DOTW: jal singng...jaan jaan hindustan - Page 2

Originally posted by: water11

Well no offense , but if they are praising India also then what is the problem 😲 ....if relations were not good that was not completely India's fault...i hope everyone knows the history........but frankly telling you after reading your comments i really felt bad.

I love being an Indian and also respect Pakistan as at the end of the day, Pakistan is a part of India...

Thanks Guys,...

Hey, it's absolutely NOTHING against India. Surely not. But what did aggrevate me was that they were blaming their ex-band-member for having sung a song in India [which was a great hit and a real nice song]. And now they're kinda changing a song meant for their country into a song for another country [and they totally ruined the song]. Doesn't matter whether India or any other country of the world. As I said, they can go ahead and make songs for India, I do not have ANY problems with that at all... but they should stop singing songs meant for Pakistan for other countries. A little patriotism would be nice. Besides that they were blaming Atif for something which they're actually doing themselves, and even worse. Atif just sang A song in India and they're changing a song for Pakistan into one for India.

Just imagine an Indian singer sang "Phir bhi Dil hai Pakistani" instead of Phir bhi dil hai Hindustani. Don't you associate this song with your country? That's why I think this is sick of Jal to do that.

PS: Pakistan is NOT a part of India, Pakistan and India are two different countries. Quid-e-Azam gave Muslims their own country called Pakistan. [Although there are also other religions practised in Pakistan].

OMG how could they....and i totallly agreee with scorpian and amy....guyzzz seriously....and as for water...buddy your talking form ur INdian POV......we werent even talking abt the song having anything to do with india or pak....wut every1 here is saying....why are they using a song tht is TOTALLLY dedicated to PAKISTAn...ONLY....im sure u wudn't like it if they changed lets say best devotional song into saying somethign good abt pakistan...would u like that?????this song have been the main theme for pakistan after its national anthem...every single person in pakistan knows it...and it had nothing to do with pak or india...its abt ppl trying to copy it and change into something totally diffferent just to get some fame...which im sure after this is unlikely to happen...jal seems to be VERY jealous of Atif....i mean did we object anything atif did in india...no..instead we liked it because it was brigning ppl 2gether in a way...

and as for u saying Pak IS a part of india...well letme rephrase it for U..pak WAS a part of india before August 1947..NOT ANYMORE.....and im sure u know ur history as well as we do ours...and i think in the other previous replies nobody even MENTIONED anytihgn abt india's relation with pak r whose fault it is...so plzzzz keep it ont he main topic which is copying th eother song....u took the wrong way....well lets keep it where it is now...and i hope jal will get some sense... 😊 peace out...

Originally posted by: anumra

OMG how could they....and i totallly agreee with scorpian and amy....guyzzz seriously....and as for water...buddy your talking form ur INdian POV......we werent even talking abt the song having anything to do with india or pak....wut every1 here is saying....why are they using a song tht is TOTALLLY dedicated to PAKISTAn...ONLY....im sure u wudn't like it if they changed lets say ur national anthom into saying somethign good abt pakistan...would u like that?????this song have been the main theme for pakistan after its national anthem...every single person in pakistan knows it...and it had nothing to do with pak or india...its abt ppl trying to copy it and change into something totally diffferent just to get some fame...which im sure after this is unlikely to happen...jal seems to be VERY jealous of Atif....i mean did we object anything atif did in india...no..instead we liked it because it was brigning ppl 2gether in a way...

and as for u saying Pak IS a part of india...well letme rephrase it for U..pak WAS a part of india before August 1947..NOT ANYMORE.....and im sure u know ur history as well as we do ours...and i think in the other previous replies nobody even MENTIONED anytihgn abt india's relation with pak r whose fault it is...so plzzzz keep it ont he main topic which is copying th eother song....u took the wrong way....well lets keep it where it is now...and i hope jal will get some sense... 😊 peace out...

Absolutey, yaar... VERY well said. But one thing... Pakistan was never a part of India. Before, there was a country which then was divided into two, namely Pakistan and India. So these are two different countries which came into being after one country was divided. 😉😉

Originally posted by: water11

Well no offense , but if they are praising India also then what is the problem 😲 ....if relations were not good that was not completely India's fault...i hope everyone knows the history........but frankly telling you after reading your comments i really felt bad.

