sfarazi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hey guys,
A thought popped into my head while watching the past few episodes and I couldn't help but compare Natasha and Sona's characterisation. Ever since Sona has fallen in love with Dev, there have been many complaints about Sona losing the essence of her personality, lacking self respect and in general losing her fiercely independent self which to some extent is true. However, a character who has bothered me in regards to the points I just mentioned is Natasha.

Let's have a close look at Sona first. A self-made working woman who has dedicated her entire life to studying and her job as a nutritionist but secretly she harbours hopes of finding true love and of travelling the world. Her seemingly smooth life is turned upside down when he meets Dev Dixit, who is at first her worst enemy, having removed her from her stable job into a place where she didn't want to be. This is the phase in the show where I felt she lacked a backbone and needed to be more firm with Dev that it's not acceptable to get someone fired just so they would become a personal nutritionist. She did display some resistance but Dev managed to quell that pretty easily and sure enough she developed a liking to her job there (or more like her boss 😉).

However, she regained the self-respect when she would demand to be called Dr.Bose or when she would scold Dev for treating her like crap and that's how she managed to get a sorry out of him too. Another point that stuck out to me was how she never gave a fitting reply to Mami when she brainlessly taunted her. I would be so angry at Sona for not taking a stand but after a while I realised that Sona was just being smart. She knows there's no point in arguing and stooping to the level of Mami when you simply can't win in a fight with someone like that. She knows her worth and she doesn't need to prove that to Mami which is a sign of Sona's strength and intelligence.

Personally, I find Sona to be such a beautifully written character and so true to what women of the 21st century embody. The way she pushed away Dev's hand when he wanted to check her temperature, the way she kept a distance when taking that photo with Dev and her desperate attempt to remove that ring and flee are all indications of her resolve and how she wants to protect herself. The stand out moment for me was how, even in so much pain, she always has the best interests at heart for Dev and she isn't letting her heartbreak affect her existing relationship with Dev. She is strong, independent, loving and so very real. Sona has only emerged with a stronger sense of self and worth.

After that long spiel on Sona, I'll turn my attention to Natasha. She is shown to be more accomplished than Sona in almost everything. She earns more than Sona, she has travelled all over the world, she has better clothes and jewellery BUT she doesn't know her worth like Sona does. What astonishes me is that how she is completely fine with her father practically selling her off in a business deal in the name of marriage? I found it hilarious when she commented on how Dev didn't look excited about the engagement when in reality, neither did she. As Dev very aptly mentioned to Sona that "any boy would be lucky to marry Natasha" so why is Natasha settling for Dev when she has a feeling that her father is pressuring Dev to marry her?

Mr Gujral has praised his daughter in front of others to no end yet he feels that a business deal with Dev is the only way to also secure his daughter's marriage. Does he not have faith in his daughter to be good enough for a man like Dev Dixit without a business deal? To me, that's exactly what this situation is saying. If Natasha knew her worth and understood that she has worked hard all her life to be what she is today then she would realise that this is an insult to her very being. Also Dev always saying that Natasha is a "nice girl" is a reflection of how she hasn't been able to leave a substantial impression on him because it's clear that she isn't interested in this alliance either. More than Dev, it should have been Natasha who should have said no to the engagement but I hope that after this incident, she realises that she doesn't need to settle for the sake of her father.

p.s Sorry for the very long and random post but I would love to read your thoughts as well 😊

Shegufta

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

821

Users

3

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

ash_devnarshi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
You are right... nice analysis on sona...I totally loved it
sfarazi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: fionadsouza

You are right... nice analysis on sona...I totally loved it


Thank you! Glad you liked it 😊
Khusharni thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Every word was true! I don't understand the hate towards Natasha, I mean, yes she is "technically" in the way of DevAkshi, but in a way hasn't she actually helped them? She's made them closer in ways they wouldn't have if she wasn't there. I hope she cancels the engagement herself if she realizes Dev likes Sona, which has been quite obvious, but lots of people *cough Dev cough* are oblivious.😆
And I really really really hope they don't make her a negative character!!! PLEASE CVs DONT DO THAT TO US!!!! I hope she's sort of becomes there Cupid.
And I agree with you. Though I feel sometimes why doesn't Sona just yell back at Radha Rani and say STFU, I understand there's no point. And why should she have to justifie herself to RR?
Khusharni thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Oh, another thought came into my head. Though I am a feminist, and I support a woman's or a man's decision to become a house wife/husband, it really irks me why Natasha would want to give up her career? especially with the way they've portrayed her, I don't get why she would really do that, it doesn't seem right. Just my thoughts😃
sfarazi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Khusharni

Every word was true! I don't understand the hate towards Natasha, I mean, yes she is "technically" in the way of DevAkshi, but in a way hasn't she actually helped them? She's made them closer in ways they wouldn't have if she wasn't there. I hope she cancels the engagement herself if she realizes Dev likes Sona, which has been quite obvious, but lots of people *cough Dev cough* are oblivious.😆

And I really really really hope they don't make her a negative character!!! PLEASE CVs DONT DO THAT TO US!!!! I hope she's sort of becomes there Cupid.
And I agree with you. Though I feel sometimes why doesn't Sona just yell back at Radha Rani and say STFU, I understand there's no point. And why should she have to justifie herself to RR?


Haha I love your spirited reply! Yeah she has helped them come closer and she never really looked that interested in Dev in the first place. I hope she doesn't become negative and the chances are she won't be because that would be terrible characterisation. What I would like to see is her actually say something about this engagement and tell Dev that she never felt it was right either or at least have her realise that she should have some say in who she marries. Thank you for your opinion ❤️
sfarazi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Khusharni

Oh, another thought came into my head. Though I am a feminist, and I support a woman's or a man's decision to become a house wife/husband, it really irks me why Natasha would want to give up her career? especially with the way they've portrayed her, I don't get why she would really do that, it doesn't seem right. Just my thoughts😃


Yeah she's just a very bland and one dimensional character tbh. I feel like the CVs haven't invested enough time in really focusing on Natasha (well probably because we'd rather watch Devakshi 😆) but it definitely is weird that a girl who has travelled so much and has accomplished such great heights would want to give it all up and become a housewife? I guess that only reinforces my belief that Natasha lives for her father and doesn't exercise her own free will

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".