Heart bleds but it still hopes.

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Gagori Chatterjee

@jyoti06

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 8 years ago

#11

Wonderful take dear .. Just loved the way u r writing about both the POVs .. Its easy to blame the culprit and sympathise with the victim but equally difficult to try to understand the psychology of the culprit and the reason behind why she did what she did ..

Also I m one of the few who is really enjoying this track as its bringing out the best from the actors and also the best part about the track is that we hv almost 15 mins dedicated to HaYa and just 2 mins of Preeto and co 😆 .. No wonder even trps hv rised and I saw on twitter , so many old members who left watching the show hv come back because of this track .. So definitely something is right about this track ..

Coming to yesterday episode , We all noticed how rudely Soumya spoke to Harman but we dint notice after he left , she confessed how much she loves him and will keep loving him all her life ..I think this is the first time she actually confessed that she loves him .. earlier she used to b in denial about love .. but yesterday she directly said she loves Harman after he left ..

Today she rudely told on Harman's face she does not love him .. But this is a open loop in terms of story telling because tomorrow when she will realise her mistake and redeem herself , she will complete the same loop by confessing her love to him .. Every track has a start and a finish .. If this track started with Soumya misunderstanding Harman , then it will end with Soumya realising her mistake and going through a redemption phase too .. thats what u call story telling .. If we always expect both to b forever understanding , then there will b no story ..

And I prefer Soumya misundertanding Harman anyday over Harman misunderstanding Soumya simply because if the later happens then it gives a moral victory to Preeto .,.. But yesterday when I saw those 2 mins of Preeto sitting like a looser as her son has crossed all limits of madness in love , I felt sadistic pleasure seeing that defeat in her eyes .. and this is where I m loving the track ..

In future I do expect Harman to b angry on Soumya after the misunderstanding clears and then Soumya making all the efforts to convince him ... I will enjoy that as much as I m enjoying this track ..

Quote

Shonal8

@Shonal8

Explorer

Posted: 8 years ago

#12

I don't think we know the TRPs of this track yet. Last thursdays one was based on the previous weeks one which was good. tRP was high even the week of the trio marriage track. It was around 3. Some viewers will like this track and some won't. That is fine. There is no right or wrong about it. I am finding it too painful to watch and am avoiding it. Transformation of Soumya, Haya track, spice, intensity, I wanted it alll but not in this way.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Gagori Chatterjee

@jyoti06

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 8 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: Shonal8
I don't think we know the TRPs of this track yet. Last thursdays one was based on the previous weeks one which was good. tRP was high even the week of the trio marriage track. It was around 3. Some viewers will like this track and some won't. That is fine. There is no right or wrong about it. I am finding it too painful to watch and am avoiding it. Transformation of Soumya, Haya track, spice, intensity, I wanted it alll but not in this way.

If trps dont rise .. they will shift back to Preeto drama again .. same old key giving drama 🥱 .. so if given a choice I will anyday opt for this track over the key giving drama because I know this track will b followed by Soumya's redemption track .. at least I can see my favourite actors perform here than just siting mutely with Preeto alone dominating the scene ..

Quote

Shonal8

@Shonal8

Explorer

Posted: 8 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: jyoti06

If trps dont rise .. they will shift back to Preeto drama again .. same old key giving drama 🥱 .. so if given a choice I will anyday opt for this track over the key giving drama because I know this track will b followed by Soumya's redemption track .. at least I can see my favourite actors perform here than just siting mutely with Preeto alone dominating the scene ..

I think we are all united on that front. No one wants to see Preeto dominating the episode, hate it or Shannos jewellery or Raavi's caricature, or Veeran Uncles poor attempt of trying to be a villain. We want Vivian and Rubina to get the maximum screen space with interesting logical tracks. At the moment although Rubi and Vivian are acting really well I cannot tolerate the expressions that Tarana is throwing at Harman. The dialogues are painful and unreasonable too.

To me this is equally unbearable as is Preetos screen dominance. So makers pl keep Haya track and make it reasonable and balanced even if it is showing misunderstandings. don't take it to the extreme and make it nasty. Don't destroy lead characters and make them unlikeable. Keep them dignified even in anger. Let the anger be justified.

