Complain, complain and complain some more... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.4k

Users

18

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Divine-Pearl

That's what we call discussion.

If someone wants to talk about logic, his/her wish, free world, open forum, and democratic country

All opinion should be accepted without personal attack. Yes, others shows are more illogical but people discuss about all bloopers, blunders and illogical nonessential in respective forums.

Instead of asking others not to watch if they don't like, better don't take part in a discussion which you don't like. You shouldn't be the one asking others what to do and what not?



👏 👏 👏

I applaud you for speaking out on this thread. It is an open forum where members discuss their views.
As long as we maintain courtesy and decorum and avoid personally attacking members there should be no problem in a healthy discussion. It is people's perspective the way they look at the discussion. To some it is negativity and complaints, to some it is constructive criticism. Whether one should quit watching the show or refrain from making posts is that individual 's decision. Other members cannot decide for them. They cannot tell them to leave the show or forum. That is bullying and intimidation.

Everyone in this forum started watching the show because they found it interesting. Now after a few weeks they may be finding too many faults. Again this depends on individuals. Some people are happy with good looking leads and a love story of any kind without logic. Some people like a good story line with logic. Some people want the main characters to act and speak well. When a show is on national television, the PH have to face both criticism and praise.

But to ask members to quit watching or quit posting is dictating to them and infringement of members ' rights.

Hope all members will respect differing opinion and views.
honeybrij thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Very nice post. Well Said. You have said what I wanted to say, this forum is full of negativity. It's just a fiction show for entertainment. Why take it so seriously?
I see posts complaining about story, characterization, logic...etc. It's fine to discuss all these, but it looks like some members are just looking for negative points only.
Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
Are we so spoiled by histrionic and the OTT dramas by Zee and Star that we're finding faults in this show, albeit that there are some glaring loopholes and inconsistency but still I mean compared to the shitfests on Zee tv that my dadi watches this show is like an Emmy winning drama😳 But yes I do wish that the CVs take some constructive criticism and try ti improve the show, both these new shows on Sony are a breath of fresh air compared to the never ending regressive sagas on the other channels, I would hate to see them fall prey to the TRP idiocy.

I'm surprised at seeing how much people are bringing down Erica here, like damn compared to the other frozen faces on tellywood I'd say that she's doing a damn great job with the material at hand, in fact I find Shaheer way too overrated and mumbling his dialogues and all.😳 IDK about the Bengali thing since I'm a gujju and desi tv has completely butchered Gujrati people beyond repairI literally am watching to see Sonakshi and Ishwari interactions since they've shown them better than the lead pair.
tu-jo-mile thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Divine-Pearl

That's what we call discussion.

If someone wants to talk about logic, his/her wish, free world, open forum, and democratic country

All opinion should be accepted without personal attack. Yes, others shows are more illogical but people discuss about all bloopers, blunders and illogical nonessential in respective forums.

Instead of asking others not to watch if they don't like, better don't take part in a discussion which you don't like. You shouldn't be the one asking others what to do and what not?

Yes I also support you..this is an open forum..all have rights to express their thoughts..
but nobody has right to tell others not to watch the show..its their TV..their money..their choice..and their right to express the opinion..and sometimes complaining does not mean that they don't like the show..of course they like the show..that's why they want it to be perfect..why being so irritated yaar!
-Sara. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Agree with you! It's so annoying to see.
virat50 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Bolly*_Crazed

Hello Fellow Forum Members,

So, I keep seeing posts on this forum complaining about one thing or another.
Don't get me wrong, I did my own fair share of nit picking in the beginning, but damn enough is enough.

There are members on here writing posts with so much hatred and negativity it makes me wonder why they're watching the show in the first place?! Literally, its a damn SHOW, it's meant to be watched as a leisurely activity and meant to bring relaxation to your day for 30 minutes, but we have members here having high BP over it.

Everything has been nit picked from the way Sonakshi's dad can't speak proper Bengali, to Sonakshi's dressing sense, hair, job ( I was apart of this ...so I'm guilty too), and more.

YES, there are a lot of pot holes in the plot and a lot of things don't really make sense, but if they bother you THAT much simply don't watch it, and if you can look PAST IT ( which I've decided to do) then continue on watching, but if you can't then move on...and stop polluting this forum with so much negativity.



