Vidya's Kahaani or PC's Mary Kom?

😉 I love both actresses. But some have said both these performances and movies are overrated. Please share your thoughts. Should be an interesting discussion. 😊

Neither is Kahaani the movie or Vidya's performance in it overrated.

Both were exceptional. I rate Kahani as the best thriller I have seen from BW.

PC was great as Mary Kom but the movie was a below average affair. Too long, unnecessary details like the romantic angle and way too much patriotic element involved. That is not how you make a biopic. It depicts the real life story, not made to suit you agenda bullshit.

Originally posted by: zaaratq

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Vidya and Kahaani over PC and Mary Kom anyday!! I think PC as Jhilmil would be a better comparison... If so, then BOTH for me, maybe a little more for Jhilmil, cos she made me cry and feel for her.. Vidya has good acting in Kahaani as well, but I couldnt relate to her..
</font>

Jhimil is clearly better than Kahaani or Mary Kom.
Both actresses are icons. I love both their work. 😊

Originally posted by: -Arsal-

Neither is Kahaani the movie or Vidya's performance in it overrated.

Both were exceptional. I rate Kahani as the best thriller I have seen from BW.

PC was great as Mary Kom but the movie was a below average affair. Too long, unnecessary details like the romantic angle and way too much patriotic element involved. That is not how you make a biopic. It depicts the real life story, not made to suit you agenda bullshit.

Mary Kom had a lot of potential. SLB ruined it. 😡

Never saw Mary Kom 😆😆

Originally posted by: Rhino2close2car

Never saw Mary Kom😆😆

What about Jhilmil? 😉

Originally posted by: ShantiAshtangi

Jhimil is clearly better than Kahaani or Mary Kom.
Both actresses are icons. I love both their work. 😊

I wouldn't say clearly better. Kareena in Talaash, PC in Barfi and Vidya in Kahaani were all fabulous performances. Rani too though her role was shorter. You can pick anyone over the other (it would be by a whisker though) but all are right about the same for me.

Acting of the highest order. No stupid songs, over the top dramatic moments or dialogues etc.; which is what we used to seeing in BW. Just putting a character in a situations and the letting it blossom out on screen.

The funny thing is that all of the these three movies came out in 2012. What a year that was for movies.

*Spoilers*
The climax of Kahaani where Vidya pull out the water bag, stabs the guy in the foot and then proceeds to shoot his brains out, was amazingly shot and acted in. I had goosebumps watching and nearly fell off my chair. Vidya has totally me believing that he was a pregnant woman up to that point and then that she was well capable of pulling off a murder.👏👏

Originally posted by: -Arsal-

I
wouldn't say clearly better. Kareena in Talaash, PC in Barfi and Vidya
in Kahaani were all fabulous performances. Rani too though her role was
shorter. You can pick anyone over the other (it would be by a whisker
though) but all are right about the same for me.

Acting of the
highest order. No stupid songs, over the top dramatic moments
or dialogues etc.; which is what we used to seeing in BW. Just putting a character in a situations and the letting
it blossom out on screen.

The funny thing is that all of the these three movies came out in 2012. What a year that was for movies.

<font size="4">*Spoilers*</font>
The
climax of Kahaani where Vidya pull out the water bag, stabs the guy in
the foot and then proceeds to shoot his brains out, was amazingly shot
and acted in. I had goosebumps watching and nearly fell off my chair.
Vidya has totally me believing that he was a pregnant woman up to that
point and then that she was well capable of pulling off a murder.👏👏

Sad we don't have good movies like this much anymore. Anuskha did great with NH10. 2015 could
get better. Let's see. 😊

Come on guys, no more opinions? 😊