Discuss:R.A.B. dead or alive..(pg 2,3)

could RAB be regulus alphard black??!!!

he was sirius' brother..and is a death eater..

if yu check the 5th book ..he has also been mentioned there..

first, i thought that RAB was sum1 on the good side..actually i had hoped..butt...

tata

tc

dhwani

maybe...its possible. i guess its a good lead 😃

This theory has been discussed alot here...
Ummm I truly don't know..
Im hoping it is not him though...Because I want it to be a shock to me..on who it was..
:D

-Mahak-

I dont know but he does not make sence. Cause Sirus ( 😍) made him sound like he was seriously evil n it does not make sence that he suddenly turns good. N I agree with Manshi, I hope its not him cause I want a new character added.
-Aastha

dis theory has been discussd a lot of times..d thng wich strikes me is dat JKR wont give us sooo mny clues if its him....she liks 2 keep us in full darkness.....letz c

hey good guess yaar...maybe ur right... 😃 😃

That is one of the more popular theories doing the rounds..... now a days...

tejas

its still under controversy. but its a possibility. neways jk would have a surprise for us. 😉

its been discussed sooooo much everywhere .... and its very accurate too .. specially with the "heavy locket none of them could open" in the 5th book when they are cleaning 12 grimmuald place ..... but its just not possible that jk rowling will have it that predictable .... she usually has stuff that no one can even guess ... like in the third book sirius being good and oeter pettigrew bad ....... and in 4th book .. who woulda thought of alastor moody

and in the 6th book about the half-blood prince .... i can bet most of the people like me thought of the half-blood prince being voldemort ... since he was half-blood and he lived 50 years ago and that was the date on the book :)

so its supposed to be tricky i guess ... but you cant help thinking its regulus black ..... so its really complicated :)

maybe jk rowling panicked by thinking how many people have guessed it right and actually changed the person who should be RAB 😆

Originally posted by: Dhw@ni

could RAB be regulus alphard black??!!!

he was sirius' brother..and is a death eater..

if yu check the 5th book ..he has also been mentioned there..

first, i thought that RAB was sum1 on the good side..actually i had hoped..butt...

tata

tc

dhwani

but he is dead? deadon the earliest detah eater days only