Arent Adi and aliya siblings???

Bhaskar

@maharathikarna

Voyager

18

Posted: 9 years ago

#1

Want a clarification from regular viewers. Arent adi and aliya siblings?. I mean aliya calls ishitha amma and mani appa. Ishita is step mother of adi. In addition aliya calls mani appa and mani is husband of shagun who is mother of adi. In either way isnt adi and aliya siblings even if not related by blood???

1

Reply

Quote

Rimjhim Ghosh

@Rimu_coldfire

Sparkler

30

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#2

I am also confused with this thing...but again anything can happen here..

adi is 21 and working in Raman's office

instead of establishing their careers adi and aliya are getting married at 21 -_-

1

Reply

Quote

Siham

@sihu

Voyager

18

Posted: 9 years ago

#3

Aliya just calls Mani Appa...he is not her father, and neither is Ishita her mother.

3

Reply

Quote

Seetha_R

@Seetha_R

Voyager

15

Posted: 9 years ago

#4

I saw this question being popped up time to time so I thought I will give it a try to clear.. this may not be what you are looking for but I just want to try..

If you keep aside the way Alia addressing Ishita and Mani as Amma and Appa doesn't make Ishita and Mani parents of Alia or husband and wife.

Both Adi and Alia are not related by blood and total strangers. Yes, Adi is Shagun's son by blood and Alia is Mani's neice by blood.. if Alia is Mani's daughter by blood then she would be a step sister to Adi thru the marriage of Shagun and Mani. Hence their Marriage is not correct in moral stand point..

Same way Adi is Ishita's step son through her marriage with Raman but she has no blood relationship with Alia.. all her relationship with Alia is she is a mother like figure to Alia hence Alia marrying Ishita's son Adi at this point is not wrong..

Hope it made sense..

4

Reply

Quote

--Royal--

@--Royal--

Trailblazer

42

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#5

Nope there is no relation between ishita and aliya.. even i dont understand why still she called her "Amma" palane ka matlab yeh thode hi hota h ki aap usko "mom ya dad bulane lago😕(its completely my POV😊 ) its would be great if aliya call ishita "aunty" 😳 even mani is not her father.. so thankfully they aren't siblings.😆

btw i m watched some old epis of YHM ...so Adi is 21yrs old aur usne abhi tak apane MBA tak complete tak nhi ki hwooow first he is sooo young for marrige or engagement and second study tak complete tak nhi hue hai aur sagai and shadi🤢🤢 whats wrong with ishita and Raman...samjha chahye na ki abhi sagai/shadi k liye thoda wait kar lo.😕

why they are parmoting child marriage?? 😆 ( i mean 21 yrs baache hi to hai.🥱)

2

Reply

Quote

heperchaun

@heperchaun

Navigator

14

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#6

Yes. Adi and Aliya are siblings. Both of them getting married is against all the things yhm stood till now.
If u argue that adi and alia are not siblings then ruhi is not ishitas daughter in anyway either.
Disgusting is the only word suited for this engagement.

1

Reply

Quote

Bhaskar

@maharathikarna

Voyager

18

Posted: 9 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: sihu
Aliya just calls Mani Appa...he is not her father, and neither is Ishita her mother.

I know she just calls them amma and appa but would anybody just call somebody amma and appa without meaning anything???

Even otherwise isnt basic premise of the serial that you dont need to be related by blood or law and relations are made by heart and love???

Wasnt that the reason ruhi became daughter of ishi maa when she was not even married to raman.

Now how can a serial go against its basic premise and turn it 360 degree here.

I mean both mani and raman till now didnt want the marriage to happen and were telling all things to stop it. But wont a normal person tell this as the basic reason why this marriage should not happen even if its their excuse???

Edited by maharathikarna - 9 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

Bhaskar

@maharathikarna

Voyager

18

Posted: 9 years ago

#8

Originally posted by: Bentall
Yes. Adi and Aliya are siblings. Both of them getting married is against all the things yhm stood till now.
If u argue that adi and alia are not siblings then ruhi is not ishitas daughter in anyway either.
Disgusting is the only word suited for this engagement.

I just saw the post now. Thats what even i felt as a casual viewer. But then again in ektaa world anything can happen😆. But i felt it was taking it to little bit extreme. After all 21 years might be legal age to marry but still it marriage yaar.

1

Reply

Quote

heperchaun

@heperchaun

Navigator

14

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#9

[QUOTE=maharathikarna]

I just saw the post now. Thats what even i felt as a casual viewer. But then again in ektaa world anything can happen😆. But i felt it was taking it to little bit extreme. After all 21 years might be legal age to marry but still it marriage yaar.

[/QUOTEi] this is not about age alone. Adi and aliya should have never been paired up. Yhm has touched its all time low. Adi aliya engagement is as creepy and shocking to watch as mihir aliya.
I hope adi or aliya is killed to save the show from disgrace.
Next they might get shravan married to ruhi. 🤢 already 16yr old ruhi is made to wear sari.
That girl aditi bhatia seems too eager to grow up offscreen too.
Yhm is a disaster post leap.

1

Reply

Quote

Ramyasri

@Twihard18

Navigator

11

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

Same question in my mind since a week 🤣

1

Reply

Quote

Arent Adi and aliya siblings???

Related Topics

Explore Topics