{|KAVACHADHARI Karna: AHAM Sharma's AT#11|} DT's Nt pg 70

First Previous

Page

120

Next Last

Poll

What caused Karna's death?

Frequent Posters

Krrish

@RoyalLEO_Krrish

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#551

Originally posted by: riti4u
My dear friend if you think we hate pandavas then you are mistaken in fact I think its majorly our friends here who think pandavas deserved to know karna real identity before he died and thus despise kunti more. I am not fond of all pandavas but I do like draupadi. But fact is that this thread only discusses karna so we stick with that.We like KaJu as well -some real version..some star version ..

Exactly what i told my mum yesterday!

Krishn told Karna about his identity but he never told Yudhishtir or Arjun or any of the pandavas who Karna was! ( Now that is what i call unfair game) Cz i strongly believe that both Arjun and Yudhishthir would've NOT fight against Karna No matter where or which group he belonged.

Yudhishthir would've stopped all pandvas, as he is strong believer of dharma. Even Arjun didn't want to kill Karna when he bent down to fix the wheel. Arjun respected Karna and Karna respected Arjun despite of the relation revelation OR not!

& ditto HATE kunti to the core!

Quote

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

#552

DT Note

Hello Karna AT Members,

This note is two address two important issues in Karna AT

1 You are NOT supposed to discuss any other members of the forum, or any other ATs, or mock them. Please refrain from posting or commenting about any other members or ATs of the forum. Keep the discussions to Karna and his character in the show .

2. This is Karna's AT. His relation can be discussed with Kunti here. Discussing Kunti otherwise should be done in Pandava's AT not here..

Any comments which violate the rules of the AT, or the DT notes, will be removed and action will be taken against individual members who violate the rules.

Regards

Mahabharat Dev Team

Edited by munnihyderabad - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Justitia

@Justitia

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#553

Regarding the poll, I would say that Karna's death was caused by the curses he received...

Also, I found this sentence which suggests that YBNS had every chance of getting killed if NOT for Karna's promise -

"Except Arjuna, thy other sons, Yudhishthira, Bhima, and the twins, though capable of being withstood by me in tight and capable also of being slain, shall not yet be slain by me."

https://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m05/m05146.htm

Therefore, in a (hypothetical) scenario of NO promise made by Karna to Kunti -

Would even Krishna's presence on the Pandava side have proved to be completely futile? Or, would Krishna have ensured somehow that ALL Pandavas would've survived even under such circumstances?

Quote

Sabhayata

@Sabhayata

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#554

Originally posted by: FollowYourHeart

I know that Pandavs didn't leave a chance to jibe at him, specially Arjuna...but if SB has downplayed their insults, SB has downplayed Karna's obnoxious role in the dice game as well...but even if it hadn't downplayed either of these things I wld have still loved both...because both of their flaws, pride and ego being the biggest of them, but still both of their goodness as well...whether we like it or not both indeed r the fruits of the same plant, so there is BOUND to be certain inherent similarities btw them...I love both of them for who they r...and my heart breaks to think that these two divine forms of shakti and samarthya were supposed to be together, on the same side,,,,,,but fate had other more cruel plans...

completely agree one distortion leds to another because they didnt show pandavas insulting karna they couldn't hvae shown karna's hatred towards pandavs as well that is why we had ⭐️karna feeling bad for pandvas

Quote

Sabhayata

@Sabhayata

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#555

haven't seen karna krishna conversation yet but from the discussion seems like karnali's arent happy

Quote

Sabhayata

@Sabhayata

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#556

Originally posted by: ...Diala...
Karnalis.. Good afternoon... I wrote a big essay on EDT abt Karna and posted it only to see I lost my connection 😡 pissed off and went away...

please do post it sometime seems like me and watcher are the only ones who write about karna in EDT

Quote

Justitia

@Justitia

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

#557

Originally posted by: Sabhayata

completely agree one distortion leds to another because they didnt show pandavas insulting karna they couldn't hvae shown karna's hatred towards pandavs as well that is why we had ⭐️karna feeling bad for pandvas

I think CVs just want to simplify the reason for Karna's promise to Kunti of sparing 4 / 5 Pandavas...

⭐️Karna has felt bad for the Pandavas (shedding tears and all), ⭐️Pandavas never insulted him as much as they did in the epic, and although ⭐️Karna DID insult Draupadi - the role he played in her insult has been watered down in the show...

But that still wouldn't explain why ⭐️Karna would refuse to give promises for sparing ⭐️Arjuna...

I mean, ⭐️Arjuna has NEVER called him THAT.

Or will ⭐️Karna want to take revenge for the curse that ⭐️Arjuna gave him in the dice hall?

Edited by -Shani- - 11 years ago

Quote

Sabhayata

@Sabhayata

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#558

@shani:⭐️karna will not spare ⭐️arjuna because ⭐️karna promised in one of the episodes to ⭐️dury that no matter what he will fight ⭐️arjuna so because of his promise to dury he will fight ⭐️arjuna