Why I can never forgive Mr.S

Nomatter even if all the civilians come out alive from the hospital, Mr.S had hurt them badly. Why? Because the panic and fears and anxieties of witnessing or being victimized of an attack like this is not small. It takes months to become normal and years to forget it. I am not saying this aise hi. I am saying this because I have gone through this. I was in Taj Hotel on 26th when the attack took place. I was hiding for 2 days. I got rescued on the 28th. It took me 6 months to actually go out alone and roam. It took me 6 months to smile properly. And till date if anyone mentions about that hotel/Gateway of India /That attack I become terrified. Anyhow coming back to Mr.S he is torturing and killing civilians mentally and emotionally nomatter what the reason were. I cannot forgive him ever...

And THAT'S EXACTLY where lies my entire issue too with Siddhant...

The creatives reasoning for transforming sid to sadiq is unconvincing . That is where the entire problem lies . Even if sid wanted to do anything for greater good as he says it , he has risked innocent ppl . Their can't be any justification for that .

Correct !
Even if nobody dies in the end, the trauma those people went through can never be justified.
All this greater good is nonsense. The same way Dumbledore-Gridelwald's "greater good" was!

I soo agree. I don't think this type of a stunt will be entertained anywhere in today's world - however 'noble' one's intentions are. That blast in the hospital may not have killed people b ut in such situations there are chances of people getting maimed or injured for life. How is this justified?

Originally posted by: Aahana-

I soo agree. I don't think this type of a stunt will be entertained anywhere in today's world - however 'noble' one's intentions are. That blast in the hospital may not have killed people b ut in such situations there are chances of people getting maimed or injured for life. How is this justified?

There are a lot of other ways to teach the establishment a lesson than indulging in all this madness. If he is so sure of the role of India's top people in the Peshawar attacks, he should have gathered evidence while in Pakistan and later exposed it to the world and taken them to the court.

Right now, with all this tamasha he has already become a criminal. Holding an elected government official hostage in this manner would be considered waging war against the country, plus wrongful confinement, destruction of property and so many other charges will be put on this madman if he survives.

Its better if he dies. Surviving means life time imprisonment in either case (whether he is Sadiq or Siddhant).
Because even if he is Siddhant and all this has some hidden agenda, he still should to be punished. The path he has chosen is so so wrong.

They have stumbled so badly that no matter which route they take, Mr S's characterization will anyway remain unconvincing..

Originally posted by: .Fragrance.

They have stumbled so badly that no matter which route they take, Mr S's characterization will anyway remain unconvincing..

The fear of being held captive, the fear of getting killed nytime, any moment is very clearly visible through the eyes of Naaz... The actress has portrayed it significantly... They are not mentally and physically prepared for the trauma Sid is making them go through... No reason can be so great enough to justify this action of Sid...

And if the have turned a person like Siddhant Thakur into terrorist, for the great love of Lala, then I don't know if I can tell any difference between

A wise and a fool,

A human and demon,

A lover and a hater,

A knowledgeable and an illiterate,

A learned and ignorant,

A protector and a destroyer...

🥺

Either ways the story has failed in becoming an impactful story, at least in my opinion.. 😒 Yes Imaan and Vikram have managed to remain respectful, interesting and my favorite characters till the end , but story as a whole got lost somewhere in the world of absurdity and confusion just before reaching the climax..

PS :- I hope u are doing good in life now... 😳

I would say u r brave... to share what u went through and conquer on those difficulties is a big step..so proud to hv u here n got an opportunity to interact with u..

Originally posted by: memad

I would say u r brave... to share what u went through and conquer on those difficulties is a big step..so proud to hv u here n got an opportunity to interact with u..