Tell me honestly........

Guys i m not supporting anyone here neither Nandini nor Manik

I m just pointing the word "TRUST" n "I HATE U" track based on this...seriously CV's this is the reason...or is this again to send Manik on guilt trip

Guys we have all seen the character of Manik from start n even Nandini...
His cruelty,his deadly nature,his rudeness etc etc
her tolerance ,her softness,her friendly nature

so some points to highlight about Manik n Nandini

He tried or i shud say gave a taste of death to Harshad when Cabir got hospitalized...
N when Nandini got attacked by Chudail...Manik said to Harshad "One cut on her n i wud have cut ur throat with this"...where Nandini witness his madness when she saw bruises on his palms
He fought with the guy who misbehaved with Nandini during the Poll/Secret ballot

He loved her but never acknowledged that how extent he is going for her,did he ever said that he ll not harm anyone

She saw his madness, she saw his cruelty,she saw his protective side for his friends...
She even saw his good side but only for her n Fab5...beyond that no one
She said "tum acche ho" but he said "nahi banna mujhe accha"[shower scene]
So i dont think she was wrong...she dint lie...instead she said truth

So here my question is...Y he is thinking that she cant doubt him...who is just with him from few months...may b later he ll realize when he ll get to know that even his friends also doubted him who r with him from years

My actual question is....."Agar Nandini ko chot lagti toh Manik Chudail ko Marta ya nahi"...?/"If at all Nandini got seriously injured Manik wud have killed/hurt Chudail or not"

and his question was baseless...based on Nandini's character how can he ask that "Agar main tumhari jagah hota n koi kehta ki tumne maara hai...i wud have said no bcz i trust u"

Even if she is in his place she wud have not killed anyone bcz she knows the calue of life

So i think here CV's have done a mistake i guess...somewhere again it ll lead to a guilt track for Manik

Tell me honestly...answer my question

Do u ppl really feel this Hate track is justifiable on this scenario

May b i cudnt justify my post...so plz can someone come up n talk from two sides...

I think most of them dint like my previous post ...i repeat i seriously dint connect to the TRUST part ...

Due respect to Parth n Niti they nailed it...no doubt...i have issues with CV's...so u guys can answer if interested

she has hurt him, that's a truth

Originally posted by: Miminits

she has hurt him, that's a truth

but the hate track seems a bit far-fetched, both are only "friends'. not even bf-gf yet, yes they have deeper feelings for each other still they arent even a real couple yet

so break-up seems strange

😕

That's what i m saying...going into dark n all is a bit much more to this...

if we see that way then he hurted her more...by saying somany things...till date

or i shud say Nandini has given him more imp in her life...

How can he get hurt when his character tells that he can do anything in anger...

i understood one thing is that on every aspect he cant take a NO for him thats it

Here definitely someone has to show him mirror

The thing is tat Manik is an extreme character. Friendship or no friendship? Love or hate? Trust or mistrust? Yes or no? People dun evn dare come near him because it is just his friends.. he can't even be friendly with anybody.. until Nandini came in.. they both understand each other, but for him either it is trust or mistrust. Even a sec of doubt is too much for him. The evolving in his character is much needed. He needs to understand that life is not a courtroom with just 2 options at a given tym.. he needs to understand that sometimes things look worse than they really are.

Manik is extreme be it with his nager or love ..he is extreme ..but he would never kill anyone ..he might hurt them badly ..but he wouldnt kill anyone ...he is broken kid ..who always lived in darkness ..and the thing is for him his frends ,that is his most valued relation ship should have complt TRUST in him ...rmeber when dhruv raised his hands agaisnt him during goon fiasco ..the thing which hurted him was dhruv thought manik sent the goons ..it wasnt that dhruv raised his hands..for this boy TRUST is very impt ..and nandini for a moment had doubts on him ..for him trust is blind ..he was experincing the happiness of being in light but nahh ..he lost it ..just becz of the lack of trust ..

well it depends if his I hate you is same as nandanis in farm house then its ok and if in next few episodes when they show him coming out of initial shock of what she said and he try to understand her pov and thinks back to all the things he did then its ok but if they drag it and show like he really hates her then I think I will be making one of those I quit posts.

I will hate it if Nandini sheds tears and goes behind Manik pleading with him to forgive her. Seriously, it's okay for Manik to break the trust by pushing her to Dhruv without asking her but he can't forgive her for telling the truth based on evidence? Nandini had every reason to believe that Manik could be guilty.I would want the CV's to give that girl some self respect and make her concentrate on her Career. She can make new friends and hangout with them. She can also take a trip to Mangalore. Let the new Guy fall for her and let her get friendly with him. This time I want Manik to realize that he can't live with out her and not the other-way round.

i agree with u...

no one can be blamed...

manik s a character with lots of diff shades... he s hurt bcoz whom he loves more than anything thought he can do something like that... remember the scene where nandu was drunk n accused him of torturing n making shahid trying to suicide... at that time itself he doesnt wanted nandini to have a doubt on him n he instantly said he always had it covered...

he can tolerate any one thinking he s bad n cruel... but when it comes to nandini he wants he to believe him... this is d reason why he s hurt... so justified...

he said he hates her s more like he felt he lost everything again,... she brought light into his life,... n some where down the line she showed that she doesnt believe in him... so i m not ready to go by the word HATE too much... because all said in an impulsive moment cant be taken soo seriously...

for nandini during harshad incident she dint find dhruv near by when she searched... n she has always seen d impulsive manik who can go to any extend to take revenge if his loved ones are being harmed... so nandini after seeing d video thinking that manik has done it accidently s also justified...

for me its all matter of time... with more calm mind both should think again...

n they cant stay away for long... they have proved it a lot of times... so i m happy with this track also... because it will bring more intensity to both the characters n their relation/...