Barkat and Suraiyya's hatred justified??!!

Book_Kash thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
While watching today's episode again one thing is keep on hitting me .. as per the spoilers or rumors that barkat will hate aaliya ?
As we all know that aaliya will play key role in search of barkat ..
Now my question is what could be the possibility? What makes barkat hate aaliya?
Why should barkat hate her?
And does zain will support aaliya and become her shield ? Or brother-sister long lost love over shadowed the relation of zain and aaliya?

I know I know its too early to say anything because beintihaa is unpredictable but we can atleast give a thought over it

I think the fact that aaliya from bhopal and being her kidnapper's niece she will hate her

Barkat was child then when she got kidnapped so she must be no memory of aaliya being kidnapper's nieve so definitely there's a possibility that someone will make barkat show the things in a negative way and obviously against aaliya

What are your thoughts on that

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.7k

Users

8

Likes

29

Frequent Posters

priya_bp thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
First of all hands of to all the CVs!!!👏
A very emotional episode!!😭
Coming to the point, I guess it would now makes sense why Barkat is also against Aliya!! Though, it may sound little crazy, she was kidnapped at the age of 2 and separated from her family!
God knows, what she went through!! So, we cant really blame her for removing her frustration and anger on Aliya! As she was kidnapped by none other than Aliya's uncle!!
So, I guess even if Aliya saves Barkat, they might still show Barkat plotting against Aliya!
The best part of BI creative team, is that they even have a justification for the antagonist!!
It just goes into showing we are all humans, and at the end of the day our emotions take over our logical thinking and no matter how hard we try not to, some incidents change our outlooks towars our life!!
p.s : Never thought my post would end on such a srs note! Anyways, sorry if already posted!
naj7 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Hey just cudnt watch the episode yest..
But read all the comments.. i guess barkat may not really be bad to Aaliyah .. but Suir's dislike may prompt her to also hate her.. she may also learn that wen she was deprived of a life as beautiful as this..Aaliyah is in the same house..
So mayb .. but how i wish the character was not negative.. come on she was away from her family for sooo long.. instead of spending the rest of the days being pampered by her parents, bros, bhabhis, chand kala or even playing with her nieces and nephew.. she is going to waste her time plotting against Aaliyah..
Hmm anyway..
Lady_Impala thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
I just hope that barkat is not an out and out negative person. maybe she will just feel frustrated with how she was kept away from her family and thus will blame the person she most closely affiliate with her kidnapper therefore her apparent hatred for aliyah.
but I have a feeling that later on she will turn positive.
nandini27 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
I hope this doesn't end up being long. If does, couldn't help it I guess. 😆

So my opinion on this is, Suraiya and Barkat's anger towards Aliya is justifiable. I will take up each character to explore.

Suraiya's anger and hate towards Aliya and Bhopal. As a mother, loosing a child and not knowing what happened to her is one of the most horrible fate any human may have. I dont think any mother ever comes out of the hope and yearning of seeing your lost child just once. And considering the man who took away her baby is your sister in law's brother in law, its unforgivable for her. But she has tried to accept them as much as possible, especially letting Usman talk to his sister and her family. Deep down she knows one man's character does not define the entire family's character. She also knows Aliya was a baby herself, what is it that she did? But she feels her loss, all those years on missing out on her daughter's growth, not knowing how she is, alive? She never understood how Usman could accept Aliya as a daughter. But she has a side of a good mother in law as well, which has not really come out.
There is this scene when Aliya hugs Suraiya for giving her an expensive gift, but all she wanted was her presence. Only few seconds, very few you see an emotion playing across Suraiya's face of surprise. Not knowing how to react to such a genuine gesture, which was completely innocent from the girl. May be at that moment, she remember her own daughter as well, and then the bitterness seeps in. I want the CVs to explore this anger that Suraiya has towards Aliya. Make it right. Make her a mother-in-law to Aliya who is supportive, encouraging and accepting. Make her see that Aliya is of no fault and embracing her will only bring more joy to her family.

