Aliya's trust on Aayat?

I dont know how many of u felt but i felt slapping scene a bit over. I mean come on Aayat is her sister, doesn't she knows her own sister? Definately she will not do this knowingly and aliya should have understood that someone trapped her sister. She also knows Zain helped her so its obvious that aayat is innocent. Her sister obviously will not go to an escort agency willingly. Instead of knowing whole truth, she slapped her. I found it out of place.

I disagree..as an elder sister my self I understand Aliya and Ayat did somthing extremely stupid.
She is old enough to understand u shouldnt trust a guy she met for 2 sec.
Now a days you cant even trust people you have known for years.
Ayat should have spoken to her sister if she was so worried about her parents financial situation but she didnt cus her mother told her not to but was willing to go behind her parents back and take a big step like that.

Originally posted by: shahz

I disagree..as an elder sister my self I understand Aliya and Ayat did somthing extremely stupid.
She is old enough to understand u shouldnt trust a guy she met for 2 sec.
Now a days you cant even trust people you have known for years.
Ayat should have spoken to her sister if she was so worried about her parents financial situation but she didnt cus her mother told her not to but was willing to go behind her parents back and take a big step like that.

But aliya still doesnt know that where and how she met this guy? How she came mumbai? How her name got involved in escort agency? What was her motive behind this? I just mean without knowing a single thing she simply slapped. These reasons which u mentioned are not known to aliya yet.

M gonna copy paste the reply from one of my other posts.😆

As far as forgiving Aayat. Its a very spontaneous reaction. As a sister, if my sibling lies to me about something big that has troubled him/her or put him/her in trouble, I would shout too. I would be furious too, not just because he/she did something wrong, but because I am hurt that he/she did not find it important they share it with me. Am I not a sister? Why not share it with me? I would be very very hurt. I can attest to that because I am a sister.

Originally posted by: AnjiStar

But aliya still doesnt know that where and how she met this guy? How she came mumbai? How her name got involved in escort agency? What was her motive behind this? I just mean without knowing a single thing she simply slapped. These reasons which u mentioned are not known to aliya yet.

Even if Aliya doesnt know the whole story she does know Ayat lied to her and her parents so that alone is a big reason for her trust to break.

Originally posted by: shahz

Even if Aliya doesnt know the whole story she does know Ayat lied to her and her parents so that alone is a big reason for her trust to break.

i think aliya was right in her place bt aayat needed tht slap to mke hr in sense as nxt she wnt go with a man who she is chatting to n who he shes dsnt knw tht well she didnt knw rocky tht well... aliya was right in my mind...

I don't think its a matter of trust... aliya does trust ayat a lot and vice versa. I felt her reaction to some extent was justified..i do hope she gives ayat the chance to explain her situation... there is a dif between how zain and aliya reacted to ayat's escort incident... zain was more calm wanting to know what problem she was in and save her... here aliya finds out abt her sis from a stranger and is obviously livid at the thought of ayat being involved with the wrong group. aliya and ayat have been bought up in such a way where their reputation and honour means greater than everything and this escort incident was putting that reputation at stake so aliya was bound 2 react the way she did. but I do feel she should give ayat the chance 2 explain...maybe when she finds out the truth she'll realise that ayat wasn't at fault.

^^ Yup! I think which is why she decides to bring it in the open and send her back to Bhopal as well. I think its all the covering up and lying that triggered her anger more than how and why Aayat ended up with Rocky. She has been on an emotional roller coaster since the accident. Like the lil kids said, kit kit chachi. 😆

All of you people above told exactly what I needed to say😆

I too feel that Aaliya slapping Aayat was justified. Even I'm an elder sister and I'd be deeply hurt if my sister hid something as huge as this from me. Why she hid it and for what reason will be all secondary but the fact that she hid it would be the one that would hurt the most. So it's all justified :))