Where does that leave Sony's Indian Idol - Page 2

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

some of the singers frm II-3 wuoldnt even be able to pass the auditions of ASVOI.....the quality of singers there is jsut superb!

I agree with u there...but somehow i get the feeling tht even though the singers are good....the performances seem like the pre-recorded or something.....i dunno yyy but i find something fishy wit ittt....😕

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

some of the singers frm II-3 wuoldnt even be able to pass the auditions of ASVOI.....the quality of singers there is jsut superb!

I so agree with you! The judges there close their eyes and listen instead of looking at the style and performance! If some of the II contestants go their..the judges will stop them in the middle of their singing like they have done before!!..but all the shows are good in different ways. Indian Idol looks for style and singing..Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2007 looks for singers all around the world..and ASVOI looks for the most well trained singer in all around India. So every show has its ups and downs..one show may have one thing attractive and the other may have something else that attracts the viewers. The good thing is all shows bring people to fame for us!😉..I believe "Fame brings style" hehe..*Just my view of the shows😊*..but all three shows ROCK!!!!!!!!😳...II is gonna rock..galas are on its way!! can't wait for tomorrow!..Our hottie Zayed Khan and one of the best singer Sunidhi Chuhan are coming!! wohoooo..and our rocking contestants..they are going to rock the show!!!!!😃

I think the VOI and SRGMP are great shows which brings great singers .. SRGMP has produced good singers in the past who have done amazingly well in the industry ... Indial Idols have not produced the quality of singers that these other shows get.

The ratings at indiantelevision.com is right.

Here they are for 3-9 June

08/06/2007 STAR VOICE OF INDIA 6.4
09/06/2007 STAR VOICE OF INDIA 5.9

08/06/2007 SAREGAMAPA CHALLENGE 2007 6.4
09/06/2007 SAREGAMAPA CHALLENGE 2007 5.4

09/06/2007 INDIAN IDOL-3 5.8
08/06/2007 INDIAN IDOL-3 5.3
07/06/2007 INDIAN IDOL-3 4.9
06/06/2007 INDIAN IDOL-3 4.3
05/06/2007 INDIAN IDOL-3 4.1
04/06/2007 INDIAN IDOL-3 4.1

no matter what II will be in the lead 👏

Nah Sony will be fine. All the contestants are great now. 😉 They know how to sell themselves and they will do a great job with that.

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

I agree with u there...but somehow i get the feeling tht even though the singers are good....the performances seem like the pre-recorded or something.....i dunno yyy but i find something fishy wit ittt....😕

yes even i agree with you. the singers are so perfect. even experienced singers when they are singing on stage live dont sing as well as the svoi contestants. so even i feel that the performances are pre-recorded.

my family prefer watching svoi. so maybe ppl in general prefer it as they feel they have better singers. not everyone would smell a rat.

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

yes even i agree with you. the singers are so perfect. even experienced singers when they are singing on stage live dont sing as well as the svoi contestants. so even i feel that the performances are pre-recorded.

my family prefer watching svoi. so maybe ppl in general prefer it as they feel they have better singers. not everyone would smell a rat.

Since what they are showing in SVOI right now is only audition round and the way judges have stopped singers midway and asked them to leave, i do not think they are pre-recorded.

Yes they are pre-recorded and edited when they show it to us but this is the case with all the other shows as well.

Indian Idol s becoming more of an Anu and Alisha show .Its disgustng to see their domination n selection of people with zero talent .