Critiquing sanaya's acting [DT NT-PG2] - Page 18

Created

Last reply

Replies

178

Views

22k

Users

62

Likes

1.1k

Frequent Posters

tvbuf thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: DexterRocks

IPK made her, otherwise we all know what happened to chanchan. Just because she has a popular show in her graph does not make her the better actor. And this is Ashish's 4th year in tv. Care to tell me what did sanaya achive in her first four years? Atleast Ashish bags shows due to his acting skills and not because his previous show was a hit that too on star plus where apparently all the shows are more or less hit.



It took Sanaya several years to master Hindi, and I do believe she has a very good handle on it now, and probably the same number of years to feel comfortable in the predominantly Hindi speaking TV serial world - both viewers and makers, so it is not an equal comparison to say AS has been acting for only 4 yrs, and SI for many more before that.

I grew up in a major metropolitan city in India, and no one attending the public schools/colleges speaks Hindi, and I think I can say that its a snob attitude that keeps youth away from associating with anything not related to western culture. So I understand where Sanaya has come from.

I will not get into the comparison to AS mode here, because I don't want to reduce to such negativity. Suffice it to say that AS had an easier time fitting into TV land.
dknala thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
I have reported this post.
sonapari thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Tvbuf,lemonsunrise...let it go please...if someone thinks sanz is not a great actress...their opinion...
I think after first 10 pages the comments have turned into a fight...
We need to ignore such posts...
Please let it go Frds...
shalinii173 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Sanaya was so good in initial episodes her character was very clear. But now I think the CVs are confused one day she is strong then next day weak. Two days back when she was angry with rudra, especially while lifting the suitcase when Rudra tried to help her, I saw Khushi there. Who Is completely Different from Paro. Even Rudra character is not proper just 2-3 weeks back he promised he gonna make her life hell and but within days everything changed and now he is helping her to wear bangles. He too changed so fast. So what happened to those 8 vachans everything vanished just like that?

Actually the problem is with the CVs and the storyline not with Sanaya. One question to Asish's fans who bash Sanaya for her expressions. Even his expressions are same in almost all the episodes then
Y blaming only Sanaya? I am not against anyone here. I love Rudra character and the actor Ashish. I don't see any Problem with the actors and their acting but the characters, everyday it changes I think CVs r confused:(
Edited by shalinii173 - 11 years ago
sonapari thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shalinii173

Sanaya was so good in initial episodes her character was very clear. But now I think the CVs are confused one day she is strong then next day weak. Two days back when she was angry with rudra, especially while lifting the suitcase when Rudra tried to help her, I saw Khushi there. Who Is completely Different from Paro. Even Rudra character is not proper just 2-3 weeks back he promised he gonna make her life hell and but within days everything changed and now he is helping her to wear bangles. He too changed so fast. So what happened to those 8 vachans everything vanished just like that?

Actually the problem is with the CVs and the storyline not with Sanaya. One question to Asish's fans who bash Sanaya for her expressions. Even his expressions are same in almost all the episodes then
Y blaming only Sanaya? I am not against anyone here. I love Rudra and Ashish. I don't see any
Problem with the actors and their acting but the characters, everyday it changes I think CVs r confused:(

I agree ...completely...
But if you are biased towards SI then it's easy to blame her...
Otherwise if you blame cvs or other actors how would be there 22 pages for your post...
Kuchh toh khaas baat hai sanz mein tab hi to sanz etani popular hai...😳
shalinii173 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: sonapari


I agree ...completely...
But if you are biased towards SI then it's easy to blame her...
Otherwise if you blame cvs or other actors how would be there 22 pages for your post...
Kuchh toh khaas baat hai sanz mein tab hi tosanz etani popular hai...😳



22 pages for my post? When dear? I actually don't post much. am a silent reader of RR forum. But I never know that RR forum has two groups ( just yesterday came to know). I began to watch RR for Sanaya, and began to like Rudra/ashish too. But am really shocked to see fans bashing each other's favourite. . Y so much hatred in RR forum? Never come across so much of negativity and hatred towards the main leads in any other forum. 😕 really feel bad. I thought everyone in this liked Parud, not just Paro or Rudra. But am disappointed. I actually read the first page and commented, later when I read few other comments I was completely shocked so came to delete my post. (Felt I better stay away from this thread).
lrlpam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Frankly speaking,neither ashish nor sanaya are gonna get any acting awards inspite of being brilliant. Nor are they gonna bag films bcz of their acting skills. So for me atleast,it doesn't matter how perfect or imperfect the acting is...what matters is how well are the actors connecting with the audience,how convincing they are and looking at numerous posts in the forum,I can safely say that SI has succeeded big time in doing so,even in minds of TRP aunties who didn't think much of her before. As for me,I have not been able to relate to paro's actions in the last few weeks,inspite of reading positive posts on the forum. But my problem is with the script and definitely not the actor,who I think has mastered paro after immense hard work. Sanaya herself said that paro has too many limitations and is not expressive and sanaya has done nothing but show this very fact to us,which unfortunately is being considered as mediocre acting. The problem is that paro is being judged through khushi's range of expressions,if one truly wants to know sanaya's range,he/she needs to watch her enact a similar scene in mjht,ipk and RR and notice the vastly different body languages in each of them. That's just my opinion,repect the TM's POV. What's actually disturbing for me are the subsequent comments in the post. I saw a similar rivalry destroy a forum after 1.5 yrs,can't believe it's happening within 4 mnths here. RR exists bcz of sanish and parud! Sanaya and ashish fans have to unify as sanish fans if they want RR to survive and win the upcoming battles of popularity,awards and TRPs,so as of now plz keep ur differences aside,it's a request.
Suhana2014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: lrlpam

Frankly speaking,neither ashish nor sanaya are gonna get any acting awards inspite of being brilliant. Nor are they gonna bag films bcz of their acting skills. So for me atleast,it doesn't matter how perfect or imperfect the acting is...what matters is how well are the actors connecting with the audience,how convincing they are and looking at numerous posts in the forum,I can safely say that SI has succeeded big time in doing so,even in minds of TRP aunties who didn't think much of her before. As for me,I have not been able to relate to paro's actions in the last few weeks,inspite of reading positive posts on the forum. But my problem is with the script and definitely not the actor,who I think has mastered paro after immense hard work. Sanaya herself said that paro has too many limitations and is not expressive and sanaya has done nothing but show this very fact to us,which unfortunately is being considered as mediocre acting. The problem is that paro is being judged through khushi's range of expressions,if one truly wants to know sanaya's range,he/she needs to watch her enact a similar scene in mjht,ipk and RR and notice the vastly different body languages in each of them. That's just my opinion,repect the TM's POV. What's actually disturbing for me are the subsequent comments in the post. I saw a similar rivalry destroy a forum after 1.5 yrs,can't believe it's happening within 4 mnths here. RR exists bcz of sanish and parud! Sanaya and ashish fans have to unify as sanish fans if they want RR to survive and win the upcoming battles of popularity,awards and TRPs,so as of now plz keep ur differences aside,it's a request.


Agree.. Now its getting uglier.. Not a good feeling Thank you for this post.. Will try to refrain myself from this...
VishaD. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
Despite a note on this thread, things continues to get ugly.
You have been warned and now time to face the consequences.

Topic Closed for review.
RR DT

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".