Quote

sairitu

@sairitu

Inactive

Posted: 8 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: Shonal8
Absolutely agree Sairitu. My mum is also calling Saumya an idiot not influenced by me at all. We wanted Haya track but not through lack of logic and humiliation of Harman by Saumya unreasonably. We want Good Haya track not this nonsense. In my opinion this is no better than the kitchen politics or the trio marriage. Saumya pours buckets of sweetness to the wrong people and kicks Harman brainlessly.

Just saw today's segment ,again she gave another kasam for harman to leave her despite him asking her to give sometime to explain.so thankless and unkind of her.In that promo,her dialogue of " lost faith on love" pissed me off.If she doesnt trust harman 's love,then there is no love in the world. i am really scared now,what will she do in bangkok now? Poor harman .He is the best main lead character i have ever seen on indian TV ,a flawless person.

Quote

soul76

@soul76

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Shonal8

I think we are all united on that front. No one wants to see Preeto dominating the episode, hate it or Shannos jewellery or Raavi's caricature, or Veeran Uncles poor attempt of trying to be a villain. We want Vivian and Rubina to get the maximum screen space with interesting logical tracks. At the moment although Rubi and Vivian are acting really well I cannot tolerate the expressions that Tarana is throwing at Harman. The dialogues are painful and unreasonable too.
To me this is equally unbearable as is Preetos screen dominance. So makers pl keep Haya track and make it reasonable and balanced even if it is showing misunderstandings. don't take it to the extreme and make it nasty. Don't destroy lead characters and make them unlikeable. Keep them dignified even in anger. Let the anger be justified.

I really wish the anger here was justified which it is not. Soumya doesn't deserve Harman, period. I don't say this because of her gender status but because she had failed him time and again. All he ever wanted from her was an assurity of her love which she never gave him. If she is unsure of herself then why be in a relationship, why use him as protection time and again. She's better off in her own community, romancing new men. Harman needs to leave her.

Quote

Gagori Chatterjee

@jyoti06

Alumni

+ 8

Posted: 8 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Shonal8

I think we are all united on that front. No one wants to see Preeto dominating the episode, hate it or Shannos jewellery or Raavi's caricature, or Veeran Uncles poor attempt of trying to be a villain. We want Vivian and Rubina to get the maximum screen space with interesting logical tracks. At the moment although Rubi and Vivian are acting really well I cannot tolerate the expressions that Tarana is throwing at Harman. The dialogues are painful and unreasonable too.
To me this is equally unbearable as is Preetos screen dominance. So makers pl keep Haya track and make it reasonable and balanced even if it is showing misunderstandings. don't take it to the extreme and make it nasty. Don't destroy lead characters and make them unlikeable. Keep them dignified even in anger. Let the anger be justified.

Lets just say the more rudely she behaves with him , it will leave more impact when she will regret , redeem and apologise to him .. Impact becomes less if the misunderstanding or separation does not really get the extreme reaction from us viewers .. fact that it is indeed getting that extreme reaction from viewers will leave a bigger impact when she will realise her mistake and make efforts to manaofy him as that time it will b role reversal ..

If the anger is shown in a dignified way then we wont really feel anything when the misunderstanding ends .. climax of any track looks good and leaves a lasting impact when the track is taken to its extreme limit .. thats what the CVs r doing .. They r obviously not expecting the viewers to shower praises on Soumya at this moment .. so they r getting the exact reaction from audience that they r expecting from this track .. Most of us r sympathising with Harman and hating Soumya .. thats exactly what the track is all about .. If we dont feel sorry for Harman or if we dont really hate Soumya then the purpose of the track actually fails and then we wont feel anything during their reunion either ... Its like every action has equal and opposite reaction 😆

Also in any misunderstanding , one party will always look wrong and one will look right .. otherwise the misunderstanding track does not really serve the purpose at all .. Today if Soumya dont say those rude words to Harman , then tomorrow the depth of her apology or love confession or her regret wont leave an impact either ..

Mayb some dialogues could hv been toned down but otherwise I feel the rudness from her side is necessary for building up the main climax and the next track ..

Quote

1 2

Heart bleds but it still hopes. - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics