The Plausibility of Tia's Potential Pregnancy.

-castaways- thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
The Plausibility of Tia's Potential Pregnancy
So let's not even bother touching on the sheer hypocrisy of the situation itself (plus other people on the forum have already ranted about it far better than I could!) because Oberoi Mansion is the land of hypocrisy. No, let's actually think about this potential pregnancy, and what it actually means for Ishqbaaaz.
I say potential for a reason; I genuinely wouldn't put it past a vamp such as Tia is, to fake a pregnancy.
Think about it - she pretends to attempt suicide because she 'can't see a future for her and her child because Shivaay Baby seems to be so captivated with his forced wife that he won't give her a divorce'.
Can't you imagine her saying that?
Shivaay stops her, and tells her he needs time to think. In which time, Tia tips the media off about how Mr. and Mrs. Shivaay Singh Oberoi are expecting, which here ensues a completely expected media frenzy. Cue, Shivaay the morally righteous idiot divorces his middle-class wife, and then he and Tia have a hush-hush wedding. Two weeks later, she announces to the family and the media that she had an early miscarriage and everyone smothers her with sympathy, and love.
It sounds like quite the elaborate plan with multiple plotholes- but something that the brainless Tia Kapoor would come up with. The only intelligent part of the plan is tipping off the media; so even if the Oberoi family find out about Tia's reality, they have to still accept her in front of society because they can't risk their reputation abandoning their 'pregnant' daughter-in-law.
What our dearest Tia forgets to prepare for is the hurricane that is Annika and the force that she is coming for her.

Anyhow, if the pregnancy is real - that gives prospect to some more drama.
The first thing that really takes priority is how Shivaay reacts. The only way for him to consider the child as his, is if Shivaay and Tia have slept together. This strikes me as slightly odd for a few reasons.
For one, wasn't Tia only originally in it for the money? Isn't her heart, soul and aura completely Robin's?
Saying that, she may still have the hots for SSO (who doesn't?) so that's kind of understandable. But Shivaay? Has he ever, ever shown to be remotely attracted to Tia? Or really, to anyone but Annika?

The most romantic thing that he's ever done to Tia (or intended to, at least) is given her a back hug. The other two times, he's either too busy hiding from Annika (the moon on his wristwatch scene) or stood there like a rock while Tia all but assaulted him. Even with Annika, who he is insanely attracted to, he hasn't done anything apart from look at her lips intently. Not that he's really had the chance!

The point is, Shivaay doesn't really seem like the type of man who really spends time trying to feed his sexual desires. So for him to sleep with Tia, it doesn't quite make sense.
Saying this, if there's a random plot twist, and he has slept with Tia, I wouldn't really mind. He's a thirty year old man, for god's sake. Him still being a virgin is not realistic in anyway. Apart from the fact that this means that he was being devastatingly hypocritical with Annika and Daksh, this shouldn't be something that we should be worried about.

See, whatever Nayi Soch crap Star Plus spouts on a daily basis, Ishqbaaaz is everything but unconventional. Thus, I doubt, no I give you a blood oath, that the CVs would never, ever make the child Shivaay's. In their eyes, it would completely devastate ShivIka.

So let's just assume for now that the child is Robin's. What does that do for us?

1. Prove that Tia is evil to Shivaay. And thus, further challenge his NKK-centric belief system.
Well if he knows that he hasn't slept with her, then he has to realise that she's cheating him. I've seen Qubool Hai, in which there is a pregnancy track as well, where Tanveer accuses Asad of being the father of her baby. At that point, Asad and Zoya are in love, so he pretty much withdraws from her and refuses to marry her with the guilt of what he has supposedly done hanging above his head. However, there, he has an unconscious one night stand with her - which isn't really plausible in Ishqbaaaz, unless they fit in a one night stand between ShivIka's windscreen drama and Tia's suicide attempt. Now that I think of it though, seeing how fast things have been moving in IB world, I wouldn't really put it past them at this point. Let's just say though, that it's quite crystal clear that Shivaay has not slept with Tia, and instead, he is freaked out about how he is going to deal with the media and the family. Insert Annika, and her adventurous ways here.

2. Give way to ShivIka investigating Tia.
Cue cutesy scenes between the husband and the wife. Hopefully we'll get to see Annika using her intelligence for once, instead of flailing around accusing Tia left, right and centre with absolutely no substantial proof.