I love being an Indian and also respect Pakistan as at the end of the day, Pakistan is a part of India...

Thanks Guys,...

sorry not agree with you... we are not part of india... we have our on independent country.. since 14th aug 1947.. o.k😊

OMG i love to see ur patriotism for Pak......thanx guyz......and thank God that Pakistan still have some true Pakiz......good to see that
and i hope jal main bhi yeh aqal ayey ...Amen 😃

yah wini im soo happpy toooo....but seriously some ppl juss come and think hey actually know wut they're talking abt but its always the wrong ht ing...i mean were we even talking abt anything between india or pak...all we were talking abt was the SONG....thata was it....but some1 took it the other way and that kinda made me mad..lolzz nywyazzzz as long as ppl like all of us...nothign can happen to pak...

Lolzz.... 😆

Thanks for your reply guys, but i was not trying to argue or create a fight on any point ...i was only asking what is bad if he is also praising India. 😕

I agree with the point that, the song was always a Pakistani song and there are emotions attached to it and you dont wanna share it, but you can't compare it to National Anthem...I hope everyone knows the difference between a song and National Anthem.

Anyways, there is no reason in arguing and yes even though since 1947 Pakistan is a separarte country, but if a child leaves his house and starts staying separate, parents still remain parents 😉, child can never say that they are not my parents as i dont live with them.

Roots can never change 👍🏼 , once again i dont want to hurt anyone's feelings...but would love to share my views.

Cheers 😊

Originally posted by: wini

OMG i love to see ur patriotism for Pak......thanx guyz......and thank God that Pakistan still have some true Pakiz......good to see that
and i hope jal main bhi yeh aqal ayey ...Amen 😃

ALLAH karey amin sum amin and also unko logon ko bhi.. those thinks that PAKISTAN is a part of india.. which is not..😃

Originally posted by: water11

Lolzz.... 😆

Thanks for your reply guys, but i was not trying to argue or create a fight on any point ...i was only asking what is bad if he is also praising India. 😕

I agree with the point that, the song was always a Pakistani song and there are emotions attached to it and you dont wanna share it, but you can't compare it to National Anthem...I hope everyone knows the difference between a song and National Anthem.

Anyways, there is no reason in arguing and yes even though since 1947 Pakistan is a separarte country, but if a child leaves his house and starts staying separate, parents still remain parents 😉, child can never say that they are not my parents as i dont live with them.

Roots can never change 👍🏼 , once again i dont want to hurt anyone's feelings...but would love to share my views.

Cheers 😊

😊😊

Hey... we ain't arguing, either... just explaining our point.

And hey, the example about parents and child doesn't really fit here. Let's take the example of Yugoslavia... it used to be one country and now it's all divided. People do not call it Yugoslavia anymore, neither do they say Croatia is a part of Serbia or so on. These are all different countries which came into being after one big was divided. So, Pakistan is not a part of India. If you want to look at it like that, one can also say India is a part of Pakistan, which is absolutely not true.

Hope you get it now. 😊😊

Besides that, it's all history and you shouldn't try to make us believe a thing which's your point of view only. So, you can believe whatever you like and we believe what we think is true.

Ok referring to comment by water...first of all u sed wuts wrong wid prasing India.....OF Course NOTHING AT ALL....we dunt even care if they take any song to praise India...but they CANNNOT take any devotional songs that are only for pakistan and change it into something abt Indiaa....thats one thing,,,,

the other thing u sed was the parent thing 😆 .....welll seems like ur forgetting the history here....Since when did India become the PARENT....and if im not mistaken India got to be its OWN country a day AFTER pakistan's birth.....and u guyz never even owned the country when pakistan came into being....the entire state was ruled by British nation....and when that rule broke up two countries were formed India and Pakistan...now i dont understand how did India became a parent to Pak...when it was never even part of it...wut the both countries were part of was the British Empire...oh and one more thning that Pakistan broke apart BEFORE india...so India never got a chance to declare Pakistan its own area....im sure tht clears things up here....

nd yah of course we dont mean to argue on anything as well,....nd im sure u wudn't liek Pak to have anything to do with any of your devotional songs because they're patriotism of a country and mean s a lot....i hope u understand.... 😃 lets be nice little friends...LOLZZZ....im suer its not a sin to be friends with some1 from India...LOLZZZ 😳