hevin9 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I used to be such a big big fan of this serial when it started, The freshness, the innocence of all the characters & the natural flawless acting of every single person was remarkable & impeccable. From Akshara to her parents, to the Singhania family every single character played it so simply & perfectly. But today the only true character that is left to the show is Dadi's. NONE other character is potraying that simplicity or perfection. If anything they are far from it. ESPECIALLY AKSHARA!!!!!
Karishma was doing a good job for a while but CV"S made her bite the dust too. Bana diya Akshara ka pankha ussey bhi. Agreed this serial is about the main CHaracter Akshara but above & beyond it is about Rishta. relations which cannot be complete without atleast 2 people. So in that case everyone is important. Not just Akshara...The SInghanias (earlier everyone, now a handful) & Maheshwaris sing this bhajan everyday in their house. "Harey Akshara , hare akshara...AKshara Akshara...Nakshara Naitik..."

BUt WHY ??? OMG!!!! The lady is epitome of overacting lately & its in your face OVERACTING. The fake quivering of her lips, the supersonic ultra fake stammering "hum hum hum...apne apne Capetown wale ghar ...ko hi , ko hi...apna apna ,ghar kahengey" WT funk girl? ...the in your face mockery of look i am crying...sympathize with me ...but hey where are my tears...?? Its appalling. WHy are the CV's doing this to the character ? They have stripped the girl of her innocense or she has done to her self. WHatever the reason its unbearable to watch her. Her mom & dadi do a better job of acting...The CVS have to decide if she is an independent strong woman who carries home & office & family & extended family of bro in law, co sisters & nanads & their wicked mother in law, her own brothers & sis in laws on her shoulders or she is this damsel in distress, who cannot even approach her mil.

She JUST cannot be BOTH. Nope try hard to please & convice yourself but this is no matter to fear & run away from temple or cry in your mum's pallu for. Had this been a question of Naitik being in coma i would have understood this reaction...But not in this situation. My point is why SO SO SO much of overacting from someone who did such a wonderfully job to begin with ?

I dont want to give up watching only coz of her daddi who always shows things in such a brighter & uncomplicated perspective. BUt Akshara is a turn off with her screen presence.

I know i will have a lot of people or most of them who will disagree with me cause they love her unconditionally but this is my perspective & your welcome state to yours.

IF there are CVS or other people who are related to the serial, please do something about it. Just looking sweet & glamorous onscreen is not enough. & EVERY character is contributing to the show. NOT AKSHARA alone. SO please value that role/character & their opinions they state onscreen ...Please dont make the other characcters read AKSHARA GITA all the time!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

