartik reading the letter, his realization,the flashbacks...everything was perfectly portrayed.I liked the fact that the scene of Manish singing the song was included in the flashbacks.The background song was apt for the situation.

Kirti-Kartik scene was awesome.So perfectly portrayed...

Suvarna-Manish scene was nice.Manish feeling guilty and apologizing to Suvarana who consoles and encourages him.Liked how she assured him that everything would be alright.Perfect dialogues.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

4 months ago

Charu said the right thing today

What Charu said to Abhir today was absolutely right. When he is hiding the fact that he is having an affair behind Kiara's back then what is the...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

13 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai August 26, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

🗣 Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread! 🗣 Make sure to...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

27 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai August 12, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

Story Development - Zama Habib, Ghanshyam Bhatt Story Writers/Dialogue: Vaishali Nayak/ Divya Nidhi Sharma and Pankhuri Gangwal/Aparajita Sharma...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

1 months ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai August 5, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

Story Development - Zama Habib, Ghanshyam Bhatt Story Writers/Dialogue: Vaishali Nayak/ Divya Nidhi Sharma and Pankhuri Gangwal/Aparajita Sharma...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

1 months ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai July 29, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

🗣 Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread! 🗣 Make sure to...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".