3. Prove that Tia is evil to the family.
I honestly think that pretty much everyone is happy with the ShivIka wedding apart from Pinky, who is still completely captivated with high-society Tia Kapoor. However, I genuinely feel that when she finds out about Tia's reality, she will be one of the first people to completely want to destroy her. And then we can finally have the sweet Annika-Pinky moments that we've all been hoping for ever since Annika became Shivaay's wedding planner!

4. Open the storyline up for some more villains, more misunderstandings, and then ShivIka in love.
Because come on, as if Gul Khan and her CVs will be satisfied with two villains, and one misunderstanding. No, they'll be heaps more but I just hope that with Tia out of the picture (for now, at least), Shivaay can have a nice redemption track, ShivIka can eventually fall in love, and accept each other. And then we might also get to see more of the other pairings on the show!

Speaking of ShivIka, I find the contrast quite interesting. While Shivaay doubts Annika everyday, we really have never seen Annika question Shivaay's doings. That was one of the first things that made me fall in love with ShivIka - the proposed bond of faith and trust between them that no other couple on Indian TV has ever really successfully followed through with. I'm hoping that witnessing Annika's unwavering faith in him, only deepens Shivaay's redemption. However, we never really know with Shivaay's redemption, because right now, it looks like it's going to be overshadowed by Tia Reiki Kapoor, the Queen-of- Implausible-and-Nonsensical-Revelations.

All in all, this pregnancy track is quite overused so I hope that the CVs will attempt to make it slightly more interesting, and realistic than what he have seen before.

Or we can all physically, mentally and emotionally prepare ourselves to witness Annika adopt ShiTia's offspring 😆
Edited by Innika - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

1.3k

Users

5

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

AnnzSageflower7 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
A well thought out analysis! 👏
I feel, the plot being unraveled at the moment is for Shivaay to feel that he has absolutely no control over his own life decisions.

Now that he feels the sweet beginnings of love with Annika, we will have a short reprieve period of ShivIka becoming closer and realizing their love.

But now that he wants to be her husband and lover, her finds he HAS to let her go. She's might refuse to, because she knows he's being blackmailed by Tia. But the obvious angsty route is to make him divorce Annika when he doesn't want to.

At some point, she needs to leave the house and Shivaay. I have a niggling feeling Tia isn't going too disappear to soon... There's a high point somewhere in there involving divorce papers.

But Dadi is strong, and Tia could never win with her before.
Edited by AnnzSageflower7 - 8 years ago
chottekikhushi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Innika, brilliant post as usual!!
It definitely did highlight some stark truths.
I too dont think that the baby is Shivaay's.Tia loved Robin too much for that!! But whether Shivaay will be eventually made to believe that is another thing.
I may be wrong but isn't a DNA test done for an unborn baby done by CVS sampling after like 10 weeks.( Cant believe my obsession for this show has actually reduced me to discussing Obg here but still!)

Which means that Shivaay hadn't even met Anika then because in IB time, as miraculous as it may seem, he has known her for only about 2 months or even lesser. So Tia can claim ( or rather, the CVs can make us/Shivaay believe) that he had a ONS with her before when he was drunk or something!!

Having said that it would be very distasteful for the viewers so I do hope that the track takes another route- one to expose Tia's true colours to Shivaay ( and eventually Pinky but right now I really dont give a damn abt what she thinks!!), make Shivaay fall even more with his wife because of her undying faith and trust in him, and eventually somehow make Ani's words come true. That it will matter to him when something he holds dear to his heart is taken away and other people make his life's decisions and he will have no say, meaning he may come to the verge of actually divorcing Ani who he now knows he cannot live without!

Moreover, I am hoping when all is lost, Tia will blame Shivaay for Robin's murder and Ani will be the ever mahaan bahu and take up the blame to pave way her lawyer or something, aka Chutki or Om's love interest!
Edited by chottekikhushi - 8 years ago
Userdoesntexist thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
A very very thoughtful analysis Innika. *claps*
That (revealing Tia--breaking NKK ideology--redeeming shivaay--strengthening shivika, and then NOT losing the new found strength of love due to some amnesia of writers) is what Gul should do. If this happens, then I have no complains with any amount of villains or frequent blunders in logic by Gul Khan.

