Indian Idol losing its credibility?

Hi guys,

We have witnessed many good and talented singers being voted off. In this competition, there are not-so-fantastic singers left.

Do you think Indian Idol has already lost/will lose its credibility?

Your views on this please!

Indian Idol has lost it's credibility the day Alisha *dumb doll* was made the judge. 😆 😆 she repeats the same words all over again.

How can the show lose credibility if the viewers are in power here? The show would lose credibilty if the judges had chosen a disappointing Top 28, but we all know that the talent this year was VERY impressive, so I dont think so.

Originally posted by: Connie

Indian Idol has lost it's credibility the day Alisha *dumb doll* was made the judge. 😆 😆 she repeats the same words all over again.

Ditto! Personally, I don't find her fit to be a judge. Although Udit is a fantastic singer, he doesn't give the necessary feedback to the contestants. It feels "half-hearted" 😆

i think there are still many gud singers if public votes sensibly then we can have a talented singer as ii 😳

its lost its credibility this time mainly becoz of alisha....she is not a good judge

i think we still have good singers...if suhit isnt voted out tomorrow, the level of the show will definitely go down...last year, we had many bad singers in the top 12...this year there arent that many bad ones...if suhit and ankita leave tomorrow ill be happy
also the judges, esp udit, arent that good...udit just praises every contestant, i dont think he knows what hes talking about more than half the time...the only judge i like is javed saab

Originally posted by: Natasha_I

Ditto! Personally, I don't find her fit to be a judge. Although Udit is a fantastic singer, he doesn't give the necessary feedback to the contestants. It feels "half-hearted" 😆

yeh udit himself doesnt know wat he wants to say😕😆

baat ghuma phira ker end per wohi nikal aati hai😆

alisha n udit's judgement dont really matter now as public has power to choose best talent😳

its lost its credibility this time mainly becoz of alisha....she is not a good judge

Originally posted by: Natasha_I

Ditto! Personally, I don't find her fit to be a judge. Although Udit is a fantastic singer, he doesn't give the necessary feedback to the contestants. It feels "half-hearted" 😆

Yes Udit sometimes is scared to speak, that is why he always has to match his opinion with one of the judge's. 😃