Originally posted by: -Purva-
Ali has been wrong with respect to the housemates from the beginning. Soon as he entered, he began talking of what he's seen and the impression he has of the people. He should've let the people talk to him. He's given no one time to understand him at all.
Given that he had entered the house in middle of the night, there was no need to keep people awake to talk to him. The P3GS gang was especially hard hit because they sleep in the living room, so the whole-night movement might've upset them a lot.
Like you rightly said that leadership is not about giving orders. Ali seriously lacks that quality. Praneet and Minisha are the only people I've seen in the house (so far) who seem to have that knack in them.
Even his attempts to entertain people were like "everyone drop whatever you are doing, we're going to have an entertainment program". Seriously people are NOT going to respond to that. Plus the song he sang was pathetic to say the least.
Ali's style is more towards - humiliating people. It's obvious people are going to be upset with him. You have to give people the respect and space.
Yes. He wanted to show housemates, yo man, I know what shyte you have been upto, no messing with me brah, and I would start immediately to deliver your just desserts. It doesn't work that way. it didn't work when salman from outside and a much more high profile person tried to do it, in 175% softer tone, why would other's listen to his khabardari.
As it is the house is full of deluded clueless people. And he openly showed his partiality to P3G gang, anyone would take his comments with a pinch of salt.
Ali, can be a good leader imo. He is smart.
Sushant, who arguably is the smartest guy in the house ( don't be fooled by that diva attitude, he has a industrial physcology degree), who understands strategie the best decoded Ali in 2 minutes in todays epi.
he went about his task well too, bringing people out of comfort zone, showing people's mistakes or back biting.
but his whole punishment and quoting captain at drop of hat were providing negative connotation.
He has plenty of tact, and he was not at all aggressive with gautam and Praneet.
I think he was impatient to show them what audience thinks of them and start changing them asap, it was not prudent of him to act out of his pre conceived notion from what he saw on the TV, without giving a fair chance to himself and the housemates to know each other.
Either that, or he has been strictly briefed by BIgg Boss to up the heat quotient of the house. When the biggest TRp grabbing issue of the 5 weeks are an outside affair and airing its laundry on show, or 45 minute of drama of has been diva or physical heckling of a contestant by a crazy contestant, you know the house needs some action.