was the 20 mark round and top 6 selection fair??

Page

Jane Doe

@Jane_Doe

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Everything was going great till the last round, i feel 20 marks was a bit too much, okay maybe trying to equalise it to out of 20 marks that other contestants were given

but 20 0 0??? Thats way too much, neither did the winning duo deserve a full score nor were they exeedingly btter than the rest, and they could have opted for a 20 10 5 marks for 1st 2nd 3rd or maybe 10-0-0

And when we think of the losing two in that round they werent half bad but their contribuition to team was 0

it seemed really unfair

and to top it of that 20 mark is sure to get their team to highest scorer of week and hence the same team gets to put up any two acts for the top 6 selection

I would have prefered remo solely deciding a top 6 selection from the winning team, was captains call necessary??

I dont hate the show (love it infact) dont hate any captain( love them all d sir shaks n sumeet) didnt hate any contestant.. just found this unfair and wanted to know everyones opinion about it

Quote

Frequent Posters

Roopal Gupta

@..Roopal..

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

i just posted on this topic in critic's corner since i was so hurt...quoting from there:

m very sorry remo sir , but with due respect,

i love the idea of urs for sending contestant to top 6 but not the criteria for it...

as we saw D team was leading but just with one round, or say, one performance from other team, the other team won owing to the final showdown..it could have been summet's team too...

but what if the best performer for the day is not in the winning team?...isn't it unfair to that performer?...he gave his best, made us go speechless but he loses the golden opportunity...why?...just because his team couldn't score well?...m hurt..

Edited by ..Roopal.. - 10 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Jane Doe

@Jane_Doe

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

ps : just clarifying dont misunderstand the title as unfair selection of bajara girls for the top 6, they were amazing but i was talking about the process of selection n scoring seeming unfair

Quote

Bhavika

@bhavi09

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

I agree banjaara girls were good better but compared to their own previous banno wala act this was a lil good but not that excellent to be directly in top 6
that's what my point was if 1 is admitted to top6 every week .,then what will audience do there is audience voting included later
only remo decides top6?
and also 20 was ok but no scores to other participants is injustice to their talent direct nil in a single round ?? when the team was looking complete winner a few mins ago !!
and captains deciding is right to an extent the captains know strengths n weakness and vulnerability of their contestants too
if remo decides then biased ness allegations would be on him
better for captains

Quote

Jane Doe

@Jane_Doe

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: bhavi09
I agree banjaara girls were good better but compared to their own previous banno wala act this was a lil good but not that excellent to be directly in top 6
that's what my point was if 1 is admitted to top6 every week .,then what will audience do there is audience voting included later
only remo decides top6?
and also 20 was ok but no scores to other participants is injustice to their talent direct nil in a single round ?? when the team was looking complete winner a few mins ago !!
and captains deciding is right to an extent the captains know strengths n weakness and vulnerability of their contestants too
if remo decides then biased ness allegations would be on him
better for captains

Actually now that i think of it, the scores given doesnt have that captains contribuition so getting a power to choose in the end does make sense

Quote

akanksha

@sharif_lafungi

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

i guess more than banjara...it was v co to go direct in top 6
but alas...showdown was gamechanger

Quote

Bhavika

@bhavi09

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

yes but judging such a talent is my god I would have seriously be sitting on floor as a judge on a lighter note

Quote

Rishita Singh

@..Rish..

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

I agree partially. I agree ONLY to the point where you said that the marks distribution should have been like 20 - 15 - 10 and not just 20 - 0 -0 !!!

Also I really and genuinely felt that kathak duo were the best cause I didn't see anything new in the 2 brothers duo and in the ip hop duo , they was sync issue twice ( i noted it ) So they deserved it and ofcourse if Team Shakti won then definitely Shakti should have the say in choosing which 2 acts should go forward and the final say should be from Super Judge! Just the scoring is bit too harsh !!!

Quote

was the 20 mark round and top 6 selection fair??

Related Topics

Explore Topics