hello im new

hi....im new to this part of the forum.

also i started reading harry potter books very recently.i love them!!i lost interest in watching tv too bcoz of this!!

anyway...i just finished reading the 3rd part.i cant understand 1 point,can any1 clarify???

how can harry do the patronus from the other side of the lake when he was with sirius?i mean...the other harry went back in the past from the future,right?so how can something from the future exist in the present?

i mean,i can understand if they go back in the past and see the things going on....but how can harry from the past see his future harry??

pls clarify my dbt....pls😭

well he was looking at his future form
and welcum here

pls tell me how cud harry from the past see his future self???? 😭

dear alcazar....welcome to harry potter section.even i am not a very old member in this section but u will find it great. 😃

Originally posted by: Alcazar

pls tell me how cud harry from the past see his future self???? 😭

i have understood it this way

nothing new is happenning when the time turner is acivated.whatever happened after the thing was turned had happened in the past too.have you seen movie 3.if u have, you will understand it a lot more better.mcnaire(the excecutioner)had not killed buckbeak in the past.he had just cut something else(in the movie-a pumpkin).harry,ren and hermione had not seen him kill buckbeak.they only heard the sound.whatever happened in the past, the same happened when the turner was used.this what i have understood.harry had seen himself. the real harry saw the harry who had turned the time turner.there were no new things happenning.just one thing happened but thats repeatedly said/seen twice

have i gone wrong guys?

😃hope that cleared ur doubt

Hey! Welcome 2 the Forum and I'll see you around!

thanks lakshmi....i have seen the movie.seeing the movie,it looks like buckbeak is not dead.but the in the novel,its not clarified that way..

i find this ending not to be as good as the rest of the novel... 😭

Welcome to HP, Alcazar! Enjoy!

hey wecome!!!! i am new too but i have been reading harry potter for a long time!!!

Welcome to HP. Hope you'll have a great time here..