'Mujhe Sunna hai, Anika': Shivaay

geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
A silent plea for her to hold on a bit longer; a prayer to her wrinkled, wet hands to stay joined with his; cold, calculated rage against the man who dared to touch the woman he loves, who dared to enjoy the harm he had caused to his wife, the woman he had misunderstood to such an extent.
These were just some of the things going through his head as he saw her trapped and screaming for help, silenced because of a psychopath he had called his friend.

She fell down, tired and unconscious, as he finally freed her from a prison of water and glass; this woman who used to throw water at him every chance she got and loved breaking glass. She had been trapped in his world of shards and poisonous, suffocating water, and he finally broke her free of a prison of his own making. And almost lost her.
A man, frenzied with the loss of his heart, his soul, just a broken man pleading for his love to be returned to him, pleading with her to call him something, to bring him back into existence in her own way, holding her close as if to make her heart beat or to make his own stop so that they could be in the same world, this or another didn't matter. Not then.
To think, his last conversation with her had been one filled with accusations and anger; to think, she would never look into his eyes, never ride roughshod over all his decisions, she'll stop being. No, he could not even dare to imagine a world without her words, without her smile, without her heart, without her.

And then, a tentative light in the darkness of their minds: Shivaay.

She had called out to him, to reassure, to believe, to calm: Shivaay.

That was all he needed: for her to look at him, acknowledge him. And he held her close, sagging with relief that she was okay, she was with him, she was safe, alive, in his arms, and so he breathed again.

But perhaps he had spoken too soon for she was silent. Seeing her break down and crying, he snapped.

After her outburst, before it, she was silent.
And he had no words.
He wanted to solve things, figure things out, but what could possibly be figured when she refused to listen, just like he had? How could she not talk to him? She was Anika, and her not speaking would slowly drive him wild, as if, as if she did not exist at all, and he could not take that. Never. She needed space to lick her wounds, while he, he needed some relief from his guilt. And so he declared in front of his family, his full faith in her, that he would not take it if anyone insinuated anything against her good character. It was not much, but it was still something: a beginning of a journey of forgiveness.

Guys, I tried...but sadly, the episode was too rushed for me to FEEL anything much; the editing was extremely shoddy, and there was no time given to even register anything. The pacing, the random song inserted in what should have been a completely background-less scene, so as to amplify emotions, made the whole kidnapping, her torture, seem trivial. The way it was quickly dismissed with a nod. It was quite disturbing.
Anyway, I had to rant somewhere. But I won't ruin these words. I adored the way Shivaay reacted to her unconscious and when she gained consciousness.

Love
Geet

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

4.5k

Users

15

Likes

110

Frequent Posters

Sweets101 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Always a fresh in depth analysis. thanks Geet.
Wow. .glad to be first to comment know your post
Edited by Sweets101 - 9 years ago
mineforever thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Again a fabulous post. 👏
I loved the episode.❤️
Not going to think about how rushed it was.
Nakuul was fantastic.
I wanted to c a scene where Shivaay is trying to sleep but he gets nightmare about losing Anika and then wakes up and sits next to her so he can stare at her and assure himself that she is alright and in one piece. But, oh well.
Edited by mineforever - 9 years ago
geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Sweets101

Always a fresh in depth analysis. thanks Geet.

Wow. .glad to be first to comment know your post


Thank you Sweets! 😳 Glad you liked it 🤗
blackorwhite thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
👏👏👏
Your post rocks as usual..
Bahut jaldi nipata di inhone yeh kidnapping ki kahani 😊
Did it meet my expectation? Not exactly.. But it was not that bad!! I'm kind of now used to them giving me half-backed scenes where I can see the potential and then cry and crib about the execution.. Jiska apna alag maaza hai and yeah AY ke thread mein karenge 😊
Songs: I actually preferred Jaane Nahi(Sonu Nigam ❤️) to O-Jaana.. Glass Half full wali baat hai yeah 😆 but would surely have preferred if they would have given us silence and would have let the emotions speak(maybe add kal ho na ho - heart beat ka sound at the end agar sound daalna hi tha)😊

Your post is amazing as usual 😊 My fav lines:
he finally broke her free of a prison of his own making.
No, he could not even dare to imagine a world without her words, without her smile, without her heart, without her.
She had called out to him, to reassure, to believe, to calm: Shivaay.
That was all he needed: for her to look at him, acknowledge him.
Just want to add 1 word to the below line:
She was his Anika, and her not speaking would slowly drive him wild, as if, as if she did not exist at all, and he could not take that. Never

