Rate 2days performances! - Page 4

Originally posted by: Maya_M

I didn't watch the galas but still my overallrating

Prashant: 10/10

Emon: 0/10

Amit: 0/10

Ankita: 10/10

I have learnt music since childhood, Bengali, Classical, Ghazals and Movie songs. So i have knowledge of music and all Sa re ga ma pa since Sonu Nigam's time i gave my judgement and comments before the judges declare the results and informed to my Guruji's over phone and even one of my Boss who also had interest in singing as they are busy in their tuitions or recording etc. before the result declared and my Comments/Results were ALWAYS , I say ALWAYS ..... RIGHT . EXCEPT FOR ONE OCCASSION WHEN ANURADHA PODWAL CAME AND I FELT SHE WAS BIAS.

I KEEP WATCHING AND DOING THE SAME NOW ALSO FOR SAREGAMA PA AND VOI BUT IIF IS NOT A SINGING COMPETITION HENCE NOT MUCH IMPORTANCE IS GIVEN ON SINGING TALENT BY THE PUBLIC I SUPPOSE AND TO SOME EXTENT SOME JUDGES ALSO.

SO MY VOTE IS

10/10 Emon
9.5 /Amit
7/10 Prashant
5/10 Ankita

Well this is purely based on singing:
First round:
Emon - 9/10( a classic- no one can sing it like Sonu)
Amit - 9/10 - I think he could have put in more feeling, he is capable of much more
Prashant - 7/10 - Didn't really connect with him
Ankita - 6/10- Thought even Neha last year was better

Second round:
Emon- 10/10(excellent)
Amit - 9.5/10 - was expecting something more amazing from him
Ankita - 7/10- Better then the first, but not outstanding
Prashant - 6/10- No feel, just technical singing.

First round:
Emon - 10/10 Excellent
Amit - 9/10 - good
Prashant - 6/10 - after mukhda changed the channel
Ankita - 6/10- sur missing, aditi's rendition is still in my mind.

Second round:
Emon- 10/10 again excellent
Amit - 9.5/10 - technicaly .5 emon was better than him
Ankita - 5/10- horrible singing, murdered the song
Prashant - 5/10- again after mukhda i changed the channel to srgmp.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

I didn't watch the galas but still my overall rating

Prashant: 10/10

Emon: 0/10

Amit: 0/10

Ankita: 10/10

😆😆😆 i m assumin dat its a joke..rite???if not...then...wht can i say....