Humari adhuri kahaani

Humaari adhuri kahaani

After watching today's episode I feel the makers of the show like it when the leads are pitted against each other and a fandom splits. The same is the case for her other show.

Today in the forum I am seeing the fandom split between those who are for Vividha, those who are for Atharv.

Mostly we watch shows for the lead. We join their names because they become one and we love them both. And we did the same with Vitharv and here we are today- torn between which path to choose- and perhaps I will never forgive the makers for this but if you go to see, we are still faced with real situations so is it fair to pinpoint who is right and who is wrong.

Atharv:
Today's episode made me realise that things have changed a lot for Atharv but he can see a change in Vividha's eyes- it's like he is searching and searching for his love in her eyes but he can't see it. She has hesitated way too many times. And he has missed way too much. He wasn't there to see Ravish and her bond form but one can't overlook the fact that they were married-she said she only ever thought of Atharv and that's right but it's clear that she cares for Ravish and fair enough he did a lot for Vividha but is she looking at him in the way she once looked at Atharv? Is she only with Atharv because that's all she has known all her life? Atharv therefore has every right to clear this doubt because she has changed. Her equation with him has changed. Her equation with Ravish has changed also.

Vividha:
Ever since she has known what love is, she has only loved Atharv. There is no question of loving anyone else but sometimes you do things due to habit and because it feels like this is the right thing to do. When the synergy around us is right, we don't want to change that.

Perhaps Vividha can't see through her feelings for Ravish because besides loving Atharv, she knows nothing else. To even bring anyone else close to her feelings for Atharv would be like committing a sin...like she is cheating on him but is Vividha unknowingly falling for Ravish? If she isn't then why is she not able to exert the same right on him as she used to. By now our sherni Vividha would've grabbed Atharv by the hand, dragged him to the room and kissed him so hard just so she can prove to him that she is only his. But this Vividha does none of that, she is simply just going with the flow now.

Ravish:
Today for once he was likeable. What he said to Atharv made total sense. What he told the media was applaud worthy. He can see it clearly that Vividha loves Atharv or is he so convinced because that was his duty to fulfill all along.

And I like the bonding of Ravish and Atharv. Both mature and both share good chemistry. Both Vikku and Shashank are really good actors and this can clearly be seen in the scene they had together and you can see that a few days together and they would have an amazing bond!

Today again we are faced with the question that who does Vividha love and the makers have played with our heads and emotions well because right now, I actually don't know.

I ship Vitharv and for me there is no other way out so if makers have another plan up their sleeve then that will be the end for me because this show is about Vitharv. These are just hurdles and they will come out of all this even stronger.

Atharv needs peace of mind because he doesn't want to be his dad so one can't blame him. Vividha needs to just get out of this guilt because until her guilt is with her, she won't be able to love Atharv with all her heart.

All three are entangled into each other and sadly one will come out hurt.

What a heavy episode. My head and heart actually hurts.

Kat

quite a detailed summary there 😊

And just to further your point of fandoms and splits, even though it can piss people off at times, we have to remember the words of Vikram himself from his latest interview:

"If there is no triangle and it's only Atharv and Vividha, there will be no more story left, there needs to be some sort of drama to spice things up, and the makers are trying to ensure every type of fangroup gets to have what they want to see."

Just gotta power through and see where this journey goes I guess!

With all due respect Kat you're pretty much doing what others are failing to do too i.e. Listening to what Vividha really wants which is Atharv!

If she had feelings for Ravish, she would question herself right? Instead others are questioning her. She is a very very compassionate individual! It's just a shame that just because she is doing something for her ex-husband it's construed as something else.

For her, she's so sorted in the head but what hurts her is that everyone especially Atharv won't accept that she loves Atharv only.

It's as simple as that but every show needs drama.

The whole point of the current track isn't to show any confusion for Vividha, it's to show Atharv's insecurity! That's what they're playing at and at the same time trying to create a brothers bond which frankly I fail to genuinely see.

If Vividha wanted to fall for someone else, nothing would stop her because she will do what she WANTS! She's not a sacrificial lamb and nor would Atharv make her feel bad about it.

Honestly I am not falling for the triangle! I have no doubts regarding Vividha's love or her choice! But my problem right now is the writing and slowly taking away from Vitharv the very thing that stands out about them even if it is temporarily! I think phase 1 has set such high standards in terms of everything that anything less than that seems mediocre. The actors themselves are making fun of the tracks that it self says a lot about the current state of this show! I can't relate to both Vividha & Atharv in some of the things that they are doing in the present which is why I am waiting for that break down from both!

kat.. as a newbie at JNDSD... I chose to watch the show because I saw Atharv and VIvidha.. and the pair spoke volumesto me.. now that Ravish ispart of the story..I see the three as a super trio! three main leads as I see them . I feel both as actors and in role they compliment each other. However as it was Atharv and Vividha I warmed to first,I see it as their love story.Ravish I wish to see as a strong positive factor that will unite them.. thanks for a thoought provoking post..love hammie

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

With all due respect Kat you're pretty much doing what others are failing to do too i.e. Listening to what Vividha really wants which is Atharv!

If she had feelings for Ravish, she would question herself right? Instead others are questioning her. She is a very very compassionate individual! It's just a shame that just because she is doing something for her ex-husband it's construed as something else.

For her, she's so sorted in the head but what hurts her is that everyone especially Atharv won't accept that she loves Atharv only.

It's as simple as that but every show needs drama.

The whole point of the current track isn't to show any confusion for Vividha, it's to show Atharv's insecurity! That's what they're playing at and at the same time trying to create a brothers bond which frankly I fail to genuinely see.

If Vividha wanted to fall for someone else, nothing would stop her because she will do what she WANTS! She's not a sacrificial lamb and nor would Atharv make her feel bad about it.

Reemz, aside from the letter which she hadn't written...Atharv's 'allegations' so have you call it are based on what he is seeing. This very Atharv would never have doubted Vividha regardless of what he saw, he would've confronted her but these two are connected from their souls. My point is why can't Atharv see his love in her eyes? Usually that's enough but having said that, he has refused to even look into her eyes, perhaps scared of what he may see.

We all know Viv loves him but in the situations they have been post his recovery, they still haven't had a proper moment.

Originally posted by: Hamlet53

kat.. as a newbie at JNDSD... I chose to watch the show because I saw Atharv and VIvidha.. and the pair spoke volumesto me.. now that Ravish ispart of the story..I see the three as a super trio! three main leads as I see them . I feel both as actors and in role they compliment each other. However as it was Atharv and Vividha I warmed to first,I see it as their love story.Ravish I wish to see as a strong positive factor that will unite them.. thanks for a thoought provoking post..love hammie

Totally agree for me it is simply that Ravish re unites them. Frankly I don't honk as of now what Vividha says to Atharv will make a difference. He is pretty set in his mind and someone does need to do something drastic to make him realise...but it shudnt have come to this but I guess it's a show and drama will be there.