Judges..wastes or important?

Hey evryone..

i want to ask u all..how much importance do u give to judges comments?Do u take ur decision after listening to judges comments or u mak ur choice on ur own?

And if u do think judges comments are very important den who do think is most honest and impartial judge?

Take care

Ankita

most of them comments made by judges are senseless..i care less for their comments 😆

I just noticed dat in judges vs judges too debaters are given same topic..seriously i made dis post widout even seeing dat topic..so i moderators want dey can close dis topic.. 😃

noo anku thts not a prob..here everyone can give their views.. but in that thread only 4 can debate 😃

Lol..Its better we take our own decision

Originally posted by: buttercup

most of them comments made by judges are senseless..i care less for their comments 😆

umm i wont say all of dem are senseless but yeah most of dem are dat way only..i mean Alisha is a biased judge..and udit jee dont noe wat to say..except lekin and acc to him till date 12 ppl r in top 5..😆😆Javed jee is honest but sometyms he also makes mistakes..but byfar javed jee is most sensible judge..acc to me..😃

Originally posted by: buttercup

noo anku thts not a prob..here everyone can give their views.. but in that thread only 4 can debate 😃

thnks😳

Originally posted by: kothra

Lol..Its better we take our own decision

so huzi bhai u think judges are good for nothing..and even if judges wont be dere we will be able to mak our choices?😕

Well my opinion is 50-50 i mean i agree with the comments of the judges sometimes but most of the time i go for my own opinion.Though i believe javed akhter is the most honest judge inspite of the fact that he criticize suhit alot.

frankly..i vote only by the singing..and to me..all judges are partial..or show some kindda enimity with the contestants!!

Originally posted by: madzey

Well my opinion is 50-50 i mean i agree with the comments of the judges sometimes but most of the time i go for my own opinion.Though i believe javed akhter is the most honest judge inspite of the fact that he criticize suhit alot.

he critices suhit bcoz suhit is honestly not a good singer..and bcoz of him true talent is being not supported..but i guess yeah javed jee is being harsh at tym abt suhit..but if other judges lyk alisha supports him even if he sing totally totally flat den even if javed jee critices him even if he sang in surs at some pts is not a big thing..😃

Originally posted by: craziegal

frankly..i vote only by the singing..and to me..all judges are partial..or show some kindda enimity with the contestants!!

dere i agree wid u dat all judges are partial..even javed jee is partial wid Ankita.but hes bestudit jee is not partial but he dont hav any opinion of his own..he cant stand wid any opinion..😆