Harshit - Page 2

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

mangrooves

@mangrooves

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#11

pooja agree with u completely...people who profess to have great gyan in sangeet ,oflate started saying harshit is no good but as a layperson(which majoity of us are)i find toshis voive very irritating ..... also all the drama to bring him back is sick...for me harshit is a far better singer and will vote for him

Quote

bilu

@bilu

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: anu is # 1
did i hear the word soothing and hirsht in one line? i need a break now after reading that

Pleeeeaaassseee go ahead and do so.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

David Prasad

@CANADIAN2007

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#13

Well it is loud and clear that ANU # 1 is bent on targetting Harshit as a bad singer. What he should realize that all these singers now in the lineup are very good singers however VOI should go to one who is able to sing all types of songs. If Anu# 1 can guide me to any episode where Toshi has been able to sing any one of Sonu Nigam,s , Kishores or even rafis song as to any near perfection as what Harshit has sung. Toshi has never done that and he never will be able to but on the other hand he is a good sufi, qawali type singer. So Mr. Anu # 1 go get a music guru and learn some details about music. Do not just use abusive words b4 you think.

Moderator's Note:
No personal attacks on any member shall be tolerated... Please refrain from making personal remarks against the members...

Edited by smallwonder - 18 years ago

Quote

bilu

@bilu

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#14

Exactly my point!! At least others try to sing different songs!!

Moderator's Note:
Please Do Not quote posts that are attacking any member...

Edited by smallwonder - 18 years ago

Quote

SAnode

@SAnode

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: CANADIAN2007
Well it is loud and clear that ANU # 1 is bent on targetting Harshit as a bad singer. What he should realize that all these singers now in the lineup are very good singers however VOI should go to one who is able to sing all types of songs. If Anu# 1 can guide me to any episode where Toshi has been able to sing any one of Sonu Nigam,s , Kishores or even rafis song as to any near perfection as what Harshit has sung. Toshi has never done that and he never will be able to but on the other hand he is a good sufi, qawali type singer. So Mr. Anu # 1 go get a music guru and learn some details about music. Do not just use abusive words b4 you think.

Dear moderator,

sorry for quoting this post. I dont approve personally attacking any member,but i just wanted to say a few words concerning the part which i hav highlighted in red.

The question about Toshi's versatality has been raised and has been answered a hundred times. Please carefully listen to toshi's Ek haseena thi(kishore's), Din dhal jaaye(Rafi's) and Dil mangta hai (sonu's). Unlike Harshit who imitates kishore, Toshi has an entirely different voice. but he beautifully sang ek haseena thi and was appreciated by the judges and kishore kumar's sons. Judges said they were close to tears when he sang Din dhal jaaye. Sonu nigam himself suggested Toshi to sing dil mangta hai after hearing him and liked it when he sang.

If one person can easily sing sufi songs which are difficult for most of the singers, it doesnt mean that he cant sing other kinds of songs. In my opinion, (and i'm sure i'm not alone) Toshi definitely has more range than Harshit