1.2k

Users

7

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

mona.sweetypie thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
I totally disagree with your post topic maker..For me & my family only Hina as Akshara bind us still to watch this show other wise for us & she is doing more than justice to her character..Actually people can't feel the pain she had gone through in this tract & no one will under stand it if you don't like Akshara's character..You have problem with Akshara jaap mala in the show as the central main lead..This is the character which have faced lots of barriers in her journey & sacrificed every time from beginning till now..I want to ques what you will do when you heard some one said there is no babu & beta..It's not so easy for anyone to come closer..Every one is happy here if naitik's , duggu's bhajan mala will be done..The creatives have n't changed the attitude of Akshara after being dragged out for her house from bhabhi maa for no reason, As a viewer we ( my family) wished that creatives will show a change in her behavior but they still continue with this..this is the reason we watch this show off & on..But for us, Hina Khan has done beyond justice to her character & she has played each & every role so naturally & perfectly, we find no flaws in her acting..Who is perfect in this show? Neither Maheshwari's Nor Singhania's is my answer...One family live in Super mahaanta tags i.e. Singhania's & One family goes on keeping jaap of their jamai sa & his family...Whose dadi or her family won't even utter a word when their daughter was thrown from her house..In this show we find more bhajan mala of Singhania's elders & also the super tags given to each & every member of this..This mahaanta tag for every one not only for Akshara...Singhania's attitude is responsible if you feel Akshara's innocence & simplicity has lost..What do you think about other characters? Are they perfect? No..Akshara's character is the only one for which we attached & will attach still & felt & can feel every pain & happiness of her life ..This is what called pure natural acting if you feel closely for a fictional character..For my family Hina Khan is the brightest star of this show & Hats off to her for playing this role with her natural flair acting & also the audience like us who is still hooked to this show only & only becoz of her...Flaws in every character showed in this show..How can you forget munna & lalla jaap too much in this show?..My observation & whole family view.
Edited by mona.sweetypie - 10 years ago
vidyasharma thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
How can the topic maker say that Akshara is totally turn off on this screen..It's she & her acting capabilities & the way she has portrayed her character help this show to run this long..bhai yeh toh dekhna ka naazaria hain kuch log kewal characters & actors ke aandar kewal faults dekhte hain aur kuch logon ko wahi baat sabse appreciable lagti hain.. With Akshara's jaap most of the fans have problems but if others not? Why?..How can you say that every one have done or will do Akshara's jaapin the show but for me here more jaap of whole Singhania's especially daddaji family, gayatri, munna, lalla & now new joining in this list naira..Have n't you seen these things too?..Criticizing always one character & actor is very easybut if you really feel the pain, sufferings, happy moments of any character you can't write such things for any character& you can watch the show with every prospects..Yes for me too Akshara & Hina Khan is only binding force to watch this show as I & my family can relate myself /ourselves more with her..We too wish that creatives will provide different prospects too in different tracts but for them making Singhania's,Naitik, Duggu,Akshara & their relatives special treatment & mahaanta tag the only solution..far from realistic approach..
Edited by vidyasharma - 10 years ago
ruchika123 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Totally disagree with your post topic maker..Akshara's character given more importance only & only bcoz this character suffered/suffers/still suffering the most..No other character suffer the pain which Akshara's character felt/will feel..May be your outlook to judge actors acting is different but for me Hina Khan the perfect Akshara for me & She has played the role with great conviction , command & her natural ability & that's reason Hina Khan as an actor & Akshara as a character very close to mass of audience watching this show & her true class acting abilities has helped her won maximum awards for the show & also the most prestigious Dada Saheb phalke award last year..Her acting abilities has won laurels for her & her character truly...I am a proud fan of Hina Khan & always appreciate her natural acting skills ..Hats off to her.
Edited by ruchika123 - 10 years ago
pj2h14 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
How can topic maker one dialogue delivery which you have specially mentioned can tell an actor is good/brilliant/ over actor..How can you judge this? I don't know but for me you have some hatred for one character as well as an actor..The reason you better know..Kya Akshara ko temple mein bhabhi maa ko gale lagana chahiya tha bajai ghar aakar apni maa se dukh share karke...How can you say that Akshara is wrong there..Are other actors face similar problems what she (Akshara) faced or facing...Are Akshara's dadi, mom are dragged out from their house..What type of dadi & mom they are, not effected by anything even after their daughter dragged out from her house & was forced to leave the place, faced terrible pain of ten yrs., hatred from some in-laws members for no reason..kya Akshara dadi aur uske maa-baap ko bhabhi maa se apni ladki ke behalf mein nahin bolna chahiya tha..kon se maa-baap, dadi aaj kal ke jamane mein chu rehta hain..Shiksa dena bahut aasan hota hain, problem , pain , sufferings of any person will be known only if same thing will happen with them..Akshara ki dadi aur family ko jamai sa aur unki family ki puja karne ke alawa kuch kaam nahin aata..joh apne bache ke liye kuch nahin kar sakte woh perfect kaise ho sakte hain..According to me, both the families are not reasonable on their terms..it's more a fictional show nothing else..Ek ko mahaan banna hain & Ek ko mahaan bananaa hain..kuch nahin ho sakta is show ka..
Edited by pj2h14 - 10 years ago
vim916 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
So but I watch the show for naksh only and they still have the same charm that they had when the show started sorry trp speaks itself if it was not for naksh the show would not have gone this far
.StarryPhoenix thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Constructive Criticism: any feedback that is purely intended to improve someone else's work in future endeavors! India-forums.com Code of Conduct strictly forbids members from bashing celebrities, the characters they portray on screen and fellow members! This includes the use of foul language, as well as any personal remarks, i.e. how the actor looks like, as they have no control over it! We welcome members to share their constructive criticism on the absurdity of the series' story line and character, as well as to discuss the actor's talents, however, please refrain from engaging in any kind of bashing, which may have severe consequences. Thanks

Topic Closed
-YRKKH DT

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

3 months ago

Personality badalte characters...

What the heck has happened in last few weeks... Seems like drop of trp has same effect as apple drop on Newton... Just that Newton chose logical...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

4 months ago

Kiara is acting like a dumbass

When Kiara stayed silent about Abhiru's relationship, I thought she will do something really witty and teach Abhiru a good lesson. But here she...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

4 months ago

Abhimanyu-Akshnav fans should stop the blame game on mere characters!!

Abhir is doing an EMA out of his free will. It's not because he is Abhimanyu's blood nor because he was raised by Akshnav. He is having an...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

4 months ago

Praise acting all you want but dialogues were 😷

Ok ... Chalo maan liya Samriddhi is good in this scene... But Like seriously... Bina kids ke zindagi adhuri hai aap ki toh fgs ADOPT kar lo!!!...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nivi26

5 months ago

Gareebi ki method acting

DKP wale hamesha jabardasti ki gareebi dikhaate hain. Unhe gareebi bhi koi costume lagta hai. Waise to hamesha apni stories me family,...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".