Girls VS Boys????

I don't understand why everyone is making a big deal about girls voted out. I think so far the girls who were voted out were not performing well and this was the first time that all the bottom three were girls. And if they r so desperate for a girl to win then it should not be an open competition. I think so far the judging was honest and the boys were singing much better than the girls thats why they have the top spots. The only girl who was performing and singin well was Ankita and she was safe this time.

If it was a boys vs girls competition then they could have done it the FG way and let the jori win a girl and a boy so everyone could be happy..

What is ur opinion on this??BTW I am a girl but I want the good talent to come out not someone because she is a girl.

No way, Deeps and Pooja were much much better than most of the guys in the competition. They didn't deserve to be in the bottom 3 that day. If as you say talent should win why should we overlook girls talent? What Javed ji said was so true. For people to admit that a girl is good she has to work 3 times as hard as a boy, otherwise why would anyone think that Parleen, Abhishek, Chang and Prashant all who did worse than Deeps and Puja that day deserve to be sitting there in their places while these girls who gave it their best stand in the danger zone.
And by any chance the girls give a below par performance you can bet your life on it that everyone is going to have them for lunch saying they should go home. but if one of their favs don't do well then we say please give them another chance, they'll come back(i myself have done this) so why give a chance to someone who's been performing below par for 4 weeks and take away the chance of someone who has only done bad one week. This is a talent competition not a place to find the cutest boy to take home.

I also want a good talent to be the Idol may it be boy or girl ..we agree on that point ...but I disagree on other points ...

I think overall the girls this year r much better than the boys ...

But I have noticed other topics where people r giving justification of how Charu should go ...

and I am tired of telling people yes Charu should go but not at this point ..there r at least 2 other worse singers(guys) than her who r performing bad gala after gala ...

But I'll stop saying all these and let u all discuss on this issue because the mindset of this forum has changed completely and I don't see the old members coming here anymore ....

So I rest my case ...

Deepali Puja were much better den a few boys, namely prashant and abshiek yet they came in bottom 2, and didnt deserve to be dere. Even charu was better den Prashant. Yes i agree smita, jolly and richa deserved to go at dat time only due to performances, however this time it shud have been prashant if we luk at only performances. 😊 I personaly like prashant but this is the truth. 😊

Sidrom is 100% right!
As for bottom 4.. its a big drama. Elimination counts and uptil now all elimintations are ok except Smitha (who got out for her looks & we are sorry about that but II format does require one to have acceptable looks both girls & boys).

TRP rating are everything. Dont read too much into bottom 4 fiasco.

Originally posted by: cool_pooja

Deepali Puja were much better den a few boys, namely prashant and abshiek yet they came in bottom 2, and didnt deserve to be dere. Even charu was better den Prashant. Yes i agree smita, jolly and richa deserved to go at dat time only due to performances, however this time it shud have been prashant if we luk at only performances. 😊 I personaly like prashant but this is the truth. 😊

I totally agree with you. Prashant and chang were really bad and the girls were better than them...but the point is sony started this girl drama this week and this was the first time all teh girls were in the danger zone before that even emon was there when he didnt perform well. So it was going all fair before they started this whole drama making the girls look mazloom and wants everyone to pity them .They dont need peoples sympathy when they were getting votes by performing well.

Originally posted by: Sidrom

I don't understand why everyone is making a big deal about girls voted out. I think so far the girls who were voted out were not performing well and this was the first time that all the bottom three were girls. And if they r so desperate for a girl to win then it should not be an open competition. I think so far the judging was honest and the boys were singing much better than the girls thats why they have the top spots. The only girl who was performing and singin well was Ankita and she was safe this time.

If it was a boys vs girls competition then they could have done it the FG way and let the jori win a girl and a boy so everyone could be happy..

What is ur opinion on this??BTW I am a girl but I want the good talent to come out not someone because she is a girl.

This is not a joke.. people dnt vote 4 girls. Majority audience r girls n they vote 4 cute looking guys like Chang. This is a bitter reality so accept it..

Originally posted by: aoch

This is not a joke.. people dnt vote 4 girls. Majority audience r girls n they vote 4 cute looking guys like Chang. This is a bitter reality so accept it..

I agree Chang is still there because of his cuteness but the rest r getting votes for their performance. Amit was voted out. Now his performance can speak for him self and so is Ankita 's thats why they were in the safe zone.

Originally posted by: bruno4

I also want a good talent to be the Idol may it be boy or girl ..we agree on that point ...but I disagree on other points ...

I think overall the girls this year r much better than the boys ...

But I have noticed other topics where people r giving justification of how Charu should go ...

and I am tired of telling people yes Charu should go but not at this point ..there r at least 2 other worse singers(guys) than her who r performing bad gala after gala ...

But I'll stop saying all these and let u all discuss on this issue because the mindset of this forum has changed completely and I don't see the old members coming here anymore ....

So I rest my case ...

I am not saying that Charu should go or not but I am not in favor of the issue that they have created out of nothing. And if you look at the previous posts before the results were even out , almost all of us suggested that charu should be out regardless of her being a girl. She was not performing well and thats why she is out. its simple as that it has nothing to do with her being a girl or a boy.

it is not an issue out of nothing. the truth is that deepali and pooja both did not deserve to be in the bottom four but they were there. it is like when emon was in the bottom four and anuji was shocked and when bhavin got eliminated and the judges did not think it was fair. the difference this time was that 3 girls were in the danger zone which shouldn't have been that way.