It was not much, but it was still something: a beginning of a journey of forgiveness.
But unfortunately, I have a feeling that this journey is going to be short 😆
Edited by blackorwhite - 9 years ago
Roudy1 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Amazing post Geet. Nakuul was brilliant today. True thou they were beautiful scenes in today's episode, the episode was rushed which even I felt uncomfortable. Surbhi too did a brilliant act today as usual both of them rocked it.
geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mineforever

Again a fabulous post. 👏
I loved the episode.❤️
Not going to think about how rushed it was.
Nakuul was fantastic.
I wanted to c a scene where Shivaay is trying to sleep but he gets nightmare about losing Anika and then wakes up and sits next to her so he can stare at her and assure himself that she is alright and in one piece. But, oh well.



thanks!😳
he was good, yes!
And @ bold: I have written a scene like this in my ff 😳
mineforever thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: geet.a




thanks!😳
he was good, yes!
And @ bold: I have written a scene like this in my ff😳


Oh.Can u share the link?
aprilsunrise thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: geet.a

A silent plea for her to hold on a bit longer; a prayer to her wrinkled, wet hands to stay joined with his; cold, calculated rage against the man who dared to touch the woman he loves, who dared to enjoy the harm he had caused to his wife, the woman he had misunderstood to such an extent.

These were just some of the things going through his head as he saw her trapped and screaming for help, silenced because of a psychopath he had called his friend.

She fell down, tired and unconscious, as he finally freed her from a prison of water and glass; this woman who used to throw water at him every chance she got and loved breaking glass. She had been trapped in his world of shards and poisonous, suffocating water, and he finally broke her free of a prison of his own making. And almost lost her.
A man, frenzied with the loss of his heart, his soul, just a broken man pleading for his love to be returned to him, pleading with her to call him something, to bring him back into existence in her own way, holding her close as if to make her heart beat or to make his own stop so that they could be in the same world, this or another didn't matter. Not then.
To think, his last conversation with her had been one filled with accusations and anger; to think, she would never look into his eyes, never ride roughshod over all his decisions, she'll stop being. No, he could not even dare to imagine a world without her words, without her smile, without her heart, without her.

And then, a tentative light in the darkness of their minds: Shivaay.

She had called out to him, to reassure, to believe, to calm: Shivaay.

That was all he needed: for her to look at him, acknowledge him. And he held her close, sagging with relief that she was okay, she was with him, she was safe, alive, in his arms, and so he breathed again.

But perhaps he had spoken too soon for she was silent. Seeing her break down and crying, he snapped.

After her outburst, before it, she was silent.
And he had no words.
He wanted to solve things, figure things out, but what could possibly be figured when she refused to listen, just like he had? How could she not talk to him? She was Anika, and her not speaking would slowly drive him wild, as if, as if she did not exist at all, and he could not take that. Never. She needed space to lick her wounds, while he, he needed some relief from his guilt. And so he declared in front of his family, his full faith in her, that he would not take it if anyone insinuated anything against her good character. It was not much, but it was still something: a beginning of a journey of forgiveness.

Guys, I tried...but sadly, the episode was too rushed for me to FEEL anything much; the editing was extremely shoddy, and there was no time given to even register anything. The pacing, the random song inserted in what should have been a completely background-less scene, so as to amplify emotions, made the whole kidnapping, her torture, seem trivial. The way it was quickly dismissed with a nod. It was quite disturbing.
Anyway, I had to rant somewhere. But I won't ruin these words. I adored the way Shivaay reacted to her unconscious and when she gained consciousness.

Love
Geet


Wow, geet.
I just wished the episode was as beautiful as you have written.
I have too penned my thoughts in my post ' damp towel and a guilt trip'.
I felt like there were 2 different episodes joined by accident. One where Shivaay Emoting (Nakul was awesome here) and the other which was rushed with shabby editing, which actually wiped off the brilliant performance by Nakul. But I did not feel that Shivaay rescuing Anika and the outburst later was driven by love. I felt as if it was more of guilt.
I did not enjoy the episode other that Nakul's acting. But it was definitely not love there. If it would have been love then the fb with the thought of him loosing her would be dominant rather than their last convo of his accusations and her cries.
His irritation at her for not speaking to him was also not believable. He expects her to be the old Anika in less that 12 hours of the most traumatic experience of her life. He did not even give her time to lick her wounds. ( I guess the CV are in a hurry to start the Tia pregnant track).
There was no Sahil and I am amazed at the indifferent attitude of Saumya and Prinku. Anika getting up and walking away to sleep in the study was also something that was not needed. What did the CVs want to show by this, god only knows?

Ashidua thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
You are a magician with words
That was a wonderful piece of writing
👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".