today SP sir was so right, sandhya can't take rules in her hand - Page 2

@suseesueez... still, invention is different from changing punishments...if sandhya wanted to change it she can only petition it ..like how people are asking for death sentence for rapists and to change the juvenile age ... but unless it becomes a law one cannot implement it ...

@jas invention or punishment anything can't be use in public events like election that why case filed against inventor.and now Sandy case Sandy can't successful when limited powers only she have.if peoples will change by taking fine and giving lectures them why accidents are happening and previous officer could stop it.sometimes it needs different treatments so you want court to investigate case and give punishments.police official have some powers to investigate small cases by their own.only high officials are allowed to give punishment then there is no meaning in this task given to Sandy.only supreme court can give un changeable judgement but it can't handle all cases that's why high courts and local courts and police have their own powers when it isn't accepted by people then they can appeal to higher ones this is the ting happened in Sandy case.at the same time when the local have nice morals then higher one can adopt it.one more small thing every new rules born after once it considered as crimes.

Originally posted by: moonshine90

@Jas -- Sorry to disagree u. When change is needed, it is necessary to make/break a rule.But i dont think "Zindagi ka safal" campaign is unsuccessful. People always resist change whether it is for good or bad. Here also tat is happeneing. People mindset is like break traffic rule and pay the fine but no realization. CV's idea is good. Take people precious time and people started their rantings. I dont think this idea make sandhya win in her first task. But this idea will sure bring in the change in people attitude towards following traffic rules as they dont want to waste their precious time for watching the 45 min video.

I dont have any idea wether police can make/modify any rules. But it is necessary as old model doesnt have any effect on people then why to follow such rules till now. This is the need of the hour to change the system which is not working.

Also SP bashing sandhya is meaningless for me. He only wants to make the figure to 0 in one week and if she tries something new, he didnt wants to listen/look into what exactly sandhya was trying to do. Infact sandhya is going for an extra mile here. This change may not be succesful in 7 days but it will ensure change in coming days in pushkar city.

RP members involving in Traffic Gyan things is OK for me bcoz traffic rules are for human welfare anyone can teach anyone. It is not that only traffic police has to do it. We common people very well can go and tell people to follow rules. Here some of them not interested in RP involving in Sandy's duty. But we can take it as normal citizen duty for creating awareness on traffic rules.

I agree sandhya was forced to do this task. But it is human tendancy that whenever we are forced to do something, out of the box idea comes and it will be driving force to move forward. Hope sandhya continues to do this even after first task completion.

I want to quote one real life incident here. In chennai, we people tend to talk about rain water harvesting. We will make rallies and awareness campaigns for the same. But people wont realize as they dont want to change. Only when goverment( 2004 i guess) making it as compulsary ( if it is not in their house, power will be cut ), they started to implement it. Sometimes bitter medicine is needed for people to do the right things.

Nice discussion.

SP gave her the task with 7-day time limit to reduce traffic complaints to 0. So, I think she was given the right to implement her plans immediately. She cannot take the routine of devising a plan for that and waiting for approval by superiors or government for such short-term tasks.