are u guys happy:;anti-ankita fans...huh

I dont understand....everyone was like against ankita...like she can't sing...she just performs....i m sure u guys will miss her from next episode and then u will see how much perfromance is needed with singing....and it wsn't like she ws singing bad...she ws a good singer also....and indian idol is a stage in which not only singing is needed....if u really want to only hear ppl sing then dont watch indian idol just hear it....and plz guys understand this indian idol is not a stage for playback singing....it is for performance with singing...bcos u not only hearing bt also watching.....l am really upset how ppl were against ankita without knowing the purpose of indian idol which is singing with performance....and its bcos of u guuys we hav missed ankita....

comments welcomed

but judges alwys keep saying they r lookin fr a playback singer 😕

when ppl leave at top 4 or top 5 we cant do nythin..coz everyone has to go and only one can remain..but i still lyk her..

SIZE=4]ya thts true that judeges were saying they want a playback singer....but if u really want a playback singer then why the hell do they tell them to perform....duh there sur will go lil bit if u perform....so stupid....

Originally posted by: zhaat

I dont understand....everyone was like against ankita...like she can't sing...she just performs....i m sure u guys will miss her from next episode and then u will see how much perfromance is needed with singing....and it wsn't like she ws singing bad...she ws a good singer also....and indian idol is a stage in which not only singing is needed....if u really want to only hear ppl sing then dont watch indian idol just hear it....and plz guys understand this indian idol is not a stage for playback singing....it is for performance with singing...bcos u not only hearing bt also watching.....l am really upset how ppl were against ankita without knowing the purpose of indian idol which is singing with performance....and its bcos of u guuys we hav missed ankita....

comments welcomed

I agree. For me, Indian Idol is not a contest where contestants come for PLAYBACK SINGING. I mean they could be for playback singing, but the main goal in my mind is for a COMPLETE PERFORMER---Stage, music videos, live, playback etc.

For playback singers, the right platform is SAREGAMA.

That is why even the mediocre Sargema contestants become Top 5 on Indian Idol. Any case, I guess everybody has different expectations from teh show.

But I loved Ankita. She for me was the most entertaining contestant on the show, and complete paisa vasool. I will really miss her.😭

ankita left this time .. means according to the one who were against her she sang veryyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy well in this GALA ..

COS , the one who sings well leaves ... godddddddddddd what the hell is this ??!!

Originally posted by: tpam

judges r themselves not clear abt their veiws!

agree

All judges have their views going in different directions. Anu Malik, since II1, has maintained he wants a singer who can perform equally well. Udit Narayan only looks at vocals--but then his support for Parleen & Prashant are questioned. Javed Akhtar is open to find anyone. He has supported performers & singers alike. Alisha.... oh well.

Yet, they keep changing their minds from week to week.

Keep in mind. The "IDOL" format is NOT to find the best singer. You can look at winners from UK, America, Canada, Australia, Norway, Sweden, South Africa, Malaysia, Iceland etc... Its not always that the best singer that wins. If it was about finding the best singer, the show should've been on radio. Also, if it was about the best singer, then the previous winners wouldn't have won. So thats that theory.

i am not anti ankita but i am happy with the result i think amit paul and emon are better singers and prashant has a good voice........the winner the indian idol actually dont get to star in a movie or they dont just make a music video...they need to record an album and thats the most important thing.....the anchors dnt say we'll make a video album and we will release your dvd they say the winner will get a music album and a car and all that. amit and emon undoubtedly will be a better choice for a music album and both sound great on stage i've seen the top 8 perform in concert and they are very good on stage and they look presentable not they are an ugly bunch of guys they'll look good even in music videos and prashant has a good voice atleast he will sound good in recording studio.... ankita was the weakest link in top 4 so i am not unhappy with the result. about radio and tv then let me clear this indian idol is about singing mainly and the judges do want performance but we dont watch tv just for performance..... lataji's concert, shankar mahadevan concert, pt.jasraj concert etc are also shown on tv not radio and these people dont "perform"

i'm not anti anki
i appreciated her aap jaisa
but she was the weakest singer in II3.

u all say tha II is not looking for playback singer, but altleast they are looking for a good singer, for that criteria also ankita falls. she's only a average singer.

if she was in your college or school will you ask her to take the pride of your institute and compete with other college for a intercollege trophy
or you ask the person who sings good.

that's it .

Originally posted by: soulfry

i am not anti ankita but i am happy with the result i think amit paul and emon are better singers and prashant has a good voice........the winner the indian idol actually dont get to star in a movie or they dont just make a music video...they need to record an album and thats the most important thing.....the anchors dnt say we'll make a video album and we will release your dvd they say the winner will get a music album and a car and all that. amit and emon undoubtedly will be a better choice for a music album and both sound great on stage i've seen the top 8 perform in concert and they are very good on stage and they look presentable not they are an ugly bunch of guys they'll look good even in music videos and prashant has a good voice atleast he will sound good in recording studio.... ankita was the weakest link in top 4 so i am not unhappy with the result. about radio and tv then let me clear this indian idol is about singing mainly and the judges do want performance but we dont watch tv just for performance..... lataji's concert, shankar mahadevan concert, pt.jasraj concert etc are also shown on tv not radio and these people dont "perform"

If the issue here is recording an album, then even the most horrendous singer on this planet could go into the recording studio and when you'll listen you won't be able to tell whether or whether not this person can sing.
And this show is not about finding the next Lata Mageshkar or Shankar Mahadhevan or whoever. Singers these days have to be much more than just a good singer---as put by Anu Malik.