Was Jalal a fool? Was he in cahoots with Nigar? Was it all a dream?

skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Friends, after my long talks with the Zee man on Thursday, that the war will be only next week and that Jalal is not a bewakoof but is shrewdly planning and using teda tactics for the war - and after he gave the absolutely same news to both Ela and Preet who later called him - I have two choices now.

One choice I have is to see the serial as it was happening on screen yesterday and assume that the Zee man was wrong. I have to see the serial at face value where a sort of starting war was shown yesterday itself, and where Jalal was being shown as utterly foolish enough to fight with few soldiers and to so easily fall into the enemy trap of Nigar and Abul Mali.

The other way is to try and see if what the Zee man said can still be right. I have to try and see if in spite of what is being shown in the episode there is some plan of a clever Jalal working in the background. I have to see if what we saw yesterday was itself the "war" or it was just the beginning of some bigger action next week, as the Zee man suggested.

When I spoke to the Zee man he sounded so strong in his conviction that I feel as if I should try and see the serial now from the way he described it than to just see the superficialities and condemn the script. I am in my own mind also questioning if the Creatives will really show Jalal as so stupid, especially when history says Jalal never ever got caught by anyone. So keeping the convictions of both the Zee man and my own beliefs in mind, I am deliberately choosing to look at the potential positives in the script that may be hidden from our view as yet. I refuse to believe the Creatives will show such a stupid bewakoof Jalal.

So first let me take stock of what happened yesterday and try to see where Jalal could have been one step cleverer than his enemies, or why the Creatives have been showing what they did ...

Yesterday in the episode two things happened. Firstly after Jalal and Abul Mali, heading their armies, gave each other lalkaars and then gave pep-talks to their own armies, the two armies clashed on the battlefield. There were just about six people on horses, including Jalal and Mali and all the rest were just foot soldiers. Atga told a rather ordinary looking sipahi to keep close to Jalal as his bodyguard, and then went on to his own position. The two armies then clashed with swordfights, while Jalal and Abul Mali took on each other directly. Midway through the skirmish, Mali got on his horse and bolted, and Jalal did the same and bolted after Mali. Mali thus dragged Jalal to a desolate countryside spot where they continued hand to hand fight. The war front thus went out of our view, and we got to see just the close up fight of Mali and Jalal.

Some men of Mali's turned up whom Jalal started tackling in full earnest, but Mali then did a trick on Jalal. Jalal's own supposed idiotic bodyguard was nowhere on the scene. Mali shouted to Jalal that he was double-crossing this stupid girl Nigar, and he was going to see to it that she is finished off since he was just using her to start this war with Jalal. He shouted to his men to go immediately and kill Nigar, while he kept on fighting with Jalal. Hearing this, Jalal threw off Mali with great vigour and mounted his horse and ran to save his Nigar Apa who seemed to have been cheated and used by this Abul Mali and Mahchuchak. On approaching Nigar, he found her tied to a tree, but unexpectedly not belligerent. In fact she kept saying she had seen through the subterfuge of Mali and Mahchuchak and was now firmly on Jalal's side. She said she wanted to apologise to Jalal for all the misunderstanding she had about him. Jalal seemed to believe it all and was dead certain he now wanted to save Nigar from the clutches of Mali. At one point in the brother-sister talks, Nigar said "Let's go somewhere safer, let's not linger here". She led Jalal to a place she knew that would be safe and it turned out to be a sort of surang or cavern. In there, Jalal looked totally disoriented - when suddenly Nigar hit Jalal on the head felling him to the ground, and there appreared Mali beside Nigar ... and the two of them said they had trapped the great Jalal and he was at their mercy and a prisoner of Mahchuchak!

If it wasn't utterly ridiculous, this whole thing would be extremely funny! How in hell would the great Jalaluddin Mohammed Akbar of the great Sultanate of Hindustan fall so easily and so dumbly to the very "easy-as-pie" saazish of the Mali-Nigar combination? I am unable to believe this is the real Jalal and the Zee man's words to Preet is also ringing in my ears. The Zee man had told Preet especially that "Jalal was never captive by anyone and promo is twist don't investigate much on it ". The Zee man had, as you all know also told me that Jalal would never have gone into the war with so few men unless he wanted to deliberately create that impression with his enemies and the real war would start only next week..

So then I had to again put on my thinking cap and see what the twist could be that Jalal would have used yesterday? Why did he appear to make a set of very foolish decisions? Why did he follow Mali out of the battlefield to a lonely deserted patch of countryside? Which King will ever abandon the army on the battlefield to follow Mali to a separate lonely patch of land? Why did Jalal fall for the line that Mali was going to kill Nigar? Why did he then rush to Nigar? Why did he believe the sudden U-turn that Nigar took as she apologised to him? Why after that did he follow Nigar to the lonely cavern, without any of his sipahis in tow? AND MOST IMPORTANTLY ... ONCE NIGAR AND ABUL MALI HAD JALAL THERE, WHY DID THEY NOT JUST FINISH HIM OFF WHICH WOULD HAVE BEEN EASY? WHY DID THEY KEEP HIM CAPTIVE INSTEAD?

Something is fishy about this whole sequence yesterday, isn't it. The thing is that it is not only looking foolish, it is looking incredible and not real.

My strongest hunch is therefore that it could it all have been a dream that someone dreamt in the night before the war and as the Zee man said will the real war begin only on Monday.
There's a very strong possibility of that!
Maybe Jodha or even Jalal himself or someone close to Jalal must have had this bad dream as if the war has started, Jalal has been tricked and trapped and he is in the cuctody of Nigar and Abul mali. In fact it could also be Nigar's hopeful dream. (But then if it was a dream, is the precap also part of the dream where Todarmal confirms to all the ladies that Jalal is indeed trapped?)

