shifa? - Page 2

Originally posted by: komalash

I didnt like her performance at all...she has got a very childish voice....maybe she can cum bak in ii6...lol...coz maybe at that time her voice will be a lil mature... 😊

If u are selected in top 28..u cannot try out for II again ever...tht;s the rule...but yea i do noe wht u mean by tht...tht she shld have waited a few yrs....😆

I have to say I was disappointed with judges comments on Shifa ...She sang beautifully ..she is a trained excellent singer and the judges comments like this might bring her down ...

I am a huge Puja, charu fan but I always admit that Shifa mein woh baat hai top 5 jaane ki ...

I mean after every perf I was more or less expecting what the judges are going to say like ankita's singing was little flat( and it reminded me of Sanchita's rendition 😉 )..
puja though better than previous rounds still was hili on sur bec she was trying to make her perf right ...vartika not that good ....

But when Shifa's turn came I enjoyed her song ssooo much that I was like , wait a minute ..they praised ankita , vartika, more than Shifa ..what's going on ???? 😕

.I just hope she goes to top 5 ....

Anyway, that's my 2 cents .. 😛

i totally agree. for some reason i think the judges are being too harsh on shifa from last two performances. of course her singing can be way better but it doesnt suck that bad!!!!!

Originally posted by: bruno4

I have to say I was disappointed with judges comments on Shifa ...She sang beautifully ..she is a trained excellent singer and the judges comments like this might bring her down ...

I am a huge Puja, charu fan but I always admit that Shifa mein woh baat hai top 5 jaane ki ...

I mean after every perf I was more or less expecting what the judges are going to say like ankita's singing was little flat( and it reminded me of Sanchita's rendition 😉 )..
puja though better than previous rounds still was hili on sur bec she was trying to make her perf right ...vartika not that good ....

But when Shifa's turn came I enjoyed her song ssooo much that I was like , wait a minute ..they praised ankita , vartika, more than Shifa ..what's going on ???? 😕

.I just hope she goes to top 5 ....

Anyway, that's my 2 cents .. 😛

seeing update I was dissappointed to watch shifa's performance & when I watched it I was wodnering why judges didnt like her?😕

They didnt say any fault in her singing...Only abt performance...& that too from all 3 judges !!! 😕

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

If u are selected in top 28..u cannot try out for II again ever...tht;s the rule...but yea i do noe wht u mean by tht...tht she shld have waited a few yrs....😆

hehe ok...yh u got me right...!😆

judges ka bhi kuch pata nahin guys! 😆

true. i wish they had atleast complimented her on her singing before tearing her down because of "performance"

yes she's really good


VOTE FOR EMON! 😳
vote for Emon! 😃
vOtE FoR EmOn! 😉

i think her performance was quiet because she was so nervous. but other than that she is definitely charismatic... so technically that shouldn't be such a huge issue