Gr8analysis. By all...am late but...pheww...life's busy..what with I have started my studies back after a break of 13 years...this itself is great news,for me...at least beginning somewhere with a little course..my excitement is like that of kids when we enter new classes and loving the new,books.
U guys said it all.
Symbols..for future story:
First cloth drowning in water..means some omen relating to water happening in Khanak life.
Then khanak. Mil giving her a new cloth...it means it will be her mil who would initiate new color new identity in her life. And this time her puja is complete at the last step. I would believe that in almost all rituals shaan was first but on marriage it was suraj...so while performing this puja she did all correct except last final part...coz that related to suraj..which was drowned...and then she took a new cloth and completed her puja.
KhaNak waiting at temple for her hubby...and arrives shaan.
Khanak. Even after first meet reads and connects to shaan like some very old and close pal...but she had,a diff personality with suraj...more like being pampered and kiddish...but with shaan she is different...a women...an equal..I would say..
ShaNak being there with each other at there worst and best times...
Shaan feels,so comfy with khanak... it doesn't even register in his mind that the girl he's probably taken liking to is,married and is someone else's wife..not once he asks her about her marriage...or anything coz she's the closest he's got connected in this village...and somehow he's holding on to her..he is himself with her and so is,she...but both have diff person as with there fiance and hubby
She's shaan mentor right from the moment they met...anchor..and shaan is her sheild...
Both are not staunch traditionalist...both are go betters in diff ways...ShaNak are rule breakers...while Nitz and suraj are more pamperers and kind of disciplinaries
Accident
I have said before...Shaan is too protected...and it's his first seeing anyone hurt...he's so shocked that he doesn't know to take the situation. He's so dependent on others for taking decisions for him that when he had to he failed...became numb. So choksi had to overtake. His carelessness too is,shown...he's introduced to a situation not to his liking for first time and he has no one to guide..and even choksi kinda understands that. First ever time he's out of his cocoon and he's lost.
But this situation...he's deeply affected, unable yet to grasp...and accept his mistake...confused as to which way to take...scared to bits..he doesn't even know to help anyone or console anyone...coward...
I think he would have run off had he not met khanak in temple. Her talk actually stopped him. Somehow she was the one to guide him to face reality..I think this instance somehow made him grow up..to have a backbone...to acknowledge his responsibility
At hospital...last moments of suraj we're heart touching..his love for khanak. Was,so deep rooted that he could think of no one but her only...he wanted to see her...he was pleading with his eyes to shan.. almost telling him..plz save me,I wanna live,,take care of my life back there..wanting an assurance...but ShaNak was too scared,confused,shocked to respond. At this point it was more of a mess for him...the mess he wanted to be free from...he didn't go near suraj coz he was not sure and afraid that he might cause more harm to him..more of fighting with himself that he wasn't at fault for this accident. He was,still in shock mode.
Brilliantly enacted by all actors...what a death scene.. one of best on tv...almost real..the pain...gosh..
Mangal is a leech but his father...his hurt was.. I just wanted to hug that family...last moments of suraj made me cry and scared to bits..does this happen in real too...nobody can ever no..
More than mangal it's his wife...dhabba on name of a female. Brilliant acting..that we hate mangal and hetal.
Shaan firs time sees pain of people...he's scared of this feeling...he can't comprehend there loss...he wants to help but doesn't know how...he wants to forget it all like a nightmare and runaway to his cocoon,where it's all happy and no pain...away from any responsibility...he's prepared to leave... let choksi take charge...but then he sees khanak. Thats when all he'll breaks lose. Her hurt is what hurts him. The actual realization dawns only after knowing the wife is khanak...his real sensitivity comes out seeing her pain,shock and disbeleif,..unknowingly she had made a special place and trust in his heart and being the cause of her hurt actually pained him..loosing her trust, her respect deeply affected him. This affected shaan wanted himself to prove his innocence to her...that's,why he actually didn't runaway even after so much. He needed a proper closure but he never got that...if it would have been any girl..he wouldn't have bothered I bet...but this was ShaNak and he wanted her to be happy...he couldn't take her hatred and gloomyness and so he decided that may be a new life will take her happy and she cg will forgive him...So shaan the manstarts decidng from here just coz of khanak. Hes ready to face anythig just for her..just to see hinself being declared innoent in her eyes...
The true stiry if shanak begins from here...shes been the reason for his growth from a boy to man right from day he met her. The moment where he hides behind door and takes away her mithai stealthily,to hidibg het from her inlaws,to indirectly taking stand for her betterment..to supporting suraj family...he does all for her...anybody can answer..why??? Hum Aapke Hain Kaun?? ...
Hats off to all actors,symbolics,music,dialogs,firction in these four five epis...summed up in one post...