Barkat - She is gonna be a mystery to me as of now. We will know to make some predictions about her only if we know in what kind of a locality/society she grew up in. Was she with a family, or an orphaned child. Did she have a happy life or a difficult one?
Assuming though the spoilers that are coming around are true, that she will create difference between Zain and Aliya, may be part of her anger can be justified. From her POV, on a wild and total assumption, there are 2 reasons based on which she an have angst towards Aliya.
One, she lost her entire childhood and growing years with her family. Her family was stolen from her deliberately. And it was all because of Aliya's uncle. Either she can be mature like her mother, knowing that Aliya was not at fault. Or she could be immature at her age of 22 and have hatred to Aliya for her lost life.
Two, jealousy. Its something some member of the house who would mention this. Her knowing Aliya took up a daughter's place in her father's heart. Irrational thoughts going on in her mind on how could her father simply think on replacing her with the enemie's neice. And her jealousy towards Aliya that the love she was supposed to get from her own father was showered upon that girl whose family destroyed their lives all those years back.
Even with all this anger, it wont be justified though that she try to separate Zain and Aliya. She can may be make Aliya's life miserable, but what can she accomplish by separating them? Isnt that hurting her brother as well? She can be a negative character initially, but like Suraiya, I want her character to be molded into someone who learns from her mistakes and becomes positive. Aliya could use a sister in that house against those 2 chudails.😆

I saw a lot of topics on the forum about this. No time to reply in each so I just wrote everything here in a single post.

This show has great potential to show amazing stuffs. Even though family tracks are boring or dull compared to the romance factor, all comes down to how these dramas and other characters directly or indirectly have an impact on the love birds. Looking forward to the Nikkah drama and what happens next.
Book_Kash thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Nans it's actually very long 😆 but an excellent post with every sensitive spot touching .. now mere demagh main aur sawaal agaye hai :-D I need to wait for these questions to be answered :-D
nandini27 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: xoxpunkxox

Nans it's actually very long 😆 but an excellent post with every sensitive spot touching .. now mere demagh main aur sawaal agaye hai :-D I need to wait for these questions to be answered :-D



Trust me 😆 I have a LOT of questions too. But strangely enough the show has been answering most of them in its own course. My first doubt is how old is Barkat and how are Fahad, Zain and Barkat arranged according to their age wise order. 😆 I really really need to know that.

With the new spoiler around, I wanna know if Mir Khan has kept Barkat in Mumbai all this time.😆

And I really really cannot point out anything about Barkat now, in sure words since I dont know anything about the circumstances she grew up in.


Taniya20 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Suraiah's Hatred towards bhopal is justified...Even her disbelief in Ghulam justifies because his own brother is a kameena!
But according to me, Her hatred towards Aaliya is not justified... What is the poor girl's fault? Just because she is Mir Khan's niece?? Not his own daughter isn't it? Its his niece! Then Why Aaliya?

Not only this, Her hatred towards Shabana too is not justified! This is my biggest problem actually! She labelled Ghulam as bad because of his brother. But, why Shabana? She is Usman's sister isn't it? When Usman is good person why will Shabana be a bad one? Why that indifference towards Shabana? She judges Ghulam based on Mir's actions, Then why cant she judge Shabana based on Usman's actions then?

What is the poor kids, Aaliya n Ayat's fault to insult them again n again? 😡

What happend with abdullah's is bad... But Suri stooped so low on the name of her bitterness... One thing i am cribbing since yesterday is She was crying no one can take her daughter's place in her life, then how can she thought of snatching Fahad from Nafeesa and married him off to Shazia? Just becoz she wants a grandson? If you lost your daughter, you should love your granddaughters even more isn't it? 😕 .. She cant just go on n ruining the lives just becoz something bad happened to her.

All in all, i wanna say her anger towards bhopal is justified but not her actions n anger towards wrong people!

