In the tussle between Siddhant and Sadiq

InsaneDivine thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Is it possible that Lala and his people might have not once but repeatedly given Sid wrong information about Peshawar attacks .. The terrorist groups often give limited access to internet to its followers and they can only access that much amount of information, as intended by the leaders of these groups.. May be the Quran also that was given to Sid was not the real Quran but a manipulated version of it by Lala..

While religion and the concept of Jannat can be used to brainwash the uneducated people like Yusuf, it cannot be used as a weapon to brainwash a person like Siddhant Thakur because he didn't believe in religion at first place.. So, may be Lala used humanity, his humanity.. He was a very soft hearted and compassionate human being, we all would agree to..

Death always bring sorrow and pain with it... But we tend to feel more shattered when a child dies than when an adult dies.. May be because children are more fragile and innocent.. And in case of a person like Siddhant, its quite a possibility that he became completely broke down. With Hussain a part of Siddhant died too.

He said he is not doing it only for Hussain but also for Rohan who gets afraid on hearing about the attack on school.. According to him Thadani and Govind Mehta were responsible for the attacks.. He did not want unnecessary bloodshed but only to a point till his demands were getting fulfilled.. In his viewpoint he was saving kids like Hussain and Rohan being attacked in future ... The life of people captured in the hospital mattered because a part of Siddhant was still there in him but it did not matter more than his maqsad, the maqsad of preventing kids from becoming a prey in the hands of Thaddani's hunger of money and power ( of course, in his POV which was certainly not the reality ).. In the continuous tussle between Siddhant Thakur and Sadiq, Siddhant Thakur lost... 😭

However, that still remains a question as to why he did not try to gain information post his return to India.. May be he had lost all his sanity by then.. I feel compassion, which is a very beautiful quality in normal human beings, in Siddhant's case, this trait was played by Lala, fueled by wrong information and his spirit to die without flinching for the good of the people was given an absolutely wrong direction... So in his POV, he was still dying for humanity but it was actually not humanity..

I don't know what I have written makes any sense or not 😆 , but since things have been left for us to interpret, this is what I ended up concluding based on what little that was shown.. 😈

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

891

Users

2

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
The problem is writers have left too many loose ends and unanswered questions when it comes to Sid's character
Those questions should have been answered coz they were necessary to help us understand Sid's motive , his perspective and story arc
They were needed to give a proper and sensible closure to the character.

We all understood one thing that what he was doing was not for any nation but for Humanity
He wanted to punish Thadani and Govind as he thought that they were responsible for Peshawar school attacks
This much was clear

But now comes the CONTRADICTION ! Which the writers never explained !

Why he wanted to release Mullah Peer...writers should have given Sid's reasoning behind it...as Sid said that he was not anti India but pro humanity then why ask for a terrorist's release who must have killed many such Hussains and Rohans !

Why keep the civilians as hostages...did he only want to held them hostage and not harm them ? Coz Ibrahim eas speaking to the terrorist in hospital but lied when Sid enquired about it !
He looked worried and shocked when he heard the news of gun firing and then he kept talking to someone on phone
Why ? Whom he was talking to ? Why Ibrahim lied ?
Writers should have cleared this up


This would have helped us to get a better understanding of Sid's character and his motives.

These questions are not some symbolism which could have been left for the viewers to interpret...these are real , logical questions which were important to justify and explain the character of Sid
And that is why I am disppointed with the writers

InsaneDivine thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
hummm... Tomorrow is the last day ..

Lets see what they show..

Perhaps some incomplete flashbacks.. 😆 😆
anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: .Fragrance.

hummm... Tomorrow is the last day ..

Lets see what they show..

Perhaps some incomplete flashbacks.. 😆 😆


Ya not holding onto hope now...after the raita the writers failaod
We will see those fbs which we have already seen
Sid is not alive so who is going to explain his perspective...Vikram can only assume but he can't know the real story
My only worry is that they don't assacinate the character rather than explaining his perspective
That is what m worried about the most.
Nothing Goood is expected of these writers anyways..I just hope they don't make matters worse
InsaneDivine thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: anshvi


Ya not holding onto hope now...after the raita the writers failaod
We will see those fbs which we have already seen
Sid is not alive so who is going to explain his perspective...Vikram can only assume but he can't know the real story
My only worry is that they don't assacinate the character rather than explaining his perspective
That is what m worried about the most.
Nothing Goood is expected of these writers anyways..I just hope they don't make matters worse


If they wish they can tell.. I mean most of Sid's we have seen in flashback only.. Adding a bit more to what remained unsaid can be done.. Just to tell what actually happened with Sid..

However, yes the chances are almost nil.. :(


Edited by .Fragrance. - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".