TOI:TV Series Review:Naagin-Hisstorically hysterical

Sutapasima thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

It is hard to begin describing the wonder that is Naagin. Where does one start? The singularly unoriginal plot, the lazy writing, the uniformly mediocre acting, the Subhash Ghai inspired music score, or the eye popping computer graphics?

The fantasy fiction show is produced by Balaji Telefilms and is telecast as bi weekly torture, every Sat-Sun at 9 pm on Colours. Like its many of its predecessors in this genre have enlightened us, there exists such a creature as the Ichadhaari Naagin. One moment a snake, another a woman, or a man, this shape shifting terminator is the Uma Thurman of the reptilian world. Predictably we only encounter them when they are out to get revenge for the snakicide of a family member. Fassscintaing...

Plot: The show introduces us to the Raheja family and their coterie of close friends and family members. Heir apparent Ritik Raheja and the pile on parivaar travel to their family mansion in spookytown Panchner for his engagement to Tanvi. However unknown to him, his family has buried many dark secrets there, more murderous than they can handle. Cut to twenty years ago, when Ritik's dubious Daddy Ankush and his buddies killed the Naag couple guarding the Shiv temple. Yes they marry like humans, and make ichadhaari babies as well. Wonder if the baby is born a snake or human. Never mind. Unfortunately for them, Mommy Naagin takes a quick picture of her killers with her photographic eyes and the couple's baby Naagin Shivanya sees this image of her parent's killers. 20 years of penance and a size too small blouse later, Shivanya has returned to get even. Joining her are a shrieking snake charmer mentor and a member of the Naagin sisterhood in Sridevi's clothes. The current track of the show sees her replacing Tanvi to marry Ritik but worrying that the moonlight might turn her skin to its snake form. Will she succeed in taking revenge or will human emotions and a potential love story get in her way?


Characters: The show must be awarded for creating the most stilted one dimensional characters of recent times. Protagonist Ritik Raheja (Arjun Bijlani) is a rich businessman (yawn) who has to get married before he turn 25 to avoid a glitch in his horoscope. Otherwise engrossed with his phone and laptop, Ritik's heart warms instantly to snake woman Shivanya ( Mouni Roy) posing as a poor maid at his palace. His Father, Ankush Raheja (ManishKhanna) gets facials, pumps iron and manhandles his wife to seem scary. Mommy Yamini (Sudha Chandran) spends time with priests and astrologers trying to appease them into forgetting her husband's snake killing past. Arjun Bijlani tries in vain to make his character interesting, and while the man is easy on the eye there is very little he can work with. Sudha Chandran tries earnestly to breathe life into her role but her flashlight bindis are more interesting than her role. Manish Khanna father is suitably evil looking and has rather reptilian eyes but needs to be told that acting cool or scary is not acting. The saaging supporting cast includes drinks a lot sister, nerd cousin, and other folks who don't contribute in any way to taking the story forward. In the middle of this mess is another Naagin (Adaa Khan) who serves as a red herring in the first couple of episodes but it's not quite clear whom she has her fangs set on. There is no emotional connect with any of the main cast and 5 episodes into the show, one can't wait for the killing to start to save us from watching their expressionless faces.

Script and direction: If the poor performances let the show down, a large part of the blame must go to some apologetic writing. Clearly having the Naagin handbook by heart can't ensure a decent script. The screenplay relies a lot on CGI, in place of actual action and emotional journeys to take the story forward. Red flashing eyes mean anger, background score replaces fear or anxiety and ridiculous chit chat passes of as romance. The dialogues sound like a thesaurus of Hindi words on revenge, religion and superstition. Especially charming are the insider jokes on how Naagins don't really exist and Ritik's dreams about snakes biting him. Very Freudian and deep.


The episodes are executed poorly as well, with shoddy camera work and direction from someone taking a nap. The humans are so comatose on this show that the fake snakes seem interesting, and have been executed quite well by the poor graphics team working overtime to scare us into caring about the fate of its characters.

It's a mystery why Ekta Kapoor chose such an oft told tale and created an entire show out it. It would have been refreshing to see a completely new take on the myth of shapeshifting women. That's the advantage of working with the fantasy genre. You can tell any story you want as long as the audience can connect to the character archetypes that emerge naturally from a well written tale. Slither away from this show if you can and just watch Anaconda instead if you really need a snake fix.


Saraswati Datar,TNN | Dec 4, 2015, 12.34 PM IST | TV Series Review
Edited by Sutapasima - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.5k

Users

16

Likes

70

Frequent Posters

Sutapasima thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
I do not like this review at all .
looks like the author dislikes snaky themes , otherwise how is this show getting the max TRPs ?? surely the author is unable to feel the viewers pulse here !!!
Renee90 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I wonder if she actually saw the show or has she written the article on pure hearsay. ☢️
Sutapasima thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Renee90

I wonder if she actually saw the show or has she written the article on pure hearsay. ☢️


the author had declared everything about the show is in poor taste ,😲😲 the story, the theme, the computer graphics, the acting, the dialogues , the SFX, then she should please do explain what is being liked by the viewers so much to give it sky rocketing BARC ratings !! why this bashing a hit show by leading newspaper ??
😆😆😆
Edited by Sutapasima - 9 years ago
1Rockstar1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Sutapasima

I do not like this review at all .

looks like the author dislikes snaky themes , otherwise how is this show getting the max TRPs ?? surely the author is unable to feel the viewers pulse here !!!

The article shows sheer jealousy of the writer.. might be sm1 bribed him/her to write 😆can't tolerate the success of the show
Mayra_jenny thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
I dnt knw whats wrong in this show evry thing is perfect nd if the author knows everything then plzz tell us that why the show is on no. 1 trp rating on 3rd week also nd plzz tell us what attracted the viewers
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
TBH, High TRP is not indicative of quality. Saath nibhana saathiya, YHM, and Kumkum bhagya are all TRP toppers but the shows are horrible. I know Naagin has exceptionally High ratings, but that is not always the best way to measure quality-although I think Naagin is a great show.
I don't think TOI will give any hindi serial a good review since they are more critical and serious. it's fine, we like Naagin but it is ok if the reviewer did not, stuff like this does not matter to me. everyone is entitled to their opinion.
drfizaahmed thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Once ekta basher always ekta basher she nt even is living in India Singapore k freelancer Indian show per review 🤣
Who cares baby Indian audience love show
Renee90 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: drfizaahmed

Once ekta basher always ekta basher she nt even is living in India Singapore k freelancer Indian show per review 🤣

Who cares baby Indian audience love show

Indians never decide whether to like anything reading the reviews.🤣
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
TFS! The writer seems to compare Indian shows with foreign ones. But Indian shows are hardly original. They repeat the same old thing and people watch the same old thing too. I am one one of them. 😆
But Naagin is high on entertainment value which primarily gives TRPs. The drama quotient is high.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".