judges/host comments are rude.

Hi,

I have wanted to comment for a while regarding the comments, especially made by Vaibhihi (whatever her spelling is) and Hussain. Don't get me wrong I think Hussain is a complete entertainer. However I think they way the talk when certain people get voted out is rude towards those contestants saved.

Example, this week Kashmera and Krushna got voted out by the Janta and Alexx and Shweta and Karan and Amita got saved.

I was wondering did the four saved contestants feel like crap listening to Hussain and Vaibihi go on about what is going on...that the people that should continue are leaving. Karan is a trained dancer, and Amita is trying with all her might to improve and they have. Alexx is a "foreigner" and for the love of god he's is doing better than most indian born actors who claim they can dance. He dances well considering his firangi is a handicap for him.

I was just putting myself in Alexx, Shweta, Karan and Amita's shoes while listening to Ms. Vaibihi (who is an okay choreographer - we've all seen Jhoom Bharabar Jhoom - dancing is not anything to write home about) and Hussain comments regarding the elimination of Kashmera and Krushna. Who by the way were very unimpressive regarding their last dance...it was very similar to the paheli song the first time round - If I recall correctly then Shah Rukh and Rani Mukherjee were also puppets in that...where is the creativity in that. And they got 10 for that...while Karan and Amita were very creative with theres and they got 6 from Ms. Merchant. On another note Amir Ali and Sanjeeda did not perform outstandingly for the Koi Mil Gaya, It wasn't that creative.

Anyways, in my opinion if Nach Baliya is going to be set up in the manner where the janta gets to vote who stays on and who doesn't...the hosts and judges should not say anything regarding those that are left and eliminated. Their job is to "guide" via points and then leave it to the janta.

Just venting because I think despite everything the hosts and judges want Alexx and Shweta, karan and Amita gone. I can already predict that Rakhi and Abishek (they do deserve it) and Amir (his expression are horrible while dancing he resembles Frank Munster from the Munsters) and Sanjeeda (very good dancer) will be in the finals.

Not meant to hurt anyone it's just my honest opinion, Ms. Merchant is getting on my last nerve...who does she think she is Saroj Khan.

sry to say friend its every1 choice u cannt blame any 1 but pls friend dnt compare aamir he is much better in dance and expression thn amita

i think you are right in the matter of vabhi, but i think you are wrong about aamir, he gives very good expression. you said that he didn't dance good on koi mil gaya, hellow what more do you expect with that kind of song. i think for judges round and farah's choice round 👏aamir and sanjeeda 😛didn't get good songs. anyway they tried very hard which i could see becasue i think you don't know aamir is a none dancer. this is the first time he is dancing. and now he has become a very good dancer.👏

Originally posted by: ahada

i think you are right in the matter of vabhi, but i think you are wrong about aamir, he gives very good expression. you said that he didn't dance good on koi mil gaya, hellow what more do you expect with that kind of song. i think for judges round and farah's choice round 👏aamir and sanjeeda 😛didn't get good songs. anyway they tried very hard which i could see becasue i think you don't know aamir is a none dancer. this is the first time he is dancing. and now he has become a very good dancer.👏

I actually remember amir ali from his film yeh kya ho raha hai..where he was a square in terms of expressions. I think he is a good dancer...it's his expressions that I am not happy about.

after kash -krush departure vaibhavi and hussains comments are insulting to couples who were in danger zone with them.at least they should have a balancs approach.

Originally posted by: piyualka

after kash -krush departure vaibhavi and hussains comments are insulting to couples who were in danger zone with them.at least they should have a balancs approach.

this is the point i'm trying to make..they should be not permitted to give these personal opinions...it's wrong.

totally aggree.
i did not like the last kashmira and krushna dance b/c it was totaly a copy of the paheli song. and i also think judges gives them more point then they deserve, esp david dhawan.

i loved the two weeks ago where rakhi and abhishek perform on the hotoh pe pas tere naam hai and yet they did not get the full marks.

Originally posted by: 02aug30

totally aggree.
i did not like the last kashmira and krushna dance b/c it was totaly a copy of the paheli song. and i also think judges gives them more point then they deserve, esp david dhawan.

i loved the two weeks ago where rakhi and abhishek perform on the hotoh pe pas tere naam hai and yet they did not get the full marks.

EGGJACTLY...Kashmera and Krushna dance was very similar to the original...and Rakhi and Abhishek's number was out of this world...the one wear she is wearing the red saree....i watched twice to see if I could see any flaws...nothing...it was gorgeous. It was a 1000 times better than anything that Kashmera and Krushna have done. No offence. But I have to agree with Pooja Bedi (despite my disgust in the way she did it), that the comments are not being translated into the appropriate marks (I really honestly believe this for Ms. MErchant - she really is making me going Crazy Kiya Re...and not in the good way. ).....

i totally agree with u soni2004, u've said the right thing, i felt the same way, alexx-swetha and karan-amitha must have felt so bad. c'mon their performances were much better in this round and i feel they deserved to stay and they r still there. But as u said Vaibhavi and Hussain were insulting them indirectly, how can people be so cold. I m glad in one way that Kashmira and Krusha were eliminated, i did'nt really find them interesting at all. Well this is my opinion

Soni2004,

Yaar, aapne meri muh ki baat chinli!!!!!!
I felt so bad for Karan-Amita and Alex-Shweta!!!!!

And I really cannot stand Vaibhavi's attitude!!! For christ's sake, she is just a choreographer!!! But the air she puts on, you would think she is the Prime Minister of the country and is working hard to run the country!!!!!

Ms.Merchant, just remember that you only choreograph some dance numbers!! If for some reason you did not choreograph a dance number, the earth will not stop revolving!!!!!

Sorry for the digression!! Coming back to the topic, I mentioned this in another topic too that I find her unfair and her comments very hurtful. She needs to simply give her judgement and sit quiet!! This is a show for the people and by the people!!
Ms.Merchant, Don't forget that you are in that seat in the first place because of us the people!!!
Because someone in the junta liked your work, you went on to become the supposedly ace choreographer!!! Don't forget that!!

From what I saw in NB2, Hussein's wife Tina was a miserable dancer. She was really really bad in the start and picked up a bit by the end. But still they won, purely because Hussein was fantastic and the people loved them like crazy!!!

And the last point I want to make is, the least Vaibhavi can do is not make the couples feel like crap with her comments. She is already making Karan-Amita's life hell by giving them a 6 when they deserved an 8!!!