Regarding barkat, i will comment once her character is introduced n her thought process is shown!
Edited by Taniya20 - 11 years ago
JennyPenny thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
See, these articles make no sense because one says Barkat is older than Zain, other says she is younger.
Barkat hating Mir and the whole Bhopal would totally be justified. Suriya's hatred is toh justified.

As far as ZaYa is concerned, I think it's best to watch than believe any of these spoilers. We don;t even know if Barkat is neg or +
mazkachazka thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: nandini27

I hope this doesn't end up being long. If does, couldn't help it I guess. 😆

So my opinion on this is, Suraiya and Barkat's anger towards Aliya is justifiable. I will take up each character to explore.

Suraiya's anger and hate towards Aliya and Bhopal. As a mother, loosing a child and not knowing what happened to her is one of the most horrible fate any human may have. I dont think any mother ever comes out of the hope and yearning of seeing your lost child just once. And considering the man who took away her baby is your sister in law's brother in law, its unforgivable for her. But she has tried to accept them as much as possible, especially letting Usman talk to his sister and her family. Deep down she knows one man's character does not define the entire family's character. She also knows Aliya was a baby herself, what is it that she did? But she feels her loss, all those years on missing out on her daughter's growth, not knowing how she is, alive? She never understood how Usman could accept Aliya as a daughter. But she has a side of a good mother in law as well, which has not really come out.
There is this scene when Aliya hugs Suraiya for giving her an expensive gift, but all she wanted was her presence. Only few seconds, very few you see an emotion playing across Suraiya's face of surprise. Not knowing how to react to such a genuine gesture, which was completely innocent from the girl. May be at that moment, she remember her own daughter as well, and then the bitterness seeps in. I want the CVs to explore this anger that Suraiya has towards Aliya. Make it right. Make her a mother-in-law to Aliya who is supportive, encouraging and accepting. Make her see that Aliya is of no fault and embracing her will only bring more joy to her family.

Barkat - She is gonna be a mystery to me as of now. We will know to make some predictions about her only if we know in what kind of a locality/society she grew up in. Was she with a family, or an orphaned child. Did she have a happy life or a difficult one?
Assuming though the spoilers that are coming around are true, that she will create difference between Zain and Aliya, may be part of her anger can be justified. From her POV, on a wild and total assumption, there are 2 reasons based on which she an have angst towards Aliya.
One, she lost her entire childhood and growing years with her family. Her family was stolen from her deliberately. And it was all because of Aliya's uncle. Either she can be mature like her mother, knowing that Aliya was not at fault. Or she could be immature at her age of 22 and have hatred to Aliya for her lost life.
Two, jealousy. Its something some member of the house who would mention this. Her knowing Aliya took up a daughter's place in her father's heart. Irrational thoughts going on in her mind on how could her father simply think on replacing her with the enemie's neice. And her jealousy towards Aliya that the love she was supposed to get from her own father was showered upon that girl whose family destroyed their lives all those years back.
Even with all this anger, it wont be justified though that she try to separate Zain and Aliya. She can may be make Aliya's life miserable, but what can she accomplish by separating them? Isnt that hurting her brother as well? She can be a negative character initially, but like Suraiya, I want her character to be molded into someone who learns from her mistakes and becomes positive. Aliya could use a sister in that house against those 2 chudails.😆

I saw a lot of topics on the forum about this. No time to reply in each so I just wrote everything here in a single post.

This show has great potential to show amazing stuffs. Even though family tracks are boring or dull compared to the romance factor, all comes down to how these dramas and other characters directly or indirectly have an impact on the love birds. Looking forward to the Nikkah drama and what happens next.



whoa!nans you've put it down clearly..all I want is a proper justifictation to each character ,like how the CV's have doen before..no illogical nafrat and stuff please..and I'm sure BI writers will balance negatives and positives well hopefully how they've done till now..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".