Disappointed with the judges

Are you disappointed with judges?

Had big expectation on Shaimak, on giving really valueable mentoing comments... he can really raise the level of this competition with his mentoring comments.

Jeetu Sir and Urmila ji - are good in what they do, but over here we don't need comments from audience celeb but as a judge...

Thank God marks given by them are still justified, but low marking should be followed up with mentoing points... like whats the reason fo 5... ok 1 is steps then rest 4???

Simply by saying ..I don't much bass mereko bahut aachaa lagga and crowd yoo hoooing doesn't really serve the purpose of judges... Start stating what made them 5 marks, so that pupils can work on thoese lines and try to match up thier point criterions.

No offense anyone.... just we need some solid tadka in judging to raise and keep the interest going...😊

i think few posts were made on this before, i was wondering on the same issue 😕 😕 😕

oh no problems, I just got time to frequent here... and fesh from watching the recording last night 😆 .Apart from mentoring am pointing the need of tadka i.e. some controversial judge like Farhan or Anu... exta spice lolss you made me spell it out now 😛 😆 😆

DT feel free to close this post, if repeatative. Thanks!

i think among all the judges, urmila is a spici-er judge, the other two are so cold 😆 😆 😆

Originally posted by: raunaq

i think among all the judges, urmila is a spici-er judge, the other two are so cold 😆 😆 😆

😆😆😆 Are you reading my mind 😆 nah but it's time to raise standards... they should do thier job of raising the standards...😊

their marks were good....but judgement was dull...

i think since it was just the first episode they were trying to be nice with words...but styl give fair grades...

hopefully in the next episodes they give the correct judgement along with the correct marks...

Try to bring Spice and u end up with judges fighting among themselves! Any way this is just the beginning. Hope they open up more and atleast explain their marks. Shamak has a problem with hindi, maybe that makes him not express his opinion well enough!

Originally posted by: varmap

Try to bring Spice and u end up with judges fighting among themselves! Any way this is just the beginning. Hope they open up more and atleast explain their marks. Shamak has a problem with hindi, maybe that makes him not express his opinion well enough!

but does he really?? it sure doesnt seem like it...except the fact that they keep bringing it up...😕

I think he does. In any case, majority Parsis in bombay speak Hindi with a Parsi/ gujarathi accent, making it sound different from the normal Bombaiyaa Hindi or even spoken Hindi of Bollywood/ normal hindi.

I also read somewhere that he was not educated in India, having lived abroad, it is possible that he may have difficulty with the language.

Exactly..If the judges r giving 5 or 6 marks to a contestent then they need to justify their act for giving such low marks ...First they r praising the performance like anything and then suddenly giving a jhatka with 5 points they should at least point out where the participants hv gone wrong so that they don't repeat the same mistake again 😊