Similarities between Ragya and a famous book/movie!!!!!!

.IPKKND. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Guys this is really weird but I feel like this story and ragya's love story parallel very much. By no means Im trying to say it is plagerised but Im saying that they are similar. Im not talkimg about the current Ragya track but Im talking about Ragini's viewpoint of love and Lakshya.
Im talking about book turned famous movie Gone Girl. Ragini and the protagonist/antagonist(the girl is good and bad in the book just like Ragini) of the book both have this obsession termed love with their man which leads them to do bad things to both the man and those around them. They are not necessarily negative but infact they almost feel that EVRYTHING IS FAIR IN LOVE AND WAR. This obsession has lead them to spoil relations and commit very wrong thimgs yet feel that they are right in their position.They have gone to boundless extents to save and attain their love.

For those of you who keep saying that Ragini is a psycho( I believe that too) must understand that the makers are actually trying to potray that sanity is lost in love and leads ppl to commit things they do not mean to. Its a weird logic but its true...

What do u guys think?

P.S Mods i do not know if this comparision is permitted nd im sorry if i broke any forum rules.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.3k

Users

6

Likes

13

Frequent Posters

wohradhahai thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
First I'll read the book lol..
But u r saying correct.
N I don't think there is any rule that u can't compare...
foresight thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
i don't think that is quite accurate...though i do understand where you are coming from.
the reason i feel it is different is because in that the girl goes to an extreme of writing an entire fake diary to project that her husband is torturing her and to send him to jail in revenge because of his affair but also because she is psycho right from day one...she is not turned into one by situations. she is obsessed with him (hurting him and trapping him) but at the same time, doesnt mind using other men for her advantage and killing them in cold blood.

here this ragini for all the obsession that she too has, she actually really loves Laksh and cannot see him physically harmed or in danger even when she knows he is one who is trying to kill her. if he returns her love, she is willing to do be the way he wants, and be docile and loving.

there in the book, she was out to get revenge and then trapped him in the end in a hell that he couldnt get out of. she was sinister and integilent at a diabolical level. ragini is more a pawn trained by her dadi and some things copies sanskar's previous plans. when she does think of something on her own ...its is more lashing out emotionally rather than shrewdly.

she will need to suffer for her redemption to really happen, betrayed by laksh to realise the true value of those she had pushed aside and hurt for him. but the in book, you couldnt have redeemed the girl.
Edited by foresight - 10 years ago
Vt-Cl thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: .IPKKND.

Guys this is really weird but I feel like this story and ragya's love story parallel very much. By no means Im trying to say it is plagerised but Im saying that they are similar. Im not talkimg about the current Ragya track but Im talking about Ragini's viewpoint of love and Lakshya.

Im talking about book turned famous movie Gone Girl. Ragini and the protagonist/antagonist(the girl is good and bad in the book just like Ragini) of the book both have this obsession termed love with their man which leads them to do bad things to both the man and those around them. They are not necessarily negative but infact they almost feel that EVRYTHING IS FAIR IN LOVE AND WAR. This obsession has lead them to spoil relations and commit very wrong thimgs yet feel that they are right in their position.They have gone to boundless extents to save and attain their love.

For those of you who keep saying that Ragini is a psycho( I believe that too) must understand that the makers are actually trying to potray that sanity is lost in love and leads ppl to commit things they do not mean to. Its a weird logic but its true...

What do u guys think?

P.S Mods i do not know if this comparision is permitted nd im sorry if i broke any forum rules.


I think Ragini has gone beyond "Everything is fair in love and war"... She has turned into a selfish monster.. She knows Swara is not after Laksh ... And now she thinks LAksh is falling for her... YET.. She still doesnt want Swara to be happy. And she is delusional thinking still that she was right in doingg everything she did and Swara was wrong.. SO this is beyond obsession with Laksh.. This is now just selfishness
merrydock thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: .IPKKND.

Guys this is really weird but I feel like this story and ragya's love story parallel very much. By no means Im trying to say it is plagerised but Im saying that they are similar. Im not talkimg about the current Ragya track but Im talking about Ragini's viewpoint of love and Lakshya.

Im talking about book turned famous movie Gone Girl. Ragini and the protagonist/antagonist(the girl is good and bad in the book just like Ragini) of the book both have this obsession termed love with their man which leads them to do bad things to both the man and those around them. They are not necessarily negative but infact they almost feel that EVRYTHING IS FAIR IN LOVE AND WAR. This obsession has lead them to spoil relations and commit very wrong thimgs yet feel that they are right in their position.They have gone to boundless extents to save and attain their love.

For those of you who keep saying that Ragini is a psycho( I believe that too) must understand that the makers are actually trying to potray that sanity is lost in love and leads ppl to commit things they do not mean to. Its a weird logic but its true...

What do u guys think?