Alternatively, was Jalal a bit smarter than Mali, and when he went and had the talks with Nigar, did Jalal strike a new deal with Nigar to act as captive but help her double-cross Mali and Mahchuchak?

I am not sure yet what the twist may be but I cannot AT ALL believe that Jalal would ever have been as foolish as he was shown yesterday, and so I am going to wait for the Zee man's prediction that the capture of Jalal is "just a twist and we should all not investigate too much on it". The Zee man is very sure the real war will start only on Monday and that Jalal will have some teda method by which he will best his enemies with a much larger force than he pretended to have. Meanwhile I will rather stew all weekend than believe that Jalal could be really as absurd as he was shown yesterday! My own hunch is that this was all someone's dream.

Now there's this additional thing we have to factor in also. The new promo ... it appears to show the ladies of the harem changing into war clothes for a fight with the men of the enemy side. How all this fits in is another puzzle. But let's wait in suspense and see how it plays out! That's all we can do, because if we try to second guess Jalal, we wouldn't know where to begin and end the predictions!

Dear Zee man, I am placing my hopes on you and trust you were right to all three of us who phoned you - Ela, me and Preet. You said the same things to all three of us and I am giving you the benefit of doubt. Don't let me down!
Having said this piece, there was only onne other peripheral scene in the episode which took place in Kabul and not on the battlefront. Haider started making cow eyes at Mahchuchak's daughter, but then Mahchuchak in front of Haider condemned another man to have his eyes boiled out because he was caught looking at someone else's wife! That was a lesson she was giving Haider to keep his eyes to himself. What this scene achieved beats me.
Folks I'll sign off here today, for there isn't much more to say about the episode. I'll reserve my deeper analysis after I have figured out what's really going on. Meanwhile I've decided not to condemn what we saw too quickly, for there may be hidden storylines behind it, and I am going to try and call Zee today if the man turns up on Saturdays. Let me see if I can get any more information out of him on what has happened!
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

88

Views

10.1k

Users

27

Likes

339

Frequent Posters

AKT.JA thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: skanda12

My own hunch is that this was all someone's dream.!


Tumhare munh mein ghee shakkar!
Edited by AKT.JA - 11 years ago
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Thanks Mansi. Lete us know if u happen to talk to Zee. I am also not going to comment much, but wait for Monday and wait and see how everything unfolds. Not sure what we saw today is a dream as in the Pre cap also TM was telling HB about Jallu being captured.

I am also hoping this is all a dream and we get to see real war on Monday
ghalibmirza thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
mansi, i am saddened beyond repair and do not know what to say! and on top of that the new promo will again prove akbar a fool and jodha will be again glorified..and the same saga will go on and on...!
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Lets wait mansi! I hope its someones dream! I doubt that! Atleast we can hope!
I cannot believe Jalal trusted shehnaaz! Thursady he was so furious about her on seeing his dead messenger, but yesterday? And he had told he would forget all relations on wearing war attire but yesterday?
Whatever, i will be glad if this is all someone's dream!
And the new promo, i dont think jo will release jalal, begums were fighting in front of the tent! So jalal may somehow free himself and come back!🤔
Begums going and releasing jalal will be heights!
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon

Thanks Mansi. Lete us know if u happen to talk to Zee. I am also not going to comment much, but wait for Monday and wait and see how everything unfolds. Not sure what we saw today is a dream as in the Pre cap also TM was telling HB about Jallu being captured.

I am also hoping this is all a dream and we get to see real war on Monday

Sindhu, zee man had told us maham will expose Rukaiyya during the fake pregnenct track!😕 But he had given some correct infos too! I donno if we should believe him this time! Lets see!😕 I hope he is right!
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Rak014

Sindhu, zee man had told us maham will expose Rukaiyya during the fake pregnenct track!😕 But he had given some correct infos too! I donno if we should believe him this time! Lets see!😕 I hope he is right!



@bold: and we know this did not happen. Now this will never happen. U might have to make some some Khayali Pulao for us...

I do not think today's epi was a dream but definitely Jo will not free Jalal. I like to watch the women fighting too but they should not be saving Jalal. Hope this wish of mine comes true..
Edited by SindhuMenon - 11 years ago
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mandyg

mansi, i am saddened beyond repair and do not know what to say! and on top of that the new promo will again prove akbar a fool and jodha will be again glorified..and the same saga will go on and on...!



No Mandy, it will not happen. By the way If Jalal is glorified or Jo glorified, at least for me it does not matter as I see them both as one. SO either gets glorified I see both glorified and love to see it like that also.
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon



@bold: and we know this did not happen. Now this will never happen. U might have to make some some Khayali Pulao for us...

I do not think today's epi was a dream but definitely Jo will not free Jalal. I like to watch the women fighting too but they should not be saving Jalal. Hope this wish of mine comes true..

And he had also told that ruku will be punished, which didnot happen either!😕 Lets see!😕
Even i dont think jo will be releasing jalal! Begums are fighting for their own safety! There is no glorification of jodha's character there!😛
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Rak014

And he had also told that ruku will be punished, which didnot happen either!😕 Lets see!😕
Even i dont think jo will be releasing jalal! Begums are fighting for their own safety! There is no glorification of jodha's character there!😛



This story is based on Akbar and Jodha not just Akbar or not just Jodha. For me they are husband and wife so either gets glorified its the same for me. I do agree CVs do make mistakes, but I am going to let it go and just be content with Akdha as they are the only reason I watch this show
Edited by SindhuMenon - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".