grey23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
apart from 2/3 performance it is clear to me that himruta always get marks more than what they deserve ( not their fault)..i feel apart from Ami j tomar performance and the one episode where ranbeer anushka came only in those 2 performances they deserved 30...but in every other epis they always get more marks...i feel that the judges and creatives are making their path clear for announcing a pre decided winner

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.9k

Users

10

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

Natkat thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Yes so true Chethan keeps on giving them 10s most of the time.Last week they did not deserve a 10 fromhim and also the time when amrutha flawed in a step. Chethan is partial to them. Other judges scores i cannot understand at all. They say one thing and they give the other scores.
grey23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Natkat

Yes so true Chethan keeps on giving them 10s most of the time.Last week they did not deserve a 10 fromhim and also the time when amrutha flawed in a step. Chethan is partial to them. Other judges scores i cannot understand at all. They say one thing and they give the other scores.

yes...i think judges r instructed to give them better marks ..because they clearly have pre decided winner in their head...and chetan is clearly partial towards them
Julie0001 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
@grey23 and Natkat

I think they provide an appealing narrative. They have been together for 11 years, both are personable and attractive. They dance well together. They represent a good story because they have been through a lot. Himmanshoo has not quite found the large success of other co-actors in the industry. He looks like potential that is waiting to be still discovered, although he has been around for a while. I think Chetan and the other judges can turn them into an appealing story.

I don't know if they will win but I think it was a mistake for Chetan to see them as the ideal couple and Himmanshoo as the ideal male. Rashmi and Nadish were shown from the start as having marital problems and they are working on it. I think Rashmi and Nadish's story because openly imperfect may at the end be more appealing.

The show initially portrays Amruta and Himmanshoo as ideal. But of course as the show progresses you can see the cracks in the relationship. It depends on perspective how serious you see these issues, but to me they do not appear ideal. There appears to me (only my opinion) that a lot lurks under the surface of happiness. They seem to carry a lot of grudges and it distorts the early picture. Therefore the strategy of advertising them as ideal initially may backfire. But who knows? I assume it is pre-determined and not by vote.

Edited by Julie0001 - 10 years ago
vibg thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: grey23

apart from 2/3 performance it is clear to me that himruta always get marks more than what they deserve ( not their fault)..i feel apart from Ami j tomar performance and the one episode where ranbeer anushka came only in those 2 performances they deserved 30...but in every other epis they always get more marks...i feel that the judges and creatives are making their path clear for announcing a pre decided winner


I agree. One of The early performance where Amruta didn't make the obvious lift, they were given marks.. Still. Why? They both r good dancers but please judges... Score on performance. Most recent performance... Everyone agreed... There wasn't a reason for chetan to give a 10. That one again was the most obvious way favoritism was showed. I don't know if they r predecided winners, but definitely an attempt is made to make them look better.
BollyPC thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Chetan is obviously biased to them... there's no doubt about that! From no angle was that a 10/10 performance.

Nach Baliye 7 is far from a reality show. It's scripted and edited to make couples look a certain way.

From day 1 it's been...

Himruta = ideal couple

UpMa = fake couple


10 weeks later...

Himruta = 7 vows, ideal couple

UpMa = 7 sins, evil couple

It was revealed in Miss Malini live chat that production gives them the songs, theme and even sometimes the dance form. So the themes the got are no coincidence. This is how they makers want to portray them.

This is the story line. No matter how many ex-Nach Baliye 7 sing praises about UpMa and vouch for them being good people, production will only show them as negative because every show needs a villain and when it's one of the most popular couples it creates buzz for their show.

Edited by Gauahargeous_N - 10 years ago
Julie0001 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
@Gauahargeous_N

Your point is interesting. Indeed from the beginning they are seen as the fake couple. I have a question for you though. Do you think that there were moments throughout the show where UpMa projected a bond that broke through the roles that were assigned to them? In other words, I agree with you that couples are placed in certain roles. But I also think that there are moments projected where the couples can break that mold set for them. What are characteristics do you think came out in the show of this couple that challenges this image?


I had no idea who UpMa was but I noticed that Upen is restrained and respectful when talking to Karishma. So that in a way allows them to escape the roles set for them.

rafalover4rever thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
This week yes I felt they did get more marks
But chetan has given abursd abursd marks to couples depending on their daily panchnama episodes

Other episodes I didn't feel they got more marks


Edited by migan - 10 years ago
rafalover4rever thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: grey23

apart from 2/3 performance it is clear to me that himruta always get marks more than what they deserve ( not their fault)..i feel apart from Ami j tomar performance and the one episode where ranbeer anushka came only in those 2 performances they deserved 30...but in every other epis they always get more marks...i feel that the judges and creatives are making their path clear for announcing a pre decided winner


Their first performance was also flawless
I agree this week they got more scores
But just because one couple is getting underscored that doesn't mean u say that other couple always got undeserving marks
Mepharm thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Julie0001

@Gauahargeous_N

Your point is interesting. Indeed from the beginning they are seen as the fake couple. I have a question for you though. Do you think that there were moments throughout the show where UpMa projected a bond that broke through the roles that were assigned to them? In other words, I agree with you that couples are placed in certain roles. But I also think that there are moments projected where the couples can break that mold set for them. What are characteristics do you think came out in the show of this couple that challenges this image?


I had no idea who UpMa was but I noticed that Upen is restrained and respectful when talking to Karishma. So that in a way allows them to escape the roles set for them.


You are very articulate in your views and writings👏

I am a himruta fan but that does not mean I dislike upma..just to clear ...😳
IMO they two are the most real couples on this show..

Upma have come a long way since the last show and they have found their soulmates...they have a positive influence on each other..upen was very negative early on but he has now found his anchor...as far as dancing ..nobody can take away their hard work and dedication...but IMO karishma is not naturLly graceful like Amrita is 😳 ...so personally himruta appeal more to me

I agree what you say about himruta...they are far from an ideal couple ...theirs a lot of turbulence under the calm waters...but the best part is they do not portray themselves as ideal...they are real and honest...it's the channel and creatives who have typecast them as something...
And so my respect from them has grown even more...after being portrayed as ideal they could have eAsily faked being so in front of the camera ...but they still choose to reveal their real selves...

I am not going to say anything about other couples...I personally dislike aishwarya ...she has a big ego and is very manipulative in front of the camera...she's shrewd she knows what she wants to be seen as and does exactly that...she needs constant fanning of her ego...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".