fairest dance show....really? DT note page 2 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.5k

Users

9

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

MimiVruShan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: bhavi09



can't vrushanpal fans stay out from it plz for god,sake stop your views when u don't even respect the super judge's decision



Oh My God! Just grow up! I stopped watching D3 like 2 yrs ago.. Move on! I am a fan of dancing which is why i'm watching this show! I have the rights to share my views since i am a viewer! And i'm not disrespecting remo's decision! U dont know me and u have no idea how great of a fan i am of Remo since DID 1! But like I said I just don't like the format of the show is all! Don't jump to conclusion everytime -.- there are contestants that are far more deserving to be in top 6 like hardik, D+, V Company, popping tiko (wgich is now one).. I like banjara girls but i would have prefered to see someone else in top 6 instead of them.. Like i said.. I dun see the point in choosing top 6 based on the whole team performance when only one artist will win the title and not actually the team!
..Roopal.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: DiamondLife

what happen..third time its team shakti?


yes...but that's not the thing i was trying to say..
..Roopal.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: NiRajCraZey

I completely agree..Sumeet and Dharmesh's team did equally well and someone from their team deserved it. I could see D+ taking the title. Its showing slight biasedness. I feel Shakti's team wasn't too strong this time to make a hatrick! Sumeet trained his team so well that his team deserved it. Even Dharmesh! I wonder why this is happeneing. And dont u feel that Shakti is showing biasedness towards Tikko :(

I wanted to see Hardik! He was the best! What about Rahul? And Nadeem..Especially after today's perfomance! 😔


well i am having no issues with shakti winning...she must have done something better that made her win...

m just quoting the criteria for the top 6 selection...i don't mind shakti's team winning...i just want the top 6 selection should not be restricted to the winning team but should be open for all..
..Roopal.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Angelicdiya


I think Remo sir is much more experienced than us.😊 He knows who deserve to be in top 6. And Shakti's team is giving back to back rocking performance. So Team Shakti deserves it 👍🏼

Just bcoz ur fav team is not winning that doesn't mean Shakti's team is weak.



as i mentioned i have nothing against team shakti or the team winning
i said i am against the criteria for the top 6 selection...the top 6 selection for me should not be stay restricted to the winning team but should be an open one...

and this is the thing i pointed out in the first week only...but that went unnoticed so to discuss this thing made a separate post...so there's nothing that i am saying it all coz my fav team is not winning...
..Roopal.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: bhavi09

@Tm till day before yesterday all were ok with remo's decisions so now y don't u respect the maestro of the show who is much more experienced than me or u


bhavi u can see the critic's corner
in the first week itself after the audition i pointed out on this criteria
but that point was not discussed much as not all are on that thread
i wasn't here the 2nd week so made this post separately today


Aahaana thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Hey Everyone,

Each and every one are entitled to having their own point of view, likes/ dislikes. Since the show is about dance, you can't always expect positive criticism about the participants, teams, judges and the performances. Every show has its own flaws so positive/negative criticisms are bound to happen so kindly try to be more open mind and accept others point of view. Do NOT attack fellow members for not sharing same opinion. Use the report button to report post breaching the rules!

And its a kindly request not to turn this discussion into a fan war.

If you have any further concerns please feel free to contact us. Thank you once again for your cooperation.

Regards,
I-F Dev Team


Angelicdiya thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
Hope this time Sumeet or Dharmesh team will win . & then the pattern will be right and accepectable for many of u.
Mystique.Kishi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
OK guys calm your pants. The lady has a right to hold and express her opinion regardless of whichever Fandom she belongs to. We can't just presume stuff.
On the topic, I would say that yes the show is not really fair. The criterion for choosing the top 6 does not make sense whatsoever. Because as I said in my topic the marks throughout the course of the show becomes redundant. What is the point of getting good marks if it ultimately depends on the face off. Also this means that the contestants are making to the top 6 not on their own merit but on the merit of whoever danced for them in the face off. Makes zero sense to me. I love everyone on the show but the pattern of choosing has to be different. For example this could be done. All the contestants from every team perform. The mentor chooses the one going to the face off and whoever wins in the face off goes to the top 6.atleast they would go there on their own merit.
That being said I refuse to believe this show is scripted in any manner. Because if it were scripted the show makers are not idiots to make one mentor win thrice. That would be too blatant and obvious and there are subtle ways of doing things. This show is very honest and not scripted in the least. Only in this show can one mentor win thrice by proving their mettle. So I am happy about that atleast. No making us bewkoof from behind the scenes. The only scripted part of the show was probably that Israeli ditzy girl with the plastic smile.
anjali_mahajan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Oh hooo its so hot here 😉😛
Anyways yes selection criteria is not acceptable...it must be something else..coz what if only 1 team winning everytime..this will be unfair with other contestants..in this show everything is just above our expectation level except the selection criteria...i will not say that its biased kind of but its quite undigestable to see the top 6 contestants from the same team if same team winning the dance war...
And guyzz its not that shakti's team winning every week thats y we raise this issue...its not that we are shakti's haters, its not about the team its about the contestants...
It will be unfair for the contestants...coz in this way deserving contestants may lost battle coz of 1 weak performance of their teammates..so dont go in wrong direction n just understand the point..
Otherthan that the show is just superbbb...i just wish Remo sir ne bhi kuch socha ho abt this matter

anjali_mahajan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Mystique.Kishi

OK guys calm your pants. The lady has a right to hold and express her opinion regardless of whichever Fandom she belongs to. We can't just presume stuff.

On the topic, I would say that yes the show is not really fair. The criterion for choosing the top 6 does not make sense whatsoever. Because as I said in my topic the marks throughout the course of the show becomes redundant. What is the point of getting good marks if it ultimately depends on the face off. Also this means that the contestants are making to the top 6 not on their own merit but on the merit of whoever danced for them in the face off. Makes zero sense to me. I love everyone on the show but the pattern of choosing has to be different. For example this could be done. All the contestants from every team perform. The mentor chooses the one going to the face off and whoever wins in the face off goes to the top 6.atleast they would go there on their own merit.
That being said I refuse to believe this show is scripted in any manner. Because if it were scripted the show makers are not idiots to make one mentor win thrice. That would be too blatant and obvious and there are subtle ways of doing things. This show is very honest and not scripted in the least. Only in this show can one mentor win thrice by proving their mettle. So I am happy about that atleast. No making us bewkoof from behind the scenes. The only scripted part of the show was probably that Israeli ditzy girl with the plastic smile.


Yeah exactly 👏
I also felt the same..n fully agree with u..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".