P.S Mods i do not know if this comparision is permitted nd im sorry if i broke any forum rules.

your right love is pure, but once is turned into obsession it is unhealthy and any bad actions cannot be justified if set out for public viewing. moral values would deem them wrong and criminally inclined, and in the real world either both should walk away, or one will end up killing the other. either ways obsessive love always ends badly.
so what ever happens between laksya and ragini its going to end badly for either one of them. by bet is that it will end badly for ragini. given what ragini has done, she should have been in jail when the truth of her trying to kill swara was revealed. if this had happened lakshya would not have tried to kill her to get her out of his life. right?
merrydock thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Vt-Cl


I think Ragini has gone beyond "Everything is fair in love and war"... She has turned into a selfish monster.. She knows Swara is not after Laksh ... And now she thinks LAksh is falling for her... YET.. She still doesnt want Swara to be happy. And she is delusional thinking still that she was right in doingg everything she did and Swara was wrong.. SO this is beyond obsession with Laksh.. This is now just selfishness

your right on that, its not about love or obsession anymore but about ragini's selfishness, she is totally jealous that sanskaar loves swara so selflessly. she is envious of the relationship swara and sanskaar have because she knows that she can never have that with lakshya.
.IPKKND. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Vt-Cl


I think Ragini has gone beyond "Everything is fair in love and war"... She has turned into a selfish monster.. She knows Swara is not after Laksh ... And now she thinks LAksh is falling for her... YET.. She still doesnt want Swara to be happy. And she is delusional thinking still that she was right in doingg everything she did and Swara was wrong.. SO this is beyond obsession with Laksh.. This is now just selfishness



No Ragini does not really hate Swara she just feels deeply insecure of Swara being around her, since she is delusional that Lakshya is finally falling for Ragini anx has forgotten Swara.She does not want Lakshya to rekindle his feelings for Swara at this stage and hence is opposed to Swara and Sanky reunion because she does not want Swara and Lakshya to be under the same roof. More than Swara she still distrusts Lakshya and feels that he will revert back. Hence her anger is aimed at Swara because she hates the fact that her man chose her sister over her...though Swara did not cause any harm to her.

And ofcourse her selfishness results from her obssession with Lakshya and her delusional feelings that Lakshya will be hers. If u have noticed since the very time she has met Lakshya she considers him as hers and refuses to find love anywhere else. This is her obssion which has inturn caused her selfishness and greed for his love.
.IPKKND. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: foresight

i don't think that is quite accurate...though i do understand where you are coming from.

the reason i feel it is different is because in that the girl goes to an extreme of writing an entire fake diary to project that her husband is torturing her and to send him to jail in revenge because of his affair but also because she is psycho right from day one...she is not turned into one by situations. she is obsessed with him (hurting him and trapping him) but at the same time, doesnt mind using other men for her advantage and killing them in cold blood.

here this ragini for all the obsession that she too has, she actually really loves Laksh and cannot see him physically harmed or in danger even when she knows he is one who is trying to kill her. if he returns her love, she is willing to do be the way he wants, and be docile and loving.

there in the book, she was out to get revenge and then trapped him in the end in a hell that he couldnt get out of. she was sinister and integilent at a diabolical level. ragini is more a pawn trained by her dadi and some things copies sanskar's previous plans. when she does think of something on her own ...its is more lashing out emotionally rather than shrewdly.

she will need to suffer for her redemption to really happen, betrayed by laksh to realise the true value of those she had pushed aside and hurt for him. but the in book, you couldnt have redeemed the girl.


Ya i agree with u...they are somewhat discreetly similar

Actually I feel that the final fate of Ragya is similar to the book. Coz in the end they accept the truth and are willing to oversee their shortcomings and pretend to be the person the opposite expects. Ragya is going to be somewhat similar. Ragini has forver tried to be the girl Lakshya wants(pretended to act like swara) and finally decided she had enough and attempted murder. While Lakshya probably after the forthcoming Ragini suicide drama will be the man Ragini expects him to be. Though she is not as shrewd and cunning as the girl in the book and hasnt gone to great extents, she has considerably pushed boundaries to gain Lakshya. Though she did not seek revenge the property track certainly meant to teach Lakshya a lesson.
clarity thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
You came up with a very interesting comparison indeed.

First of all, I love that book and movie. So well-written and such complex characters.

Though the complexity of RagYa's relationship on Swaragini is more accidental than intentional, it's certainly quite real.

Such relationships do exist in life. Maybe the Swaragini CVs are not trying to justify evil winning over good, but just trying to show that two flawed-one actually degenerate-individuals can come together and find love.

Amy was totally psychotic and could go to any lengths for her wants. Ragini is more or less the same. Lakshya and Nick are also quite similar, in that they are not exactly model human beings, though not as bad as Amy/Ragini.
.IPKKND. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: clarity

You came up with a very interesting comparison indeed.

First of all, I love that book and movie. So well-written and such complex characters.

Though the complexity of RagYa's relationship on Swaragini is more accidental than intentional, it's certainly quite real.

Such relationships do exist in life. Maybe the Swaragini CVs are not trying to justify evil winning over good, but just trying to show that two flawed-one actually degenerate-individuals can come together and find love.

Amy was totally psychotic and could go to any lengths for her wants. Ragini is more or less the same. Lakshya and Nick are also quite similar, in that they are not exactly model human beings, though not as bad as Amy/Ragini.



Exactly my point!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".