The case of the missing logic

Logical-Indian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
How illogical was today's episode? There were so many mind numbingly stupid moments today

- Maya just decides she has suffered a miscarriage and her bumbling idiot of a husband just believes it?? No doctor, no tests, nothing to confirm if her assumption is true? 🤪

- Assuming Arjun believes Maya when she says she suffered a miscarriage should'nt his first instinct still be to take her to a doc to confirm that she is ok?? Instead he lets her go on a hike with the heavy Ganesh idol?? 👏😳

- Arjun had no idea what Saanjh and Maya were talking about. For all he knew they were chit chatting and Saanjh was just trying to get Maya along to dance and she slipped and fell. It could have been an unintentional accident (which it was). Why did Arjun react and talk about "gandi zubaan" etc and banish Saanjh from his life like she did it on purpose?? I get that he was upset, but his reaction made it seem like he thought Saanjh did it on purpose, which is weird coz as far as he is concerned Sa-Maya were on good terms. 😕

- Saanjh goes and tells Maya that her mother has seen her and Arjun dance many times before but never had an issue with it so why should she have an issue now-- HUH?? Did she forget the teeny tiny detail that now Arjun is married to someone else and that the boundaries change when that happens. 😔

- Instead of talking to Saanjh about the inappropriateness of her behavior with Arjun why was Suman doing Maya "Jai Jai kar"?? I mean she was going on about "Maya kitni achi hai..." instead of actually talking about the main issue. 🤪

- ONCE AGAIN we have an apshagun (the diya falling) to indicate the Ar-Sa friendship break - Can we PLEASE stop with that already!!! I am so done with the show's excessive use of bad omen..Sheesh!!

- Arjun was never shown to believe in God. So then why did they make it seem like he lost his faith in God only NOW?? 😕

- What was with the whole Ganpati visarjan thing that Maya did?? Why did she think God also needed to be removed from between them?? what did poor God do?😕 - That whole bit made zero sense to me. Maya was always shown to be God fearing and always spoke about how only God is her friend and has supported her. Why does she suddenly feel the need to elimiate God from her life? This honestly felt like the CVs wanted to do something dramatic to show Maya's decent into darkness but they failed miserably in justifying it.🤢

The writing was such a letdown today (It is most of the days)

CVs PLease Please think through your story lines and scenes before executing them. I am not sure what to expect from the next phase seeing how they've handled the last one.

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Likes

42

Frequent Posters

roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I was only upset with Gani's idol being immersed in the water. You're right. What did poor Gani Bappa do that Maya removed him from Arjun's life 😭
Fawad321 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Someone commented on YT writers were smoking weed when they wrote today's episode😆 So many plot holes.
MrsAkyurek thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Great post! This show's promos are 1000x (not exaggerating) better than the actual episodes. It's been the same since the beginning!
Staging a miscarriage to separate friends ( saw a picture where Maya gives a creepy triumphant smile after hugging Arjun) is shameful in itself, but if the miscarriage was real (let's keep aside the medical science, PTSD, and suspend our disbelief), it's the most heartless thing to do even for someone like Maya. Killing you own child, alienating everyone from Arjun's life just to have him all for yourself?

But a few things also don't make sense. . If Maya had faked her pregnancy just only to set Saanjh up, why did she announce it way before any of the unreasonable Saanjh-Arjun interactions begin to happen? How did Maya anticipate Saanjh's outburst to occur out in the open for her to improvise on the spot to enact her drama? Or was it a mere accident, where Saanjh was at the wrong place at the wrong time, and hence the blame fell on her unfortunately?


anjaanichudi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Agree with u, it was an illogical epi... it was as if dy r in a rush... 3 epis ek mein bata diya.
I was very disappointed with d Ganesh Visarjan. There was a dialogue of Maya before that where she says God did not support her. I think dtz d reason for Ganesh visarjan... if she did dt for Arjun, dn it was her biggest mistake.
1004467 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Very well written. I agree with your post completely. Writers really think that audience is fool to accept any illogical stunts thrown at them in a flurry 😉
Seriously is miscarriage a joke? Why would they treat such medical emergency such callously 😲?

Seems like the director and writer of the show got intoxicated during Holi celebration along with Arjun-Saanjh 😆
haritha45 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sweetshruti

How illogical was today's episode? There were so many mind numbingly stupid moments today

- Maya just decides she has suffered a miscarriage and her bumbling idiot of a husband just believes it?? No doctor, no tests, nothing to confirm if her assumption is true? 🤪

- Assuming Arjun believes Maya when she says she suffered a miscarriage should'nt his first instinct still be to take her to a doc to confirm that she is ok?? Instead he lets her go on a hike with the heavy Ganesh idol?? 👏😳

- Arjun had no idea what Saanjh and Maya were talking about. For all he knew they were chit chatting and Saanjh was just trying to get Maya along to dance and she slipped and fell. It could have been an unintentional accident (which it was). Why did Arjun react and talk about "gandi zubaan" etc and banish Saanjh from his life like she did it on purpose?? I get that he was upset, but his reaction made it seem like he thought Saanjh did it on purpose, which is weird coz as far as he is concerned Sa-Maya were on good terms. 😕

- Saanjh goes and tells Maya that her mother has seen her and Arjun dance many times before but never had an issue with it so why should she have an issue now-- HUH?? Did she forget the teeny tiny detail that now Arjun is married to someone else and that the boundaries change when that happens. 😔

- Instead of talking to Saanjh about the inappropriateness of her behavior with Arjun why was Suman doing Maya "Jai Jai kar"?? I mean she was going on about "Maya kitni achi hai..." instead of actually talking about the main issue. 🤪

- ONCE AGAIN we have an apshagun (the diya falling) to indicate the Ar-Sa friendship break - Can we PLEASE stop with that already!!! I am so done with the show's excessive use of bad omen..Sheesh!!

- Arjun was never shown to believe in God. So then why did they make it seem like he lost his faith in God only NOW?? 😕

- What was with the whole Ganpati visarjan thing that Maya did?? Why did she think God also needed to be removed from between them?? what did poor God do?😕 - That whole bit made zero sense to me. Maya was always shown to be God fearing and always spoke about how only God is her friend and has supported her. Why does she suddenly feel the need to elimiate God from her life? This honestly felt like the CVs wanted to do something dramatic to show Maya's decent into darkness but they failed miserably in justifying it.🤢

The writing was such a letdown today (It is most of the days)

CVs PLease Please think through your story lines and scenes before executing them. I am not sure what to expect from the next phase seeing how they've handled the last one.

Agree with all ur points saanjh is irritating arjun is impulsive n maya will loose her happiness along with ganapatiji
JOY2529 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: roni_berna

I was only upset with Gani's idol being immersed in the water. You're right. What did poor Gani Bappa do that Maya removed him from Arjun's life 😭


may be she is feeling that he made her fell in love with that immature and cheater arjun.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".