Is Sanyukta really THAT wrong?

melody442 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

I see so many posts today that complain of Sanyukta's insensitivity and lack of understanding for Randhir's situation even after knowing the truth about Renuka Sanyal, and how she has become so self centred and cares only about herself and dream team. Randhir is the way he is because of his traumatic past while Sanyukta is being plain insensitive etc. While it would have been really nice had Sanyukta been a bit more empathetic to Randhir, is she really so wrong and has Randhir been any different regarding Sanyukta's issues? Lets try to put it in perspective. If Randhir had a difficult past, did Sanyukta have an easy past? Or has a funfilled present? Or even a promising future where she has an assurance of getting to the place she deserves after all her hard work and determination. Everydyay for her is a constant struggle to snatch one more day before the inevitable strikes and she is forced to give up on her career and dreams. If Randhir has only the support of his father, for Sanyukta its only her mother. Her father and brother have never supported her or understood her, and in fact try to do everything to humiliate her and make her feel sorry. Is it any easier to fight against your own family at every single step than being lonely? Atleast Randhir has luxury and certainty of choosing his future and his career the way he wants, Sanyukta doesn't. And yes therefore she has to be self centred or think only about her team's victory, because she has to prove herself every single time, if she falters even the tiniest bit, her loving father and brother are there to take her away even from the shadow of FITE.

Now we come to her insensitivity about Randhir's situation. Why didn't she melt then and there. Did Randhir melt then and there when he came to know how hard Sanyukta had to fight against her family for her studies, or how her father and brother treat her? Did he feel sympathetic when Sanyukta's marriage was being fixed which effectively meant a dead end for her education, her career and her aspirations? No he was overjoyed, and in fact made sure that the guy agrees to marriage, just because Sanyukta's presence "irritated" him. Didn't he know how much she cares for her dreams and wasn't it plain sadistic on his part? At least Sanyukta did it for dream team. What valid excuse Randhir had? Did he show any sensitivity when her brother rejected her for internship, except of course mocking her (yes it was triggered by that scarf, but did Sanyukta wear it intentionally?).

We are ready to give limitless time to Randhir to change and sort out his emotions. Its perfectly OK if he takes one step forward, and two step backwards. Then why not extend same time and same privilege to Sanyukta too? Fine she didn't appreciate Randhir's situation immediately. But she will with time once it sinks in. Just as Randhir is shaped by his lonely past, Sanyukta is shaped by her past and present where she has to fight for everything and prove herself every time to have some control over her destiny. And yet her future remains uncertain and at mercy of others. Just like Randhir's pain and competitive spirit doesn't allow him to be the person he can be; in the same way sometimes Sanyukta's struggle and survival instinct doesn't let her be the person she actually is. So give her some leeway.

PS - I wont be able to reply to the posts due to time constraints, but feel free to discuss. Just wanted to give an alternative POV.

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

2.9k

Users

15

Likes

76

Frequent Posters

ilovepyaar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Exactly! This is what I LOVE about this show. Both of them are equally insensitive, equally aggressive, equally rude to each other. Both of them equally "hate" each other, and one day will equally love each other. Equality is present among these two, which is EXACTLY why I love this show. The show's theme itself is equality and Sanyukta's insensitivity was needed to emphasize this theme once more. I'm loving it!
honestyfirst thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I totally agree with u ..
Nice post ..
I really understand sayus situation
..
For ur post 👏 ⭐️
yatup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Tuesday and today's episode, tuesday Randhir was humilating her and didn't even felt guilty about it but Sanyukta, she felt guilty. You're true, he didn't even melt for her. I think we are talking about her being insensitive because we saw her as the girl with a golden heart and seeing her change today a bit, we think she's becoming selfish. Randhir always being arrogant and change in his character today melt our hearts towards him.
honestyfirst thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ilovepyaar

Exactly! This is what I LOVE about this show. Both of them are equally insensitive, equally aggressive, equally rude to each other. Both of them equally "hate" each other, and one day will equally love each other. Equality is present among these two, which is EXACTLY why I love this show. The show's theme itself is equality and Sanyukta's insensitivity was needed to emphasize this theme once more. I'm loving it!


Yup ...
This show is awesome n i lovit ...
Agree with u
Supertrouper thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Arey but all these fights r getting to me... Thoda toh atmosphere cool down ho... It's lyk everybody is at loggerheads... Kitna like negative feel de raha hai... Thoda kuch positive ho...
1st vardhan stepped down... Then that internship stuff... Then this disclosure and shouting match between sandhir and Tomorrow another fight... White flag kissi ke pass nahi hai kya?
her_story thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Ok, I will confess I am one of those people who felt disappointed by Sanyukta's lack of sensitivity about the whole issue, but yes, when I think more about it, I think my disappointment is more about how she didn't behave the way I expected her to behave when she knew about Renuka Sanyal being Randhir's mom and how he hasn't talked to her in so many years. In Randhir's case, from the start Randhir has been blatantly shown as insensitive and with prejudiced views, so when he behaves a certain way, that is what we expect of him, so it doesn't shock or surprise us. Sanyukta (although not exactly the saint) has in the past behaved comparatively in a more sensitive manner-- we have seen her selflessly paying Vidushi's fees, or handing over her captaincy to Randhir for the sake of the team-- so in this case, I, and I guess many others, expected her to understand Randhir and behave in a certain way, but she didn't behave how we expected. That is the cause of the disappointment I guess. Till now we haven't really given too much thought into Sanyu's flaws as much as we have discussed Randhir's. We always only compared them with each other, but now since we have another standard (read Parth) to compare Sanyu against, her flaws have started becoming more apparent and that I guess we didn't really expect.
But as @ilovepyaar has said, this story is about two equally imperfect people, and I guess it was needed to emphasize on Sanyu's insensitivity right now.

It was nice to read your perspective. Thanks for sharing.😊
Edited by miss_bennet - 12 years ago
relentless. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
nice post buddy! :)

See in my opinion, Randhir & Sanyukta have the exact same personalities. They are two side of one coin..If randhir yells at her for absolutely no reason, Sanyukta isn't any better either. Randhir taunts her that she's a girl, a good for nothing who should just sit and home and get married, so much that he even taunted her about not getting the internship at her dad's company. And obviously no human being is going to take that lightly, yet Sanyukta didn't react back at time, but in a way she has very indrectly..Although she's hurt him in the past unknowingly..

angel.thomas thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
After today's episode even i thot that Sanyukta is merely being a spoilt brat...but maybe she was right in her place.😕
relentless. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: angel.thomas

After today's episode even i thot that Sanyukta is merely being a spoilt brat...but maybe she was right in her place.😕



She's right and wrong 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".