Do you think it was Ashaji's influence? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

Then why Sonu made mistake like this.

They should follow the rules strictly.

Where is the mistake ? Just your perception only. They have explained the reasons for their action and taking all aspects into consideration they postponed the eliminations to this week.

Even then she is influential let it be as she is most eligible to take dicisions in such situations.

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

It is not clear whether the result has been just postponed till next friday or they will have the chance to give another performance and cumulative till friday will be the criteria for elimination.

The second scenario is definitely not going to be fair to someone unfortunate who gave a good performance last week and have it bad on friday!! Hope this is not the case!!

After Fridays performance and top 3 are selected, whoever has the least points will be eliminated.

One reason could be Ashaji's request which the producers could not ignore and the second reason as was stated in telebuzz is that, last week due tot he confusion of karishma-kareena coming to the sets, the participants got minimum time to practice on their songs.So they were not fully prepared. Thats why may be this grace time.

Originally posted by: Padma55

Where is the mistake ? Just your perception only. They have explained the reasons for their action and taking all aspects into consideration they postponed the eliminations to this week.

Even then she is influential let it be as she is most eligible to take dicisions in such situations.

Tell me where you have seen before that rule of games changes after the game starts.

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

Tell me where you have seen before that rule of games changes after the game starts.

Read advil's response to it,,so perfect..👏
The truth is that Kapoor sisters were supposed to come; and when they changed their plans, the kids had to prepare songs in minimal amount of time..
Secondly the game rules you r referring to, remember when in c2007 all three pakistani guys were in danger zone b/c they were accused of refusing to sing indian patriotic songs..there was no elimination that week too..That was against the format too...
In this case, when judges are responsible for the elimination and stuff; so def there would be a lot more "manipulation of rules" so to speak.

To me it would have been more unfair, if a good singer got out just b/c he or she didn't have enough time to prepare a tough Asha ji song...
Hats off to Sonu and Suresh for their awesome decision..👏👏👏

Originally posted by: abru07

Read advil's response to it,,so perfect..👏
The truth is that Kapoor sisters were supposed to come; and when they changed their plans, the kids had to prepare songs in minimal amount of time..
Secondly the game rules you r referring to, remember when in c2007 all three pakistani guys were in danger zone b/c they were accused of refusing to sing indian patriotic songs..there was no elimination that week too..That was against the format too...
In this case, when judges are responsible for the elimination and stuff; so def there would be a lot more "manipulation of rules" so to speak.

To me it would have been more unfair, if a good singer got out just b/c he or she didn't have enough time to prepare a tough Asha ji song...
Hats off to Sonu and Suresh for their awesome decision..👏👏👏

Everyone got equal amount of time to prepare. Do you think Tanmay got more time to prepare than the others?

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

Everyone got equal amount of time to prepare. Do you think Tanmay got more time to prepare than the others?

I agree! I am a true Tanmay fan..But my thing is as judges, Sonu and Sureshi ji took an excellent decision which was in the favor of the majority of contestants..If half of the contestants sang bad, they can't eliminate the potential good singers to save the format crap..

I don't think so.. I think it is channel's decision not eliminate anyone this week

Thanks to Kapoor girls, kids had very little time for rehearsal the given songs.. so there were lots of poor performances, it was unfair to judge this time.. so it must be unanimous decision not to eliminate anyone

Originally posted by: uknaik99

I don't think so.. I think it is channel's decision not eliminate anyone this week

Thanks to Kapoor girls, kids had very little time for rehearsal the given songs.. so there were lots of poor performances, it was unfair to judge this time.. so it must be unanimous decision not to eliminate anyone

I agree with you, probably due to the kapoor girls, the kids got very little time to prepare the songs. Asha tai came, as she is very much fond of the little kids. The songs the kids performed are very popular, that is why probably the kids took very little time to prepare, but performing in front of Asha tai, it was difficult.

Wrong decision thats it. There is no if's and but's. No one got special treatment or special time to prepare. Everyone had it equal. If the Kapoor sisters were responsible Zee Should SAY IT publicly and put the Blame on them. People to step up and take responsiblity for things. Cannot say this weeks bottom 3 had potential therefore no elimination. What this tells me is that the other kids WHO SANG and prepared BETTER than the bottom 3 could stick to their guns, worked hard and got the job done in the same time as others. Who is to say they do not have potential if one of them gets eliminated this week?

Who was in bottom 3 Sagar , Loria and Smita everyone on this forum was banking on one of them being eliminated last week anyways.