ButterflyChaser thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
In this forum we have both RagNa as well as RaKhi fans. So many ppl here think that RagNa would be too mainstream as it happens in every serial. Here, I just want to discuss the story scope of both RagNa and RakHi as neutral viewer.


As we all know, EMA is not a love story but it is about a domestic worker's dream... It's about Kamla who wants her daughter to achieve success in her life and become madam. So it's basically about Kalpi and her success.

If RagNa happens then the story can proceed in following manner

1. Raghav helping Kalpi in fighting against all problems and achieving her dreams..

2. Kalpi sacrificing her love for Pakhi/Kamla... Kamla realizing this n fights for Kalpi's love

3. Pakhi sacrificing her love for Kamla which results in Kalpi-Pakhi fshp and Kamla helping Pakhi to forget Raghav and start a new life.

4. Raghav helping Kalpi in getting her mom back.

In short, story will revolve around the main theme and lead Kamla.

If RaKhi happens then..

1. Raghav and Pakhi marrying each other. Family opposes but Pakhi never cared about family and they live happily ever after. No more story for them.

2. Kalpi sacrificing her love and as always Kamla can't do anything as it was one sided love.

Here, I don't feel much scope.. So, I request RaKhi fans to add.

P.S. : M RagNa fan but writing it as neutral viewer. As EMA viewer I find more scope for RagNa as compared to RaKhi.
Edited by fairylover - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.4k

Users

8

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

OmkaraKiParvati thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
i really appreciate ur POV... If u ask me, i cn also tel tht there more scope for RagNa than RaKhi. Pakhi's love is one-sided. Unless Raghav reciprocater tht love, they both cnt be happy. whereas if u take kalpi, i cn c Raghav's pain whn she is in pain. He loves her bt his past forbids his feelings frm flowing out. Snd kalpi thinks he is rude whch in reality he isn't. i just hope CV's read tis and giv us RagNa tht cn bring more ideas to the show... Am sorry RaKhi fans. Tis was my POV. My intention was nt to hurt any of ur feelings. If by mistake i've hurt any of ur feelings, thn am very sorry.
ArshiR thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
i would like to agree in ur Ragna 3rd part.Rakhi well i wnt evn mention abt 😊
i believe Ragna WILL happen since Pakhi is also aftr him i hope in future love-track episode Pakhi would sacrifice & give kalpi wat she deserves that way we can have a new Pakhi who wont luk selfish at all 😉
blackdollphin thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
...they live happily ever after.No more story for them..call me silly bt i was laughing reading this line... Even I find more scope for RagNa than Rakhi! See many of us are saying that it RagNa will b a typical rich man poor girl love story bt I think there is always a different way of presentation just like movies. That means even a love triangle can b shown nicely instead of giving it an OTT treatment. If it's RagNa, Pakhi's character should be shown getting mature, who understands one can't get everything he/she wants, and not as a typical hindi serials vamp.
And if it's Rakhi (which personally I don't want), Kalpi's character should be built up as strong independent & a sucessful winner which suits the storyline too, but then as u said there will be no more room for Rakhi story.
nandinidavid96 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Brilliant post...you have very well worded your points and of course story was, is and will be about Kalpana pursuing her dreams (indirectly her mother's life time goal)

Whether it is Raghav-Kalpi or Raghav-Pakhi, story will revolve around Raghav-Kalpi. Raghav will play catalyst for Kalpi in pursuing her dreams; indirectly mentor her in this journey. Kalpi will help him to overcome the fear of losing dear one's. (She herself is insecure about her mom, still she never severed her bond but only tried to fortify). Raghav-Kalpi pair is not a typical rich guy falling for poor girl story as some people are saying, though it will take a long time for love to happen, undoubtedly Kalpi holds a special place in his life other than being Kamala's daughter. As of now love is last thing in their minds. This may not be exciting for all, but this is what excites TRP audience with teeny bits of romance

Coming to Pakhi-Raghav, there is nothing in the story even if her family disagrees their love did she ever acknowledged them that she will do now?? Her character doesn't have any scope to expand than turning her into negative (which I hate) as she is already grey. She has everything on plate and the entire world's time to run behind a guy with no specific goals to achieve. I think Raghav will knowingly ignore her advances and when she realizes something between R-K her selfishness will surface. She'll learn in a hard way that you can't get everything you want in the life


P.S. Sorry guys this has become irritatingly long

Edited by nandinidavid96 - 11 years ago
suhani.rahman thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
👏 well done dear..Wat i can say there are sureky more ragna scope and ofcourse we ragna fans want ragna to happen.no rakhi as couple only bhai behen ka bandhan..
BettyC thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
i have diff opinion...see if Raghav end up with kalpi whats left she is already a memsaab nd kamla no more a baai kissa katam there is no struggle nothing ...evn if kalpi achieve smething it will b all bcoz of raghav baba nd kamla doesnt evn come in d picture...it will b too boring to watch serious nd boring kalpi with boring kadoos raghav lol my pov...if its pakhi there is kapoor vs singania nd internal struggle for raghav falling in love with daughter of his fathers murderers...if its shown as good love triangle then anyday i will prefer rakhi over kalpi lol
ButterflyChaser thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: veeranu

i really appreciate ur POV... If u ask me, i cn also tel tht there more scope for RagNa than RaKhi. Pakhi's love is one-sided. Unless Raghav reciprocater tht love, they both cnt be happy. whereas if u take kalpi, i cn c Raghav's pain whn she is in pain. He loves her bt his past forbids his feelings frm flowing out. Snd kalpi thinks he is rude whch in reality he isn't. i just hope CV's read tis and giv us RagNa tht cn bring more ideas to the show... Am sorry RaKhi fans. Tis was my POV. My intention was nt to hurt any of ur feelings. If by mistake i've hurt any of ur feelings, thn am very sorry.


@bold : Same here. The chawl scene where he saw her crying clearly depicts that he has strong emotions for Kalpi. He can feel her pain.
ButterflyChaser thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ArshiR

i would like to agree in ur Ragna 3rd part.Rakhi well i wnt evn mention abt 😊
i believe Ragna WILL happen since Pakhi is also aftr him i hope in future love-track episode Pakhi would sacrifice & give kalpi wat she deserves that way we can have a new Pakhi who wont luk selfish at all 😉



Pakhi will sacrifice for sure. As she has already said that she can sacrifice anything for Kamla maa. Kamla will make her understand.
ButterflyChaser thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: blackdollphin

...they live happily ever after.No more story for them..call me silly bt i was laughing reading this line... Even I find more scope for RagNa than Rakhi! See many of us are saying that it RagNa will b a typical rich man poor girl love story bt I think there is always a different way of presentation just like movies. That means even a love triangle can b shown nicely instead of giving it an OTT treatment. If it's RagNa, Pakhi's character should be shown getting mature, who understands one can't get everything he/she wants, and not as a typical hindi serials vamp.
And if it's Rakhi (which personally I don't want), Kalpi's character should be built up as strong independent & a sucessful winner which suits the storyline too, but then as u said there will be no more room for Rakhi story.


Pakhi won't be a vamp as she has Kamla's sanskaar. She will be heartbroken and grey but won't turn completely negative. I would love to see separate love stories for both girls but if there is a love triangle then I hope it will be handled maturely and not in a typical OTT way.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".