Personally I think Ranveer and Arjun are on equal footing in terms of 'star power'.
Just focusing on Ranbir, Ranveer, Arjun, because I know nothing about Sid, Varun, Aditya. Ranbir is clearly the leader in terms of star power but even he doesn't have true star power, he won't be able to draw the crowds in for a crap film like the Khan's can.
Ranveer and Arjun are well liked but need a good film to really do well. I just watched Tevar's trailer and I think it's done better than Kill Dill because it looks like a proper masala film, Salman Khan style. Kill Dill was just a bit weird, it didn't know what it wanted to be. They tried going for a stylized action film but there were too many other things going on for that to work. Tevar looks like a straight crowd pleaser.
7