is Ravish's guess right???

srilatha1 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
so guys Mr. Ravish Vashist had this doubt... is Atharv pretending? coz otherwise he will have to leave Vividha?
this was bothering me ever since the terrorist track ended and Atharv comes out of coma. the first word he spells is "Vividha". the next scene we see is Atharv in the temple and vividha hugging him. what happens in between? how come he land exactly at the place where vividha was praying? what did sujatha speak to him after his waking out of coma? no one knows.

so my answer for Ravish's question is partly correct and partly not. yes! Atharv is normal now. but no! not because he has to go away from vividha because she is now married.

there has been a long discussions about vividha retaining her MS still. if we recall the episode where vitharv truth is revealed to Ravish, he asks her to remove her MS, even then vividha is hesitant of removing it and Ravish does that. but she wears back saying that she will perform all the duties of a bahu. but even after the revelation in front of suman & whole family she still holds it back. when in a bid to bring Atharv's memory back Ravish asks vividha to get back to her old self, and asking her to remove it, she instead hides it.

i know, my above three paras has three different points irrelevant to each other. but when i join them in a series, once out of coma, Atharv sees Vividha declaring her love for him, but finds her still not strong enough to come out of that marriage, even after the will of RK was read in open. now i feel that Atharv is pretending it coz he want her to come out of this marriage all by herself.

OR

he realised what all happened during his mental illness and how Ravish had stood for him and his mother. however, he is not the kind of the man who would believe in sacrifices. but, in the 6th vachan he asks vividha to move on in life in case of any untoward incident. now that he has seen them both married, he want her to move on. also, he has seen how much Ravish loves her.

i also feel that sujatha is also team with him. that's why she asks vividha to choose and assures suman of vividha being her bahu.

this is the reason atharv is pretending illness and pushing vividha either this side or that side.


Edited by srilatha1 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.4k

Users

17

Likes

86

Frequent Posters

Africanqueenkel thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Between your two reasons or theories if I was forced , on a plank in a pirate ship with sharks waiting under , at gun point and considering the fact that I can't swim...

As the above situation is the only time I will even consider said options I will pick option 1 , why ??

Well because from your explanation or stance , atharva is giving vv a choice , he is not making her take it off , he is letting her decide when and how to take it off without him , always saving her ... That is who atharva is ... " I can't live your life for you "

Option two is a big fat NO... For very obvious reasons . But to name one " vv refused the Vachan"

But since am not in any situation ...

I will still stand by the fact that yes your questions in the beginning were important and do bring in some thoughts ...


I still say NO ... Yes atharva wanted to empower vv to make her own choices , yes he let her decide and yes he told her your choices are yours alone , and no one can stop you from getting what you want , and yes he made that vachan , and he wouldn't come in the way of vv's happiness ...

But there is a flaw , atharva sujata , was no liar , he didn't pretend , this man was truthful to a fault , he valued women and their opinion and providing vv with half truths as a sure as taking away her choice , because it means she did have a choice in the first place ...

Atharva sujata , believed in liberty and am not sure will be instituting a forced marriage ... Vv told him , no not even death can come between us during the 6th vachan and am sure the atharva I know values her opinions and thoughts enough to know that vv knows what she wants ...

Plain and to the point the atharva sujata I know believes in clarity and openness and for this reason I can't even contemplate anything that involves him being sneaky ...


I just CAN'T ...

🤗 sri ... I believe this is your first long post I have read ...
933191 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Btw even I was wondering the same is this your first long post Sri?
I agree with Kells though, Atharv Sujatha simply does not work this way, he is the same guy who asked Vividha to admit her love in the open otherwise it's of no use but if at all I have to pick one from the two theories then I would pick the first one.
monu_tan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
I hope the first one is right Sri. Atharv moght hsve come out of coma and would have seen Vv, suman and everything that transpired in the temple. He maybe on observation mode coz now his expressions change as soon as he sees ravish. This was not there before. So maybe you are right, he might have seen a confused Vv and may have hiven her the choice.
I think the next few episodes will shed more light on this.

Another thought, do u think KK aldo has a part in this? Like Atharv might have sensed him .
sweetygirl28 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
If he wants to sacrifice y will he ask vividha to put him to sleep? No Sri too many contradictions there.
Sujata assuring suman but in ajmer she seems supportive of vitharv.


If at all he is back . Then he is after the first vachan revisit.

But I now believe he is still not back.
dreamer.ankita thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Hey Sri,
For me, no amount of reasoning can ever convince me to believe that Atharv is pretending!!
The Atharv Sujata we all know will never fake an illness for any reason!
He has always faced every situation head on! He will not let his loved cry over him!

As far as sacrificing his love is concerned, he know vivi only loves him and is still waiting for him.. so there's no point of sacrifice coz for him Vivdha's choice is the first and foremost priority, n he will not decide anything on his own!
13thwish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
I'm sorry Sri, but I'm going to have to vehemently disagree with your post. Here's why:

1) Unlike the audience or any regular person, to Vividha, the mangalsutra is not representative of her marriage to R. That marriage is long over by mutual consent, which is why she is able to bindass say and do everything she has done so far. To her, the sutra is representative of her deal with R, where she said that as long as he helped her with baby A's treatment, she would do her bahu duties. Now when he is keeping his end of the bargain, how can she go back on her end. Vivi is extremely loyal like that. When she can keep her deal with a despicable man like KK, why wouldn't she with R, whom she somewhere does respect? If she truly considered it a symbol of marriage, why would she be so nonchalant about the sindoor? Simply cuz there's no deal attached to that, whereas the sutra is like a signed contract between them. It's not strength or courage she lacks, it is only that the deal is not yet done. Simple.
2) Atharv firmly believed in truth above all. There is no circumstance in which a lie would be acceptable to him. He would never pretend. For no reason whatsoever. Never.

3) If R is thinking it, then it HAS to be wrong. When has R ever been right in this show??! 😉😆
ViTharvforever thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Ravish may be partially wrong...cz if atharv wants to stay with vividha y he backs when he saw Ravish??
n next thing if wants to sacrifice y he is staying close to vividha??

whenever atharv becomes normal he saw R n he comes to baby mode...
cool_kriti thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
One thing i am sure of. That is Sujata is nt in all this. Thats all.
I'm messed up otherwise . Nt sure wht Atharv is upto 😕

Now i am feeling is KK or Uma behind all this? What if Uma has requested Atharv to back off so Vivi can lead life with Ravish? 😕 or what if KK has blackmailed Atharv?😕
Edited by cool_kriti - 8 years ago
ViTharvforever thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: cool_kriti

One thing i am sure of. That is Sujata is nt in all this. Thats all.

I'm messed up otherwise . Nt sure wht Atharv is upto 😕


i agree..cz wat sujata said to uma when she came to ajmer was genuine
Edited by ViTharvforever - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".