He had Survived! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

5.1k

Users

13

Likes

118

Frequent Posters

-bharti- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
After a long time some sane thoughts wrt the storyline n characters, thank you, hoping against hope CVs are taking the right path
shindesweety thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Plzz go n replace the new cvs
u really wrote acc to the conditions n u very well knw them(characters)
brilliant post
takecare
zohasad2.0 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
I get you totally.

He saw his best friend lose his life and then he saw himself surviving and safe.

It is difficult to withstand such a thing for a guy like Mai Malhotra who guilt-trips for his friends every now and the even when he shouldn't. How may times has Nandini told him that he can't be there for everyone all the time.

This Manik, his reactions...all are understandable but I just hope the new CVs don't drag it and make it into one of their own previous shows. I don't want Manik to turn into a douche bag. He is Manik Malhotra...he should remain so.
shibz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@Shibz - Pretty decent insight to his head. Similarly , I will understand and see Nandu's POV. My only problem , let these two characters play off each other. Don't sacrifice anyone of them for the sake of Arya and his uselessness. If this is the conflict , let the kids handle it.


Manik- PTSD . He is long gone..saw his friend die , probably had some health issues of his own. He has always been insecure about her leaving him and not being worthy of her affection. Even after all that happened ..death/accident and whatever he went through- solitude, it can mind f**k anyone. His anger ( unreasonable but can be understood) . I really really hope they translate it well and don't make it into a d-bag move.

Nandu- I have hated it when they used Nandu's grieve to push other characters. But I will hate it more , if they mute her to Manik. If he lashes at her, she has to punch, scold , shove back. Let the conflict be balanced with her taking stride. If he has gone through a PTSD , so has she .

Both of them readjusting to their new perspectives which the tragedy has taught them can be a good storyline. It is not uncommon , bitterness, cynicism , insecurities are part of symptoms . Let Nandu be insecure too- she lost him, she suffered the confusion- let it play out as well.

The accident has changed them- how much and how willing are they to fight for each other and heal each other is and should be the story.


But , I repeat, let the conflict and arc focus on Manik and Nandu. I would hate if they make Manik a d-bag and mute Nandu just to shine Arya.




Genie, Hey😃

Exactly! See now the precap of today's epi! Why is Arya tagging along?😡

My fear too, that's why I added in the last line that I have no hopes on CVs but so far Manik's behaviour is understandable. I hope Parth didn't sign up to play a D-bag😆

Today's I understand. Manik needed to lash out and get it out of his system. He had valid points and I'm happy he didn't spare his Feb5! But tomorrow, as in another day in KY2 world, if Manik continues it then Nandini HAS TO give it back to him! Punch him, kick him, lash out.. see that's why I want CVs to show us what Nandini did after the accident. The Nandu we know would have been an emotional mess! This was the second tragedy in her life too.

They both have reasons to be insecure, that's why I said let them hug and cry it out! And then they will fight it together. Coz both know no matter what the insecurities, they want to be with each other!

And I'm still waiting for writers to justify Manik's absence😳 Today's was incomplete n confusing!

charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
@Shibz-
They messed up Nandu's narration earlier in the season. As in some of the dialogues and accusations Manik had with Nandu were what I have been venting. They rarely, made feb3 and Nandu react. If they wanted to numb out Nandu, should have made anyone from feb3 mention the struggles etc. I still don't like how they ignore Cabir.

For now, his anger , silly or not, is understandable.. but only to the point where Nandini will have to stop mollycoddling him and punch him down and make him LISTEN TO HER.I really hope, they make her talk about her struggle, cry out ..how she suffered..make her talk about feb3 too. Just give them that moment. They owe us , Nandu's version of struggle too in those 4 months.

I have no hope about his 4 month absence , it might be illogical only.
What I am hoping is one long solitude moment and them talking ..soon. They both need it. He is angry, hurt but not bitter or hating her.
Just these two are damaged too and they need to hug it out, talk and then heal together. Nandini - needs to cry out and he needs to feel re-assured. Bas. NO STUPID 3RD ANGLE , GIVE THEM SCREEN-SPACE.

Nandu needs to tell off Arya..he is everywhere and unnecessarily. He crowd them so much. Meh and he is beyond annoying and honestly , needs to buzz off.



Edited by charminggenie - 9 years ago
Sue101 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
so busy doing bla bla u did not even aske me what that reply meant, or ky2 like u made some assumptions 😲😆
shibz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: charminggenie

@Shibz-

They messed up Nandu's narration earlier in the season. As in some of the dialogues and accusations Manik had with Nandu were what I have been venting. They rarely, made feb3 and Nandu react. If they wanted to numb out Nandu, should have made anyone from feb3 mention the struggles etc. I still don't like how they ignore Cabir.

For now, his anger , silly or not, is understandable.. but only to the point where Nandini will have to stop mollycoddling him and punch him down and make him LISTEN TO HER.I really hope, they make her talk about her struggle, cry out ..how she suffered..make her talk about feb3 too. Just give them that moment. They owe us , Nandu's version of struggle too in those 4 months.

I have no hope about his 4 month absence , it might be illogical only.
What I am hoping is one long solitude moment and them talking ..soon. They both need it. He is angry, hurt but not bitter or hating her.
Just these two are damaged too and they need to hug it out, talk and then heal together. Nandini - needs to cry out and he needs to feel re-assured. Bas. NO STUPID 3RD ANGLE , GIVE THEM SCREEN-SPACE.

Nandu needs to tell off Arya..he is everywhere and unnecessarily. He crowd them so much. Meh and he is beyond annoying and honestly , needs to buzz off.



I was in fact quite surprised Manik had the same points we had discussed regarding Nandini n feb5 doing nothing!😆

@Cabir, I know right? Such a thanda reaction from his friends! Like Manik was off on a holiday and Cabir never existed!😕

Nandu needs to share her version of the story as well with him! And I don't want her "fraand" to do that for her!

Manik can neither hate feb3 nor Nandini. Like you said he just needs to be reassured. Today he stopped himself from breaking the guitar and that said a lot. Tomorrow he'll be ready to talk to his Nandu alone! But Arya's involvement is just going to stretch this issue🤢

Enough screen-space for manan - I have no hopes


@Sue, I thought that meant 'approve'😳 is there something else?😆
-rupa- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
Got your link from twitter and the way you have described manik
Is perfect ..will sharing with CV too

Hoping they don't stretch beyond point .and we get to see manik and nandu back 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".