But I am not sure that it is what Gul would do. I don't trust her. Not at all, after all those stunts she has pulled and her sheer lack of consideration of the viewers' wishes.

A similar post was written by Nappy (NapsterMonster) a few days ago, and while it was as thoughtful as this one is, I think it's just our wishful thinking.

This track has the potential to bring shivika closer, not separate them further. But it's Gul Khan we are talking about!
She herself said in a comment, "I don't put that much thought in it.."
I mean what do you expect now. She would instead make this track another rift between shivika.

Like, I said in another post, let alone logic, we can't even expect character consistency from Gul.

She might make shivay dumber than he already is and make him believe and accept Tia. like in KKB.

Anything else, would be a pleasant surprise. :)

Anni.
Userdoesntexist thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: chottekikhushi

Innika, brilliant post as usual!!

It definitely did highlight some stark truths.
I too dont think that the baby is Shivaay's.Tia loved Robin too much for that!! But whether Shivaay will be eventually made to believe that is another thing.
I may be wrong but isn't a DNA test done for an unborn baby done by CVS sampling after like 10 weeks.( Cant believe my obsession for this show has actually reduced me to discussing Obg here but still!)

Which means that Shivaay hadn't even met Anika then because in IB time, as miraculous as it may seem, he has known her for only about 2 months or even lesser. So Tia can claim ( or rather, the CVs can make us/Shivaay believe) that he had a ONS with her before when he was drunk or something!!

Having said that it would be very distasteful for the viewers so I do hope that the track takes another route- one to expose Tia's true colours to Shivaay ( and eventually Pinky but right now I really dont give a damn abt what she thinks!!), make Shivaay fall even more with his wife because of her undying faith and trust in him, and eventually somehow make Ani's words come true. That it will matter to him when something he holds dear to his heart is taken away and other people make his life's decisions and he will have no say, meaning he may come to the verge of actually divorcing Ani who he now knows he cannot live without!

Moreover, I am hoping when all is lost, Tia will blame Shivaay for Robin's murder and Ani will be the ever mahaan bahu and take up the blame to pave way her lawyer or something, aka Chutki or Om's love interest!

Agree with your each word. 😉
@italic I would love to see that. That would be so realistic and beautiful to see. Realization and redemption for all of them who didn't think of anika. I just want that they somehow land in some kind of crisis, (like a media scandal or someone's breakdown) and the entire family supports each other. Anika acts like a rock to lend them strength and all of them feel grateful and indebted towards her.. Every bond strengthend and they become that kind of happy family which we have been reading in A.C.'s and Napstermonster's stories. Ahh.. such wishful thinking.

@bold- Who are you kidding? as if they actually think of omkara this much. This track is just chutkara (pun intended) for them. from the fans. from how I saw it, that girl in comma was Sana. so yeah, Om has a girl on deathbed with a 2 year old in his arms to romance. 😆



asya34 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Res
All in all, this pregnancy track is quite overused so I hope that the CVs will attempt to make it slightly more interesting, and realistic than what he have seen before.

I agree. The only pregnancy track I really enjoyed was in IPKKND. Aarnav was so the ASR right till the end. Like Tia, Sheetal too was Aarnav's close friend but that did not make him blind to who he was and what he was capable off. He knew that she was lying and took the effort to figure that out without Khushi's help.

That is what I do not get with the character Ms. Gul has sketched SSO as. She has sketched him as a ruthless and sharp businessman who any 'sadak chalta insaan' can fool. How does she expect her audience to believe this guy is at the helm of an empire like the Oberoi's.
I do not expect him to divulge his doubts openly to Tia of course because at this point he does trust her implicitly but to have blind faith at the cost of pushing away even a sliver of doubt??? Come On!!! Does she really expect us to believe that Shivvay does not find even the slightest curiosity as to how he could have gotten Tia pregnant?? He does not think back even once to the times Annika told him she was married??? That is a lot of bull to believe about a man who only operates on 'COLD HARD FACTS'.

ASR was a sharper character and I can get why he would have misunderstood the situation when he saw Shyam and Khushi hugging. But even with Shyam, though he doubted Khushi as well, he never let Shyam have it easy. In fact he kept more of an eye on him than on Khushi.

Edited by asya34 - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".