Hey guys,

This seems partially directly at my post yesterday. As some people have thankfully pointed out, in an open forum there shouldn't be censorship. It is not a good idea to promote the idea that on any topic one should either A) praise the person/show/ or whatever the topic is B)stay silent about it.

If I find certain elements of the show extremely illogical, why can't I share those views?

Also, no-one is asking for a 100% logical show, but it should have at least 1% semblance of some type of logic.

I watched this show because I am a fan of Shaheer, and have been impressed by Erica as well. I don't have anything against any of the actors, but it's just the forced circumstances they create can be funny.
Bolly*_Crazed thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Divine-Pearl

That's what we call discussion.

If someone wants to talk about logic, his/her wish, free world, open forum, and democratic country

All opinion should be accepted without personal attack. Yes, others shows are more illogical but people discuss about all bloopers, blunders and illogical nonessential in respective forums.

Instead of asking others not to watch if they don't like, better don't take part in a discussion which you don't like. You shouldn't be the one asking others what to do and what not?


Have you seen some of the posts on here? There is no discussion happening, it is more bashing, literally, the posts consists of what people find wrong in the show and THAT IS IT - there is no suggestions, no constructive criticism. Yesterday I saw a post with a person literally listing reasons why this show was illogical and stupid?! How does that "promote discussion" all I see it as is promoting negativity and hatred.

Also, I've been on IF long enough to know that pointing out mistakes and loopholes is common and sometimes even a good thing to add substance and thought process to a forum, but what goes on in this forum is something else - something I haven't seen on any forum in my 10 years here.

Also I am not forcing someone to stop watching this show, but merely SUGGESTING that if this show brings to you as much agony as your posts suggest that you're better off not watching it. I am not holding a gun to your head and telling you DONT WATCH.

At the end of the day it is your life and time and if you want to continue watching a show that you think is baseless and senseless and borderline angers you to the point where you have to create accounts on public forums to bash it, then go ahead 😊
kinu17 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
According to me its a show. And this forum is for us to watch that show and feel free to discuss, critisize, laugh, enjoy,etc but only the characters except not bashing the actors, i have been participating in this IF for yrs so many soaps i have participated if something weird things cvs showed us definitely we all members use to teamly critisized and cvs has solved those track very excellent way and in future we will critisize too, as ours views r important to them, yes we all knows all these soaps r fictional drama but still we need to discuss. This is the part of the forum discussion, participating in the forum doesnot mean only positivity there should be some negativity as well as. U have to face it instead getting upset and suggest not to watch this show if u dont like it bla bla, its really not a good suggestion trust me
In my experience in IF cvs has changed so many times their script due to our disliking some tracks,
Bottom line guys just enjoy the show like it or not doesnot matter, just remember our pov is the succes of these indian soaps infact all soaps in the world become successful
Edited by kinara17 - 9 years ago
JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: kinara17

According to me its a show. And this forum is for us to watch that show and feel free to discuss, critisize, laugh, enjoy,etc but only the characters except not bashing the actors, i have been participating in this IF for yrs so many soaps i have participated if something weird things cvs showed us definitely we all members use to teamly critisized and cvs has solved those track very excellent way and in future we will critisize too, as ours views r important to them, yes we all knows all these soaps r fictional drama but still we need to discuss. This is the part of the forum discussion, participating in the forum doesnot mean only positivity there should be some negativity as well as. U have to face it instead getting upset and suggest not to watch this show if u dont like it bla bla, its really not a good suggestion trust me
In my experience in IF cvs has changed so many times their script due to our disliking some tracks,
Bottom line guys just enjoy the show like it or not doesnot matter, just remember our pov is the succes of these indian soaps infact all soaps in the world become successful



Very well said Kinara! 100% correct analysis. I have been on many forums and criticisms are part of every forum. And you are 100% right that CVs have corrected their mistakes and storylines based on feedback from Forum discussions. That is why i call it constructive criticism. If CVs can make some course correction, then the show will be successful.

So kudos for bringing out that point. 👍🏼
kavmuks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
I also feel the same.. After all it is show / drama .. there is too much criticism going on. There is hardly responses for good performance posts etc. Only Complains...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".