Did Sid play with Roshni's emotion??

rosesidni thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
DD and even many in the viewers feel that Sid played with Roshni's emotions😕😕 But I can't understand the reason for such a thought.. When did he do that??😲

The entire 3months, he kept her away without giving into his emotions. Even when Roshni apologized, he confessed that he loves her thinking that she was asleep, not to give her false hope😕 He didn't know she heard that.

The only weak point was the day before when he went to see Roshni in DD's house He asked her whether she would be with him, when he don't have anything. He did that b'coz he had made up his mind to be with Roshni even at the cost of leaving his house. He was equally excited but then he changed the decision seeing DD's plight. He didn't give her hope deliberately..😕

And I don't think Roshni would have agreed with Sid's decision if she knows he is doing it to get back DD's property. But I feel he could have told her the reason after divorce, even by breaking Simran's promise (I'm sure Simran would curse him if she knows that😡, but Sid could have taken that risk) And I think if in future, Roshni threatens him and demands an answer he would spill the beans. But Sid needs to be pressurized to break a promise, he won't do that willingly

So, in the entire fiasco I understand both SidNi are hurt by the circumstances but its wrong to say Sid played with Roshni's emotions.. I feel he is playing with his emotions more
Edited by zoopassion - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.2k

Users

7

Likes

23

Frequent Posters

skinnypal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
No, he made the decision for divorce just like 12-24 hours before the court hearing.. before that he was ready to be with her forever, not accept his mother's demands.. he was ready to fight for her against his own family..
the only fault i found with him yesterday was that he should have told her after the divorce when she confronted him.. he shouldn't have lied to her that time plus his thinking that he was being too selfish if he chose roshni was also wrong as this decision not only affected him it would have affected her as well..
And PROMISE? He made a deal that he will not tell his father.. what it's got to do with a promise that too which he made to his mother? He had made billions of promises to Roshni as well, most of them were broken! He will spill it out soon, or Roshni may find it out soon..
DD is delusional thinking that Sid played with Roshni.. that particular dialogue is never ending.. it started when they were not married and it continues till date!
madhuharini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Sid is very much right in his situations and he is a gem of man that no one can blame him... But I wish he could have said abt his mom's conditions to his dad without minding about the promise/secret. He is so nice and no need to be this nice to his evil mom when she cares abt his son's happiness 0%
He very helpless to do this😊 How much Roshni break down for DD's condition on that day, Sid is also equally worried for DD's condn... But his mom put him under this condition to leave his love breaking his heart😊
stephie34 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
I felt that Sid did not play with her emotions, you can clearly see how he told his mom non he cannot do what she is asking and then he went to Roshni and said how tomorrow will bring a new hope...But how cold hearted and selfish can we think Sid can be, he saw DD almost suffer a mental breakdown and he saw Roshni sitting crying to herself saying it was her fault...he could not bare all of that, so he went with the only option he thought he had and that was to divorce Roshni so in turn DD will be happy hence Roshni will also be happy...Sid fulfilled his last promise as a Jamaica that DD pride will be restored and that is exactly what he did...
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Interesting topic.

I wouldn't say that Sid played with Roshni's emotions. I think that's a serious and unfair allegation. I do, however feel that Sid made a HUGE mistake by accepting his mother's horrilble deal.

I know he did it for a noble cause. He has sacrificed his happiness (Roshni) but at the end of the day, he and Roshni deserve better.

They get a raw deal in all of this. Simran/Kritika and DD emerge as winners. But it's SidNi that will have to pay the ultimate price. Why should they have to be the ones at the receiving end every time?

rosesidni thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: skinnypal

No, he made the decision for divorce just like 12-24 hours before the court hearing.. before that he was ready to be with her forever, not accept his mother's demands.. he was ready to fight for her against his own family..

the only fault i found with him yesterday was that he should have told her after the divorce when she confronted him.. he shouldn't have lied to her that time plus his thinking that he was being too selfish if he chose roshni was also wrong as this decision not only affected him it would have affected her as well..
And PROMISE? He made a deal that he will not tell his father.. what it's got to do with a promise that too which he made to his mother? He had made billions of promises to Roshni as well, most of them were broken! He will spill it out soon, or Roshni may find it out soon..
DD is delusional thinking that Sid played with Roshni.. that particular dialogue is never ending.. it started when they were not married and it continues till date!



@bold In the deal Simran clearly told that Sid would not tell about this to ANYONE including Raj. So, that anyone would include Roshni too😕
Edited by zoopassion - 10 years ago
YD.AH thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
no he never played with her emotions
that is a too strong interpretation
he ripped and broke himself for sim
in the process roshni was also hurt
but he wanted dd to be happy
if dd is happy roshni too would be happy
plus sim also had told him not to tell any one
skinnypal thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: zoopassion



@bold In the deal Simran clearly told that Sid would not tell about this to ANYONE including Raj. So, that anyone would include Roshni too😕


She said anyone? Oh i thought she sad Raj specifically.. and he just promised her later on that no one will know about this.. 🥱
Millerrr88 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
He did and i'm disgusted by simran 😡😡
and idk why he can't tell roshni atleast 😕

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".