The most disgusting hubby who failed time and again

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Affinity

@Affinity

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#11

I don't think there's a difference between Sid and Roshni's individual plans.

It's just the fact that we see him as a guy doing it, that we get more pissed. As a trope, in general.

For example, Khushi did it for a bit in IPKKND to find Arnav from Shyam. I'm sure many other shows have had the bahu do that. But with Sid, being a guy, even if he's seducing for the greater good (well from his pov and plan), we get a bit more disgusted as an audience.

I don't think he failed as a husband. Yes, ROshni probably will get hurt but for the time-being, the plan is more likely to be successful if she doesn't know about it.

Quote

pree8714

@pree8714

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#12

@pree8714

I completely respect ur POV.. The thing is they failed to show Roshni as a good wife AFTER Sid's death.. I'm stressing the point AFTER.. Whether it was the immediate police station drama or her entire priority being getting DD out of jail and property, that doesn't look good for a wife whose husbad died with such huge blot on his character.. I would have not said this if they atleast showed Roshni having a monologue of how she is not able to do anything to clear Sid's name or searching for Shabbu or doing something like that. So, for me CVs did a big blunder in Roshni as a wife there.

I equally agree with the fact that Sid is wrong in hiding.. I have never justified his hiding anywhere. But the fact is at the end of the day Roshni and Patels will be the beneficiary of what he is doing.. Even if with the pains now, Roshni is going to gain big when Shabby is kicked out and they get back the property.. And the individual failures of both Sid and Roshni as husband and wife at some point in time has never affected their love and will never affect. So, I'm just looking at both sides and thus having a diff POV😛

P.S Anyway congrats on becoming a goldie🥳

Well yeh blame it on cvs who has shown roshni not doing anything or investigating and I don't like that either in her character I have tweeted cvs to stop showing roshni dumb as she could have played a very important role in this track like how kareena in aitraz saved her hubby but cvs had to go the disgusting way which I am not in favour I hope his plan works and not backfires as it has happened In the past

Thanks babe and I respect your POV too

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Srishti

@srishtisingh

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#13

i dont blame sid trying to trap shabby by doing all this, because i dont think he has any other way to clear his name until and unless shabby gets enlightened and spits the truth out and ask for forgiveness. sid was the one who got his name ruined, his character questioned. he knows he cant trap foxy by being that good old jamai, so sometime to bring some people down a person has to play game in their own way. regarding him being a good husband or not i dont doubt that. but situations are different currently.he has to hurt rosh to make her believe that he is not her sid, otherwise he knows he will fall weak in front of rosh love and closeness. though i dont find him a quite good son!

Quote

chandana

@Just_Smile

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: srishtisingh
i dont blame sid trying to trap shabby by doing all this, because i dont think he has any other way to clear his name until and unless shabby gets enlightened and spits the truth out and ask for forgiveness. sid was the one who got his name ruined, his character questioned. he knows he cant trap foxy by being that good old jamai, so sometime to bring some people down a person has to play game in their own way. regarding him being a good husband or not i dont doubt that. but situations are different currently.he has to hurt rosh to make her believe that he is not her sid, otherwise he knows he will fall weak in front of rosh love and closeness. though i dont find him a quite good son!

👍🏼

Quote

chandana

@Just_Smile

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: rosesidni

Chandz, looks like today our POV are matching perfect.. this is another point I wanted to make😆

@bold Sid getting close to Shabby for the plan makes him a disgusting hubby, Roshni getting close to Raghu (knowing its Raghu) is equally disgusting.. She went to meet him at midnight, have eyelocks or roam around in forest NOT KNOWING it is Sid, is equally bad.. The difference is Shabby is plain disgusting and Raghu, we know is Sid. IF Raghu was just a humshakal, still Roshni would have gone ahead with the plan of making him act like her hubby and make him stay in the room. So, if that's OK for a PLAN, even this should be OK.. The only thing is Shabby looks like a prostitute and the scenes look plain disgusting😡

But what Sid and Roshni did is essentially the same thing😛

both are lying ...diff is sid knows what roshni is doing 😆 I even made a post on this ...Roshni making stranger to act as her husband is plain idiotic ...what if he is really look alike ..and took advantage of her😲...but we didnt point out or bash bcoz we knew it was sid ..so we sided with her😉

Quote

chandana

@Just_Smile

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: pree8714

@Rose

really roshni was ok his hubby being called characterless well i guess you forgot roshni was the only who trusted sid and fought with the media and as far as she not doing anything we all know how she was trapped being all alone as DD was in jail and her husband was no where around to prove his innocence and as far as you are talking about present let me tell you roshni is not aware he is sid and i think their were many other issues to sort out as to get DD out of jail and getting their property back and even shabnam has not blamed sid and got him arrested as he has returned and ok for once i will blame roshni as she has forgotten about sid name being spoiled but she not being a good wife it was always sid who has lied to her hurted her emotions if she was a bad lover she would not fought for him and easily moved on when sid lied to her end number of times

if sid was a bad lover..he would have also left roshni ..bcoz all mess in his life is bcoz he is a jamai of patels ..he never thought like that ..now also what ever he is doing is as a hubby and jamai..that is irking me a lot as he is neglecting his parents😡

Quote

1 2

The most disgusting hubby who failed time and again - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics